JUNE 2001, VOL. 12.
XXXxxx<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<o0XxxX0o>>>>>>>>>>>>>>xxxXXX
Contents:
1. EDITORIAL COMMENT
2. DOZENS FEARED KILLED IN
3. FLASH FLOOD DERAILS
MANDALAY-MYITKYINA TRAIN, DEAD, INJURED UNKNOWN
Radio
4. DAM COLLAPSED, CAUSED BY
HEAVY RAIN AND FLOOD
Tin
5. MORE INPUTS ARE NEEDED TO
POWER A HYDRO FUTURE
By Win
6. FIX ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE,
OFFICIAL TELLS CONFERENCE
The
7.
CREATING A STIR WITH 3 BILLION YEN-- AID TO
8. FOREIGN MINISTER TANAKA IS
CAUTIOUS ON BALUCHAUNG REPAIR
PD Burma Japan, [abridged],
9.
10. CONTROVERSIAL MON STATE DAM
FINALLY COMMISSIONED.
XXXxxx<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<o0XxxX0o>>>>>>>>>>>>>>xxxXXX
Exceptionally
heavy rains in May and June have reportedly lead to the collapse of at least
one of the more than 121 rapidly constructed dams and weirs the SPDC claims to
have made since 1988, and may have caused weakening or near collapse of others,
leading officials to release devastatingly large amounts of water quickly to
prevent even more catastrophic collapse.
It
is quite possible that what has been reported is the tip of a giant iceberg. A
source from
Other
dams have failed in
There
are many questions to be answered in regard to the safety of the dams and the
numerous problems they cause. How many of the dams made in the time of the SPDC
/ SLORC have actually broken? How many people have died as a result?
How many of the remaining dams are structurally unsound and likely to break in
future floods or earthquakes? What plans have been made, or are being made, and
what steps will be taken to warn people of the dangers to avert loss of life in
the future? These are just some of the
many questions regarding the dams that we would like answers to but which will
probably never be answered.
It
is certain that there are many gruesome and worrying truths to be revealed when
it comes to the dams the SPDC is so proud to have overseen the construction of.
It is to be hoped that careful and timely inspection and repair of the existing
dams be carried out before another disaster occurs. It is equally certain that
this should be done before any other ill-conceived and poorly executed projects
are commissioned into service.
XXXxxx<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<o0XxxX0o>>>>>>>>>>>>>>xxxXXX
2.
DOZENS FEARED KILLED IN
Reuters: June 8
The
water level at Montine Dam, 350 miles (560 km) north
of
``People
were caught by surprise,'' one district resident told Reuters by telephone.
``They did not have time to prepare anything when their villages were inundated
by the flash floods.''
A
senior official from the Ministry of Agriculture and Irrigation told Reuters lives were lost and property damaged but he declined
to give details.
The
official said the dam's overflow had run into the neighbouring
``The
water level at the Montine Dam suddenly rose because
of the torrential rain and it overflowed the service spillway around midnight
on June 2,'' said the official, who declined to be identified. He did not
elaborate.
Witnesses
in the area said dozens of people had been killed and many were still missing.
Last week at least 12 people were killed in
northern
The
early rainy season has seen unusually heavy downpours in
XXXxxx<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<o0XxxX0o>>>>>>>>>>>>>>xxxXXX
3.
FLASH FLOOD DERAILS MANDALAY-MYITKYINA
TRAIN, DEAD, INJURED UNKNOWN
The
41-UP Mandalay-Myitkyina passenger train of Myanmar
Railways under the Ministry of Rail Transportation departed Mandalay Railway
Station at 2100 on 31 May. At about 0410 today while the train was crossing
XXXxxx<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<o0XxxX0o>>>>>>>>>>>>>>xxxXXX
4. DAM COLLAPSED, CAUSED BY HEAVY RAIN AND FLOOD
One
of the irrigation dams located at the middle of
But
the government news agency did not confirm yet the occurrence and the number of
death. It is also reported that the
surrounding places, especially
This
is the second tragedy occurred within a week in
XXXxxx<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<o0XxxX0o>>>>>>>>>>>>>>xxxXXX
5.
MORE INPUTS ARE NEEDED TO POWER A HYDRO
FUTURE
THE
hydroelectric industry is "in need of inputs like development machinery,
human resources and financial resources including hard currency" to realise more than 10 planned projects aimed at generating
an additional 2000 megawatt over the next five years, according to Myanma Electric Power Enterprise (MEPE) deputy chief
engineer U Win Kyaw.
|
Sr.
No. |
Power
Plant |
Location |
Capacity
(MW) |
Energy
(GWh) |
|
|
1 |
Thaphanseik |
Sagaing |
30 |
117 |
|
|
2 |
Paunglaung |
|
280 |
911 |
|
|
3 |
Mone-chaung |
Chin |
75 |
330 |
|
|
4 |
Yeywa |
|
700 |
3316 |
|
|
5 |
Kunchaung |
Bago |
60 |
190 |
|
|
6 |
Yenwe |
Bago |
25 |
123 |
|
|
7 |
Khabaung |
Bago |
30 |
125 |
|
|
8 |
Phyuchaung |
Bago |
65 |
260 |
|
|
9 |
Shwekyin |
Bago |
120 |
400 |
|
|
10 |
Bawgata |
Bago |
160 |
500 |
|
|
11 |
Thaukyekhat |
Kayin |
150 |
780 |
|
|
12 |
Shweli |
Northern
Shan |
300 |
2090 |
|
|
MW
= Megawatt. |
GWh = Gigawatt-hour |
||||
For
the time being, there are seven hydropower stations supplying power for both domestic
and industrial use. Out of the 870 MW in supply, 327 MW is hydropower and the
rest is of power generation by gas, oil and coal combined.
Hydropower
supply depends on the availability of rainfall. The plants currently generating
hydropower are Beluchaung-1 and -2, Kintar, Sedawgyi, Zawgyi-1 and -2, and Zaungtu.
Although
the electricity tariff is metered at different rates for different consumption
categories – K0.5 per kilo watt hour (kWh), K10/kWh and K25/kWh – the average
payment to MEPE is at K5.5/kWh. "If we increase the present tariff rate,
there will be other side-effects like that the prices of consumer goods will rise because of a conditional increment in their production
costs," he said.
The
electric power sector is the most highly subsidised
of all those supported by the government, including the telecom sector. But the
need in the industry now is for finance and expertise. The supply and
installation of machinery is the most expensive overhead in the development of
a new plant – on average US$0.5m to $0.8m to generate one MW. It is perhaps for
that reason that in
At
present, financial contributions to power projects comes in the form of aid
grants and soft loans from countries like
In
a case such as that of the Yeywa plant in Mandalay division, which has the capacity to
generate 700 MW, such developments as construction of access roads and
preparation of tender documents – to involve the private sector in the supply
of required materials and equipment – have
been undertaken in consultation with a European firm [emphasis added – SW].
In
the distribution of power, there are some technical losses from the grid. There
are several mitigating factors in this regard, including the size and length of
transmission lines. Apart from such technical loss, there exist non-technical
losses related to human error and opportunism, as is experienced in other
developing countries; incorrect reading of units consumed and the illegal
sourcing of electricity direct from transmission lines. In
According
to a paper prepared by a Japanese expert, who declined to be named, issues
facing the sector included generation capacity, circuits in main high voltage
transmission lines and distribution facilities in urban areas. The development
issues to be addressed, according to the paper, included the limited
availability of capital funds, the financial viability of foreign investments,
poor access and security constraints, and agreements on the use of water
resources.
XXXxxx<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<o0XxxX0o>>>>>>>>>>>>>>xxxXXX
The
And
he said that power consumers would be willing to pay more to have access to
improved electricity supplies. Electricity tariffs here fall into a number of
different categories: general residential consumers; government organizations,
public servants and pensioners; and commercial and industrial consumers. But
half of the total electricity supplied annually is used by consumers who use no
more than 200 kW per hour per month and who therefore are entitled to pay at a
rate of 0.5kyat per kW. A survey conducted by a local market research group,
the results of which were discussed at the seminar, found that consumers would
be willing to pay an unregulated market price for uninterrupted power supplies.
"0.5 kyat per kWh is very low," Mr Kazuo
said. "The rate should be consistent with the willingness of consumers to
pay, if the power supply is reliable and continuous."
But
a government official, Dr Thein Tun, said the
existing policy was that the affordability of power for consumers should be a
key consideration in calculating charges. And he suggested that infrastructural
problems were more deserving of attention. "As the distribution facilities
are very old, one-third of the total power generated is wasted due to technical
loss," Dr Thein Tun said. "And frequent
power outage is weakening the country's economic activities." It is
important to upgrade the present distribution lines, and to extend the grids to
connect cross-border grids of neighbouring countries.
To
cope with very low electrification rates in rural areas, the Department of
Electric Power and MEPE have installed diesel power generators in remote
countryside. As of this year, a total of 224 sets of generators have been
installed in 161 villages with a total capacity of 8.367 MW. At present, 63 per
cent of the electricity supply is coming from gas based generation followed by
21.27 per cent from Hydro, 14.49 per cent from thermal and 1.24 per cent from
diesel. Even though
The
total energy consumption during 1988-89 in
One
breakthrough in the government's policy has been the granting of allowance for
multinational companies to explore and produce petroleum in the country, on a
production share basis with the Myanmar Oil and Gas Enterprise (MOGE).
Currently both onshore and offshore contracts are active, with results in
discoveries of new oil and gas reserves. They include, onshore, Aphyauk Gas Field, Kyaukkwet Oil
Field and Nyaungdon Gas Field and, offshore, Yadana, Sein and Padamya Gas
Fields and the Yetagun Gas Field. "
XXXxxx<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<o0XxxX0o>>>>>>>>>>>>>>xxxXXX
Japan sunshine policy to
promote talks: US/EU due to human rights
concerns, ill-timed
Asahi Shinbun (
[Unofficial Translation
from Japanese original]
The
aid
In
April,
A
MOFA official said, we are aware that there are
differing opinions in the international community, but in order to promote the
talks,
Since
the political changes in 1988,
It
appears that Japanese aid, which comprises 60% of the aid
Regarding
the scale and delicate timing of this controversial aid from
Associate
Professor Kei Nemoto of Tokyo University of Foreign
Studies points out that if
XXXxxx<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<o0XxxX0o>>>>>>>>>>>>>>xxxXXX
8. FOREIGN MINISTER TANAKA IS CAUTIOUS ON BALUCHAUNG REPAIR
PD Burma
In
a reply to Diet member Mizuho Fukushima (Social Democratic Party) at the
session of the House of Councilors legal affairs committee on June 11, Foreign
Minister Makiko Tanaka showed a cautious posture with respect to grant aid for
the controversial Baluchaung hydroelectric power station.
Tanaka
responded that the Japanese government is trying to help basic life of Burmese
people directly, but she recognizing what
XXXxxx<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<o0XxxX0o>>>>>>>>>>>>>>xxxXXX
9.
Jiji Press (
It
is revealed on 4th April that the Japanese government is to provide aid for
repairing an old power plant in
[Translator's
Note: The plant mentioned here is the Baluchaung hydroelectric power
plants in
The
Japan Times covered the issue on
developments in
Jiji's report shows that Japanese government has
stepped up its procedure to the aid. It is said that Ministry of Foreign
Affairs is also deeply involved in the decision making process.
The
issue once appeared four months ago on Sankei Shimbun,
a Japanese rightist opinion paper. It reported on 18th December that JICA
(Japanese International Cooperation Agency; a governmental aid agency) sent an
inquiry mission to
The
mission report urged the necessity of emergency repair works, and if not, it
said "the power plants will not work properly in the near future."
in
Interestingly,
Sankei reported that the repair project was estimated by the
Sankei,
well known as its extremely hostile attitude to
It's
not sure if
involvement in
The
Sankei's article ended with nationalistic antagonism against
Anyway,
it is clear that Japanese government is heading for the first fresh aid to the
junta since 1998. At that time, they justified the aid for upgrading the runway
at
Now
Japanese government uses the same maneuver as in 1998. It calls the aid for Baluchaung repairing project as a 'humanitarian' aid, and
also says that the aid will stimulate a move for "political dialogue"
between NLD and SPDC, whose exact content is still unpublicized. Nobody knows
where the "dialogue" goes, so the international community watches the
current situation with cautious optimism, for example EU still holds the
sanction policy. ILO sanction is still on because of SPDC's
complete failure to tackle forced labor problems. In
addition, there're still a lot of problems in the border area, number of
refugees and IDPs has increased to fleeing from SPDC's offensive against
ethnic forces, killing, rape, forced labor, forced
relocation, or other serious human rights abuses.
Considering
these problems, it is hardly impossible to say that SPDC is heading for true
national reconciliation. It is policies and concrete activities of the junta
that make 'humanitarian' assistance necessary to the people inside and outside
(By
Tetsu Hakoda)
XXXxxx<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<o0XxxX0o>>>>>>>>>>>>>>xxxXXX
10.
CONTROVERSIAL MON STATE DAM FINALLY
COMMISSIONED
Based
on news from New Light of Myanmar and Independent Mon News Agency:
MAWLAMYAING
- A controversy-plagued dam, whose inauguration was twice postponed for
security reasons, was finally commissioned into operation in southern Mudon township last Saturday by
the military council's Gen Khin Nyunt.
An
earlier opening scheduled for March 14 had to be postponed, a Mon news agency
reported this week, after a guerrilla force of the Karen National Liberation
Army staged a lightning raid against the facility on the night of Mar 5-6. During the attack several
In
an interview at the time, Padoh Mahn
Sha of the Karen National Union claimed that nine
hundred labourers in a nearby construction camp, who
had been forced to work on the facility, had been released during the operation
and that the engineer in charge of the project, U Tin Lwin,
had been captured and was being held for exchange purposes.
Last
year, the Mon Human Rights Committee reported that 2,000 acres of land used for
rubber tree plantations by farmers from three nearby villages had been
confiscated without compensation during preparations for the construction. Farmers who lost their income had been forced
to migrate to
The
opening ceremony on May 26 was marked by the first public appearance of the new
commander of the Southeast Military Command, Brig-Gen Myint Swe. It only occurred after a second postponement
from May 15 for "security reasons" , the
IMNA reported. The Mon news agency said that villagers who were unable to
attend the grand opening had been fined from 100-500 kyats
for missing the occasion. The IMNA cited
the example of the headman from Kao Payan who had
been forced to sign a contract guaranteeing the attendance of three hundred
persons from his village.
In
his speech at the inauguration ceremony, Lt-Gen Khin Nyunt told the crowd of
16,000 that Senior General Than Shwe
had given guidance to the nation that arrangements were to be made for
"value-added water and land".
He said that in building dams such as Winphanon
the government was aiming "to benefit the local people without taking
economic profits into account" and reminded them that the value of land in
the area of the dam was already rising. The general also warned the people to
"safeguard" the new structure.
Water
from reservoir behind the 178 foot-high earthen dam will be used irrigate
13,000 acres of farm land.
XXXxxx<<<<<<<<<<<<<< -- ENDS --
>>>>>>>>>>>>>xxxXXX