Brief Assessment of the
Health Situation in Mon Areas
31 October 2003
Brief on the current public health
situation in Mon State
Ministry of Health and
National Health Committee of Union of Myanmar, has planned to
promote public health in the country and it is now campaniging
widely in the community for a better health in nation wide. Ministry
of Health has also implemented to State and Local Health Department
to foster the campaign and service of public health. The military
government has drawn a health project from 2001-2006. According
Health Report from Mon State, despite the military government has
developed a health project since 2001, there is no sufficient
improvement for the public health. The report said that health
budget allocation is lacking from the government to the previous
years. The Health Department could not employ sufficient health
workers and medical doctors. Moreover, according to a doctor from
one Township, the military government also could not pay regular
salary to health empoyees. Despite the military government has
received aid from overseas, the resources did not place to the
public hospitals. Furthermore, the military government has built
road construction and school buildings for the sole purpose of
remaining in power with the community support but a health service
is ignored by the Burmese military officials. The regime in Rangoon,
State Peace and Development Council (SPDC), allocates less than 10%
of State Budget for the Ministries of Health and Education. In the
recent years, WHO also found the health care situation in Burma is
worth if compared with many other countries in the world.
I.
A. Current services and condition of public hospitals
Althought
the sussesive governments have operated Local Health and Medical
Clinic in rural areas, the current military government could not
provide or re-fill full medical equipment and other medical goods
including medicines. The worse situation that almost all hospitals
in Mon State could not use 24 hours electricity. Some hospitals pay
an electricity bill to local private generators for emergency
service. Most hospital only receive electricity up to 9:00 pm if
they pay to private generators. A few hospitals have their own
generators that were donated by individuals but the generators could
not run for 24 hours as the raising patrol price.
According a township local doctor, a particular patient must pay for
the cost of the electricity bill if he/she had received emergency
operation. Consequently, most poor people do not dare to visit
hospital unless they felt serious pain.
I. B. Who
and how the private clinics work?
Doctors who have
employment from the public hospitals could open Private Clinic. Most
patients now increaselly visit to the Private Clinic than public
hospitals. A basic cost in the Private Clinic is at least Kyat
800-1000.00 for caughing. (Kyat 1000.00 is about 1 US Dollar and the
daily income for a woman in Burma is only about Kyat 500.00. -
Editor’s Note). Ordinary people mostly have no knowledge about
health and medication but they eagerly listen to the doctors and
easily accept for injection or medication. Therefore, doctors again
mostly could not visit regularly to the public hospial while they
earn more money at their own clinic. A few doctors also provide beds
and accommodation to over night for patients with extra charge.
There are a few private clinics such as “Zar Ni Aung, Taw
Win”, “Zar Ni Phwe”, “A One” and
“Popular” where patients pay highly expensive for a
treatment. These clinics are stationed in Moulmein, the capital city
of Mon State.
I. C. Prescription under
corruption
The Ministry of Health is unable to
provide sufficient medicines to the public hospitals. A local doctor
said, despite the hospital staff is advised by personals from
Non-Government Organizations (NGOs) that assistance will be arrived
shortly after the meeting, in reality there is no source of
assistances has been reached to them. The Ministry of Health has
allocated medicines for one year ration but it is only last for one
month, local doctors confirmed. According to a doctor from Mothers
and Children Welfare Hospital, aspirin amd tablets are not enough in
the public hospitals. Management Board of the public hospitals have
bought medicine from private phamacy stores and re-sale them to
in-patients for own benefit under the name of “Staff Saving
Program” or other unofficial program for extra money in the
hospitals. According to a return patient from the hospital, the
price of medicine in the hospital is more expensive than at private
phamacy stores. Furthermore, only person who holds doctor’s
prescription is able to buy medicines at out door phamacy stores.
Ordinary citizens are not given Blood Test unless they paid
for a service fee to the hospitals, a local patient said. Socially,
doctors and nurses are not properly deal or communicate with both in
and out patients, a return-patient said. Patients are forcefully
paid for unofficial loan or contribution on their arrival for
registration before they could have a bed. There were a signboard
that said “Free Treatment” in the hospital in the past
but now the signboard has gone from the public’s eye.
I.
D. Women and the problems in child delivery
Officially,
only Kyat 2500.00 is charged to “Give Birth” for
mothernity but the actual cost is over Kyat 10000.00, a local
patient confirmed. According a nurse from Mothers and Children
Welfare Association, an official government body from Mudon, eight
out of ten patients visit to local health clinic or traditional
treatment because most poor people could not afford the cost in
hospitals.
Due to the expensive cost in hospital, most poor
rural women could not afford to pay for all costs of
hospitalization. Therefore, most women in the rural villages deliver
babies by traditional birth attendents in their villages. This also
created high rate of death among women and new born babies. On the
other hand, due to the difficulties in traveling and carrying the
pregnant women, most women in the rural areas have no choice, but
they have to deliver their babies in village by traditional birth
attendents.
I. E. Phamacy stores and its
prices
Almost ordinary citizens especially poor
people can afford to use medicines (traditional medicines) from the
street shops. The worse scenario is that majority street shop owners
do not have knowledge about medication and health. (They even do not
hold a registration or a licence for selling medicines). Moreover,
various kind of traditional drugs (tablets) are available at the
street shops including at street stalls . Many traditional drugs
have no legal trade – mark or technical laboratory in medical
sciences schools. Ordinary citizens did not aware of an ingredience
of traditional drug and its consequences as
its contain over limited raw materials. Despite traditional drugs
relief a short period of pain but in fact its could not terminate
the root of disease.
According a patient, “we cannot
afford to buy medicines in hospitals and its also too expensive for
us, so we just use traditional drug becuase its have similar
effectiveness.” This is the root cause of the problems why
many patients do not go to the hospital if their health situation
not so serious. The patients went to the hopitals when they found
they are too serious.
General public did not aware that lack
of manutrition is a basic source for receiving diseases. They also
have no health education and information by the Ministry of Health
on regular base. As they learned nothing about health education, on
the other hand they could not prevent temsleves to various kinds of
diseases.
II. Symptoms
of diseases
Most serious diesaess that found in Mon
State are:
1. Haemorrhage dengue fever
2. Malaria
3.
tuberculosis
4. AIDS/HIV
5. Cholera
6. Diabettes
7.
Hypertension
8. Skin Disease (leprosy)
9. Enteric fever
(Typhoid)
II. A. Haemorrhage dengue fever
The
heamorrgage dengue fever usually occurs in May and June each year
during heavy raining season when mosquito bite to people, commonly in
rural areas. When people have suffered this fever, they mostly could
not have regular meal but often vomitting with blood. This fever
easily could effect to other surrounding people and sometimes it also
suddendly die in a short time. Especially, new born children may
suffer until they reach at the age of 16.
People who lives in
Rangoon Division has suffered than other places in 2002. According to
Health Report released by Ministry of Health in 2001, there were 3422
patients who suffered this fever and killed 57 patients. The second
area that people commonly have suffered this fever is in Moulmein,
capital city of Mon State, the report said. It is a consequence of
lack of public health education campaign and insufficient medicine in
hospitals. Some parents cannot afford for emergency treatment when
their children have suffered haemorrhage fever.
Case
Study: Child died for late treatment
An eight months
old child of Mr Nai Tin and Mrs Mi Tin Myaing from Kan-nee village in
Kawkareik Township, Karen State has suffered heamorrgage fever (when
date or month). They brought the child to Kyone-doe District Hospital
at 3:00 am in the morning. The child was crying as she suffered a
serious pain in her body. When Dr Tin Win saw the child was crying
and said with a patronizing voice “can’t you bare the
baby at home just for crying”. The doctor just yelled to the
child’s parents. The doctor then gave only two paracetamal to
relief a pain. The child parents then arranged to receive treatment
at Moulmein General Hospital but it was late and the child died
before arriving to hospital.
According to nurse from Mothers
and Children Welfare Hospital, the heamorrgage dengue fever is a
serious disease but they cannot knock every doors
each home to educate public for prevention. They can only visit
schools and provided information to students for prevention with a
few poster and leaflets.
II. B. Malaria
Malaria
is similar to heammorrgage dengus fever when it occurs after mosquito
bited to people. The malaria is commonly appear in tropical zones. It
could spread the disease from one to one after the same mosquito has
bitten to the later. The malaria is similar to heammorrgage fever
that could kill patients in a short time. Southrn part of Mon State
is a common area that malaria disease is appeared.
Health
Department of New Mon State Party also takes a serious measure to
prevent malaria for local people under its controlled areas along the
border area with Thailannd. Most eastern part of Burma bordering with
Thailand is in malaria zone, most health departments of resistance
ethnic armed groups involved in preventing the malaria. Normally, the
displaced families (because of fighting and fleeing from various
types of human rights violations by the Burmese Army)have greatly
suffered from this celebral malaria and children died becasue of it.
Resistance armed groups also formed ‘Back-Packed’ medical
teams and tried to prevent malaria and other diseases that happen
among the displaced persons.
Doctors and medical workers in
cities and villages in the firm control of the regime have less
knowledge in treating the malaria and so that some malaria patients
died even in the town or city hospitals.
II. C.
Tuberculosis (TB)
According a statistic in Mon State
in 2001,the number of TB patients in different categories are as
below:
Number of Patients Categories
1180 pateint with
phlegm virus
148 returned patient with phlegm virus
605
tuberculosis patient without phlegm virus
100 over normal
tuberculosis patient
This statistic is only applied those
patients who have registered in hospitals. It is to be believed that
there are other TB patients who have not been to the hospitals or
have not registered for treatment to the hospital. Most patients in
Burma have addicted on injection than taking tablets for basic
treatment because they believe that injection is a better treatment.
On the other hand, doctors are usually give injection to patients for
extra cash income. As many patients are poor and the treatment cost
is high, many patients could not take regular medicine for over two
years and they have frequently stoped before the end of treatment
schedule. Consequently, a few patinets die for lack of medicine and
proper health check.
III. D. HIV / AIDS
The
Burmese military government has verbally said there is only a few HIV
/ AIDS patients in the country but no official or accurate
information is aceesssable for health record. After the Burmese army
confiscated lands of farmers, hundreads of thousands people from Mon
State have no land to work but left to Thailand for employment. There
are girls and women who were forced to work as sex workers without
their consent. A few men and women returned home country with HIV/
AIDS deases to Mon State without their own knowledge. Most partners
do not / did not tell about their HIV / AIDS experiment to each other
after they have knows the sympton.
According a Karen woman at
Women Workshop, she just heard of here saying that ‘AIDS’
word but she doesn’t know what it means or what disease.
AIDS/HIV Education provided by some international NGOs have not so
effective and they just put the posters in the corners of the cities.
They have not really entered into the communities and arranged
workshop or discussion with the people.
A doctor from Mudon
Township (in Mon State), despite the government attempt to tackle for
health education campaign in the country, the message does not reach
to rural areas especially in ethnic areas.
(WCRP is still
collecting information for other types of diseases to describe in its
future publications - Editor.)
III. Conclusion:
Women and
Child Rights Project (WCRP) is an independent program that runs under
the program of Human Rights Foundation of Monland. As we provided
accurary information in this report, a further assesment is needed to
be done in another years while we are seeking to develop women and
child health in the community. It is our great concerns in regards to
women and children’s health in the community as the information
has shown that the Burmese military government failed to tackle a
basic healt care to its citizens. Furthermore, after over fifty years
civil war in Mon and Karen States, ordinary citizens have no place to
find proper medical and health care in the last half century. After
ceasefire process between the Burmese Army and Mon National
Liberation Army, an armed force of the New Mon State Party reached in
1995, we have a little access to engage with community. Overall, as
both national and international aid agencies are interested in
engaging with local community works in Burma, we have determined to
closely wotk with regional and international community agencies for a
better future of women and children. As we are an emerging
organization in Burma, a cooperation with other agencies is crucial
to tackle women and children health and welfare in the future.
“The Plight of Women and Children in
Burma” (Issue No.3/2003) - Women and Child Rights Project
(Southern Burma)
http://www.rehmonnya.org/wcrp_report.php?category=wcrpreport