Committee representing members of the People's Parliament elected in the 1990 multi-party general elections

(Committee representing the People's Parliament)

 

Notification No 24 ( 4/99) (translation)

 

 

The matters below are concerns of the people which must be dealt with by the People's Parliament composed of the peoples' representatives. As the  Parliament has not come into existence, the Committee representing the People's Parliament is issuing this notification.

 

1. It is estimated that in the year 2000 AD, the population of Burma will reach 60 million. We read in the newspapers that the State Peace and Development Council has plans for self-sufficiency in food and for the  development of the rural areas and the improvement of living conditions for  the cultivators. Those are

 

(a) To cultivate 14 million acres of paddy in the rainy season and 4  million acres in the dry season with production of 100 baskets per acre.

 

(b) Increase agricultural land as suitable for appropriate crops.

 

(c) Produce sufficient eating oil for home consumption by

(1) Sesamum crop production to be 15 baskets per acre

(2) Increase cultivation of variety of pulses in the Irrawaddy Division.

(3) Increase coconut oil production in the Tannessarim Division.

 

(d) Increase rubber cultivation in the Tannessarim Division.

 

(e) Increase livestock and fisheries.

 

2. 

 

(a) For the purpose of expanding paddy cultivation and output especially and the other crops shown above, it will be necessary to find and develop  thousands of acres of virgin lands, fallow lands, "deep water fields" etc. It has been stated that in the process, there should be no infringement on the rights of the present holders or lessees or licensees of the lands.  The area that they hold should not be included in this record.

 

(b) The authorities have also stated that permits will be issued to enable sufficient eatable oil.

 

3.

 

(a) Our information is that implementation of these projects have been  entrusted to national entrepreneurs. The authorities look upon them as  "comrades". These private entrepreneurs have had the following advantages:-

(1) They have flourished because of previous contracts for many different

businesses, especially construction work.

(2) Large profits have accumulated to them from import and export trade and

they are the nouveau riche.

 

(b) The list of the entrepreneurs given projects are mentioned in the  Appendix.

 

 

4. Our information is that following special privileges will be granted to  those who undertake cultivation of 5000 and above acres.

 

(a) Thirty years lease. (A 28 year old person will be reaching the age of  50 in that time). This will enable control of the next generation.

 

(b) They will be permitted to export half the crop produced and the other  half to be sold within the country.

 

(c) Exemption from taxes and duties for machinery, insecticides,  fertilizers imported for the purpose of their cultivation.

 

(d) The authorities undertake to assist their "comrades" by building roads and bridges to their business sites. Also facilities for telegraphic  communications will be provided at the expense of the authorities. Also, they undertake to dig wells at no expense to the private entrepreneurs.

 

(e) Loans to the "comrades" will be granted.

 

5.

 

(a) Factors that are relevant to low lying lands where there are "deep water fields" need to be elaborated. Rice is the most important crop in Burma for sociopolitical stability and trade. Therefore we should seriously consider what the implications are in the cultivation of rice in what is known as "deep water fields" and virgin soil.

 

(b) Broadly speaking, in the regions referred to as "deep water fields"  there are

(1) Some areas, though covered with water can be cultivated.

(2)Areas overgrown with imperata cylindrica thatch (a kind of grass used as roofing material), Kine (reed of the saccharum species), etc.

(3)Areas overgrown with Sauk (euonymus javanicus), trees used for firewood.

(4)Natural ponds or lakes or creeks where fishing by means of putting up

weirs etc. is carried out.

 

(c) Our information is that the private entrepreneurs intend to implement their projects in the areas above in the following ways:

(1) Take over the lands from the present owners and occupiers

(2) Take over the lands overgrown with Kine and the lakes and ponds, which

are the public property of the people.

(3) Take over lands that are ownerless.

 

(d) People inhabiting land near these low-lying regions depend on the  thatch for their roofs, the firewood plants for fuel, and the natural ponds  for fish. In areas that can be cultivated, they work indefatigably to grow paddy.

 

(e) If "deep water fields" are taken over for the cultivation of paddy  those people living in the neighbouring regions will lose all the rights  that have accrued to them as set out in (d) above.

 

(f) If these low lying regions are taken over, the cultivators will be left landless, the thatch and firewood choppers and the fishermen will lose their means of livelihood. We wish to point out here that under the colonial system, labourers were brought in from a foreign land to cultivate the fields and so were chettyars (money lenders). Because of unfavourable climatic conditions, exorbitant profit making by the chettyars, unfair price fixing without taking into account agricultural output and consumer goods, the landowning farmers position was reduced to that of landless labourers (coolies). When the world was hit by a depression Burmese farmers revolted.

 

(g) Labour is needed to grow paddy in these flood lands. Our information is that labourers, cultivators in the region, daily wage earners, and townspeople will be recruited by force to move into the "Labour Villages" to be used to implement the project. This is bound to result in social problems. Townspeople cannot cope with the work of growing paddy and they will be deprived of the facilities and living standards, which they are used to.

 

(h) The heavy rains and excess water from other sources collect and flood the deep water fields which facilitates the cultivation of paddy. This is a natural phenomenon that occurred from the time Burma appeared on the face of the earth. To convert these flood lands into agricultural fields will amount to destruction of the environment. Destruction of the natural environment has negative consequences in the economics and social life of the people. This could lead to political problems. Diverting the excess water to other regions could effect regional temperatures. Floods will

occur in what was originally dry land. We need to be aware of the environmental conditions of the region - the land, water, wind, climate, vegetation, animals, birds and fishes and all the creatures that exist in the region and try to preserve them.

 

 

6. The mainstay of Burma's political, economic and social life is agriculture and the main crop is paddy. For this reason, the development, expansion and growth of this subject has always been an important concern. The prospect of developing the wetlands has been studied before. It is not a new idea. A project was developed in 1963, during the Burmese Socialist Program Party (BSPP) era, involving the wetlands in the co-operative villages of Amaya, Sipin, Khintangyi and Kamakalic in Pegu District and the Irrawaddy delta regions of Shwelaung and Pyapon townships. Money was

borrowed from the World Bank to implement Paddy One and Paddy Two projects in new locations, but the result was poor and not worthwhile.

 

7. Factors prevailing in the post 1988 period relevant to agriculture will be presented below.

 

(a) (1) The system of cultivation approved by the authorities is known as Thi-sa-cha (rent one's land for cultivation on yearly basic.). On the average an individual cultivator can have only about 3 to 5 acres.

(2) The system of renting land to the cultivators yearly is exercised with excessive authority. Whether the yield is good or bad, they are expected to supply certain fixed amounts to the government, civil servants, for charity, for the defense forces. They are forced to supply altogether about 12 to 14 baskets at a price that is less than one half of the current market price. The simple-minded cultivators are terrified and are compelled to sell their belongings to meet the demands made by the authorities. If they do not comply with the demands of the authorities, they are repeatedly harassed in many different ways and permission to cultivate the land is withdrawn with tragic consequences for the entire family. There is no longer any incentive for the farmer and though there is

a desire and urge to work on the land, circumstances and the environment are most distressing which has resulted in a big drop in the quality and quantity of agricultural products. Production is not of export standard so exports have dropped. Burma rice doesn't get a mention in world catalogues.

(3) Another cause in falling output is the refusal by the authorities for permission to purchase adequate fertilizers.

(4) Forcing cultivation of a summer crop of rice in regions where water cannot be obtained; forcing the cultivation of pulses in regions that are not suitable have reduced the physical stamina of the cultivator and his farm animals and caused great losses in capital investments.

(5) Village and hamlet dwellers are forced to give a variety of "voluntary" (without payment) service to the authorities. They have to neglect their duties on their own land and plough and cultivate crops on Defense Services agricultural land and clear jungles and virgin lands for them without any payment. At times they are forced to relocate to other regions leaving behind the crops and lands that have been cultivated allegedly because of insurgent activity.

(6) To put it briefly, because of the unchangeable village and hamlet administrative system and the wrong trading and commercial processes, the present day hamlet and village dweller is faced with a cruel and ruthless predicament.

 

8.

 

(a) Because of the above factors, the paddy and agricultural products have fallen in output and grade. To increase production it is necessary to improve the living conditions of the cultivator. He should be given the same treatment as the private entrepreneur in the respective regions. The Thi-sa (renting land for cultivation) system should be abolished. They system of "voluntary" forced labour must be abolished. Purchase of adequate fertilizers must be permitted. Scientific methods of cultivation should be taught and good quality seeds should be found.

 

(b) It is estimated that 31 million acres of land is cultivated in Burma  of which 16 million acres is for cultivation of rice. The first priority is to upgrade the quality and increase the quantity of crops cultivated on these lands. The cultivators and farmers should be given the right to store or sell (in and outside the country) their produce and operate in an open market mode. They should be granted loans on reasonable terms and operate their business without let or hindrance. They need incentives. By nature, man desires freedom. Compulsion is detested. The same terms and conditions granted to private entrepreneurs should be granted to the cultivators for the cultivation of the 31 million acres shown above and the 16 million acres for the paddy crop.

 

9. For the cultivation of the 31 million acres, cultivators and farmers have not been granted any kind of incentive nor have there been any form of subsidy which are important features of a market economy, but we hear that with surreptitious under-the-counter tactics hand-picked private entrepreneurs have been offered a variety of favourable terms and conditions to cultivate many many acres of these lands. Agriculture is a vital concern of the nation and policies and decisions on the subject should be openly discussed. Land which is a country's greatest asset must be utilised as effectively as possible and to that end there should be proper assessment of not only the quality of land and its suitability for the purpose it is used but the ability, knowledge and capability of the

managers needs to be thoroughly scrutinized.

 

10. In paragraph 2 above we have stated that the private entrepreneurs should not attempt to acquire the lands of present owners of land and should not include such lands in their records. One situation that is worse. in such projects for conversion of unoccupied, virgin and wet lands, is a case where lakes and wet lands that are being utilised by the cultivators have been given over to the private entrepreneur.

 

11.

 

(a) Information received is that in Minhla Township, Pegu Division, about 20000 acres of paddy fields and fisheries from seventeen villages of the eastern zone cultivated and operated by cultivators from generation to generation was taken over and given to the private enterprise known as Thein Shwe Company. These people are now left without land and work and have suffered great losses. Their status has been reduced to that of coolies and there is no other means of livelihood for them.

 

(b) It has been reported that with the cooperation of the Irrigation Department, the owner of that business is digging waterways and building damns at the inns (lakes used for fisheries) The people living in the locality have fears that land that was previously not prone to flooding in the rains will now suffer floods.

 

 

12. We have heard that the banks are giving the private entrepreneurs loans as required. There are fears that strict banking practices may not be adhered to and special privileges and exemptions may be granted. If this happens, Burma's banking system and financial standing will suffer.

 

13. The authorities are proclaiming that "xxxxx Only when thousands of acres of land is cultivated by privately owned modernised business enterprises, agriculture will flourish and the lives of the cultivators dwelling in villages and hamlets will accordingly advance." It is clearly a generalization of the agricultural system without any precise and defining meaning.

 

14.

(a) To flourish and develop the villages and hamlets assistance should be given to our current cultivators. For example, increase the acreage that they can cultivate, supply them with the required fertilizers, assist them to meet the expenditure incurred in the process of cultivation and develop flood prevention strategies. There is special need for good seed species and agricultural knowledge. In addition, the cultivators should be taught the principles of market economy with the right to export. Full incentives should be given to motivate them in the business of  agriculture.

(b) Successful development of rural areas has been accomplished in some under-developed countries because the rulers and international organisations that have been established for that purpose have cooperated. Peasants and farmers have been motivated and given certain incentives like land, house, water, food, agricultural implements and other facilities like schools, roads, water connections etc.

 

15.

 

(a) No matter who does the planting, if fertilizers are inadequate, if good quality and good species is not produced, inferior rice and inferior paddy cannot be exported. The export market requires a standard equal to that of other countries. Capacity to compete in the production rate, the grinding and milling are factors in the export market.

 

(b) Our understanding is that the private enterprises will be permitted to export 50% of their yield and the remaining 50% sold internally. If this is the case, it is possible that the private enterprises (with capital for investment) will purchase paddy from the other ordinary cultivators. In such instances it is important that they should pay the market price and measures be put in place to prevent unjust demands for lower prices.

 

(c) An important point is that the authorities should be realistic and not indulge in whims and fancies in this project of giving land for cultivation to private enterprise.

 

 

16. Information received is that in Nyaungdon Township, Dah-ka village region an owner of a private enterprise has been given "deep water fields" to cultivate. He in turn has rented out up to120 acres to each of the cultivators and farmers. The cultivators have to buy machinery, fertiliser, diesel oil and other necessary equipment from the private enterprise. Money required for the operation can be borrowed from the enterprise owner. From the yield, 10 baskets have to go to the authorities, and the balance must be sold to the owner of the enterprise at the market price less Kyats

10,000/-. This kind of exploitation should not be allowed.

 

17. No matter what, the actions of the State Peace and Development Council has greatly reduced the opportunity for prosperity and social well-being of the people. They have caused the peasants and farmers to become landless. They have lost the fisheries and the thatch etc. and are now unemployed. The poor have become poorer and a middle class can disappear with only two classes remaining - the rich and the poor. Because of what is being done by the authorities, an imbalance is created which will have an effect in our dealings with the rest of the world.

 

18.

 

(a) Rice is an important factor in the sociopolitical life and the economy of Burma.

 

(b) This operation impacts on the cultivators which is the largest group living in Burma. This is a sphere that concerns the entire country and only the people who have been elected by the people to represent them in a parliament can deal with this issue in a democratic way where fairness and justice will be applied. The representatives of the people must deliberate this issue in the People's Parliament and lay down an appropriate policy.

 

Committee representing the People's Parliament

Rangoon

23 April 1999.

 

(Responsibility for distribution and publication is taken by the NLD).

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

(Appendix)

 

Schedule showing names of private enterprise, region, township and acreage of grants for cultivation of uncultivated, virgin and wet lands up to 14 January 1999

 

Company/Org                          Sub-township              Township        Granted Acrage

 

Magwe Division 198,400

 

1. Asia World                         HtaeBoGan                  Salin                10,000

 

2. Dagon International             YayBokeGyi                Pwintbyu         36,000

 

3. Myanmar Billion Group      MyoZaBo                    Minbu              29,000

 

4. Yuzana                                KyeeGan                     Minbu/             30,000

 

 

KanToke Minhla

 

5. Service International           Ngaphae/                     Salin                40,000

 

6. Shwe Family                       KoeBin                        Sinbaungwae   10,000

 

7. SHweThaZin Syndicate       TharZi                         SInbaungwae   20,000

 

8. Olympic                              AKaeRiz                     Sinbaungwae   5,000

 

9. AungHteinMin                     YayDwinGaung           Taungdwingyi/ 7,000

 

 

ShwePanDaw Aunglan

 

10. small companies                                                                            11,400

 

Rangoon Division 28,580

 

11. Interior Ministry                SinGyan                       Tikegyi            2,000

 

12. Rangoon Municipal                                               Tikegyi            1,500

 

13. Dagon Agriculture             Htantabin/Teikgyi                                18,000

 

14. Golden Plough                   SinGyan                       Tikegyi            2,080

 

15. Steel Stone Agriculture     Hmawbi/                     Tikegyi/           5,000

 

 

Htantabin Irrawaddy Division 244,343

 

16. SI Limited                         Nyaungdon/                 Danubyu          30,000

 

17. Yuzana                              MoeGokeDiDoke (South) Pantanaw   20,380

 

 

AhYwaeJin Pantanaw 1,500

 

18. Olympic                            MoGokeDiDoke (North) Pantanaw/Einmae/ 10,650

Danabyu 10,000

 

19. small companies 171,813                                                              TOTAL 471,323

 

Source: Myanmar Alin (10-2-99)