Eye-witness
Accounts
Note: Names
and specific places have been held back or changed where necessary to protect
the victims, their families or information sources; but the names mentioned in their
stories are real. While a some events occurred in 1993 or earlier, they were
first able to be recorded in 1994 and, in any event, these accounts have a
direct bearing on the overall situation of HRV in 1994, in that identical
violations continue to occur regardless of the year or SLORC claims. Therefore
these events were included.
The following
keywords describing human rights violations (HRV) have been used for
cross-referencing; interview numbers are referred to in the chapter texts.
|
Assembly |
Freedom of assembly and
association |
|
Child |
Rights of the child |
|
Detention |
Arbitrary detention and
enforced or involuntary disappearances |
|
Displacement |
Internally displaced
persons |
|
Execution |
Extra-judicial, summary
or arbitrary executions |
|
Forced Labour |
Forced labour and
slavery |
|
Livelihood |
Rights of livelihood
(i.e. pillaging, extortion) |
|
Minorities |
Protection of minorities |
|
Misc |
Miscellaneous |
|
Movement |
Freedom of movement |
|
Opinion |
Freedom of opinion and expression
|
|
Refugees |
Situation of refugees |
|
Religion |
Freedom of belief |
|
Relocation |
Forced relocation |
|
Repatriation |
Forced repatriation |
|
Slavery |
Forced labour and
slavery (i.e. portering) |
|
Torture |
Torture and other cruel,
inhuman, degrading treatment or punishment |
|
Women |
Discrimination against
women |
Interview: 1 HRV: Detention, Displacement, Livelihood,
Refugees, Relocation, Slavery
Name: Nai Win Nai
Sex: Male
Age: 42
Ethnicity: Mon
Religion: Buddhist
Family: Married
with 7 children (age 3 to 20)
Address: Pa
Interviewed: 5-7 August
1994
[Nai Win Nai
was taken as a human shield by the troops on the way from Plat Hon Pai to Halockhani.]
I
left my village almost 20 years ago because I couldn't stand the oppression of
the government. They took porters. My father was making tobacco pipes for a
living. When they came to take porters he tried to run away, they shot him and he
died. That's why we left – we didn't want to stay there anymore. We went to
Three Pagodas Pass. On the Mon side of the border [
On
21 July we were preparing the Buddhist celebration for the full moon so we were
making various kinds of cakes to offer to the monks in the monastery. Then the
Burmese troops came. At first we weren't afraid – we thought they wouldn't make
any trouble so we stayed quiet. At first they stayed all around just outside
the village, but then they came in and went house to house arresting the men.
They arrested 47 men but no women. The troops ordered the men to go to Halockhani with them. It was
On
the way through the village we had to walk with one of us on the left and one
on the right of each soldier [not all the soldiers went to Halockhani.
Plat Hon Pai is narrow and about 1 km. long along a
wide pathway]. After that the path becomes narrow and we had to walk in single
file. They put eight refugees ahead of them as a cover, and these eight men ran
away. The soldiers were ordered to shoot them but they weren't hit because they
could hide behind the trees and rocks. The soldiers tried to run after them but
they got away to warn the people in Halockhani [the
path runs through thick jungle].
I
don't know where the Burmese soldiers met the Mon soldiers, I only heard some
shootings, then the Burmese soldiers shot back. I
don't know who shot first. When we heard the shootings we ran away. We ran
through the forest to a hill close to Plat Hon Pai,
and we could see the village. We saw the soldiers coming back to Plat Hon Pai. Some soldiers made the women leave the village and
didn't allow them to take anything from their houses. Then they burned the
houses. I saw it. First they looked inside and if they saw anything good they
took it, then they set all the houses in the whole village on fire. Some houses
only got partly burnt, and some burned until only the wooden posts were left.
[Actually some houses set apart from the rest of the village were not set on
fire.] We were afraid to go back so we slept on the hill. Then the next morning
we went to the monastery and found most of the women and children there. The
monastery was the only building the soldiers didn't burn. My wife and children
had slept there together with most of the women, some old men and one monk.
The
soldiers left a half hour after they had burned the houses. With them there
were some people whose hands tied up behind their backs with rope, and they had
to carry the soldiers' things walking in the middle of the column, one soldier
after each villager. Before they left, the Burmese soldiers told the women,
"Within three days, everybody has to leave this village.” They said if
they see anyone there after that, they would kill us. We fled and came here.
Sometimes we go back to our old village just to pick up some vegetables and
then come back. Our house was totally burned. We lost everything. The soldiers
stopped my wife from bringing anything with her.
When
we got here we had to make a shelter for the family, but we didn't finish the
first day so we just put some bamboo on the ground to sleep on. We only had
blankets for shelter, and it was raining. Five of our children were with us.
Two days later we got some shelter. Other people cared for us because we'd lost
everything. I hope we can stay here because we're afraid to go back to Plat Hon
Pai or Halockhani, but I
don't know if we'll be allowed to stay here. We're afraid because the Burmese
soldiers said they would come back after three days and kill anyone they see,
and I think they might do it. If we go back we'll have problems. I think they
attacked because they think Mon soldiers might pass through the camp sometimes.
I didn't see any Mon soldiers, but it's possible, so they don't want this camp
to be set up. In Plat Hon Pai they said, "All of
you can go stay at Three Pagodas Pass. We don't want to see you here anymore. " I think maybe they don't like it that we're in a
refugee camp. They want us to stay under their control.
Interview: 2 HRV: Refugees, Slavery, Torture
Name: Nai Tin Shwe
Sex: Male
Age: 18
Ethnicity: Mon
Religion: Buddhist
Family: Single;
Father, Nai Win Nai
(see related interview 1)
Address: Pa
Township,
Interviewed: 5-7 August
1994
[Nai Tin Shwe was taken as a
human shield along with his father (see above).]
I
was born in
When
the Burmese soldiers arrived at Plat Hon Pai they
went to see the section leader and he said to the villagers, "The Burmese
troops have come but there shouldn't be any problem, so don't run", so all
the people stayed quietly. The troops surrounded the village because they
didn't want anyone to run away, then they went to the houses one by one. They
didn't beat me but they beat and kicked some people because they didn't come
out quickly enough. I was in the street when the soldiers arrested me. A
soldier grabbed my hand and took me to the school. I saw my father there – he'd
been arrested at home. The soldiers took us with them towards Halockhani. On the way they kicked me because I wasn't
walking fast enough and I fell and hurt my knee. I was near my father, and when
we heard the shooting I ran away together with him, but other people further
back in the line didn't escape. They were forced to return to Plat Hon Pai with the soldiers.
Interview: 3 HRV: Livelihood, Slavery, Torture
Name: Nai San Lin
Sex: Male
Age: 20
Ethnicity: Mon
Religion: Buddhist
Family: Single;
eldest son of Nai Win Nai
(see related
interview 1)
Address: Pa
Interviewed: 5-7 August
1994
[Nai Son Lin was
conscripted as a porter, first to Halockhani and then
on the subsequent trip to Ye.]
The
soldiers arrived at Plat Hon Pai on 21 July at about
7:30 a.m. Burmese time. I was at home. When they arrived at
our house. 10 soldiers stayed there. They cooked and ate inside our
house. They ate all our rice and curry, and all the cakes we had prepared to
send to the monastery for the Buddhist festival. Then another group of soldiers
arrived and arrested my father and my uncle. They also took away my brother
from the house while he was on the way to see his friend. About five minutes
after they took away my father and uncle, the same group came back to arrest
me. They didn't say anything. First they pointed their guns at me and then
kicked me twice to frighten me. I was sitting down so they kicked me in the
back with their big boots and it hurt afterwards. Then they told me to go with
them so I went. My mother and some of my younger brothers and sisters were
there, but they didn't dare say anything because they were afraid.
They
took me to the school and on the way one soldier kicked me, put a gun in my
back and asked me about weapons in the village. I saw my father and brother at
the school just for a short time, then they took me with them to walk across the
village and then on towards Halockhani. The soldiers
had forced more than 100 people from
When
we got to the village they ordered me keep carrying the ammunition instead of
the porter from
We
left Plat Hon Pai about
The
day we left Plat Hon Pai we weren’t given any food –
not until the day after at
Interview: 4 HRV: Livelihood, Refugees, Relocation, Slavery,
Torture
Name: Nai Chan
Sex: Male
Age: 38
Ethnicity: Mon
Religion: Buddhist
Family: Married
with 1 child (age 5)
Address:
Interviewed: 5-7 August
1994
[Nai Chan is the section
leader of Plat Hon Pai section of Halockhani
Camp.]
I
used to live at Loh Loe.
I'd lived on the Thai side of the border for 20 years. Now I've been section
leader of Plat Hon Pai for four months. On 20 June at
They
arrived at about
It
was another group of soldiers who took the refugees to Halockhani.
We were still in that same house when they came back. I saw them carving one
wounded soldier. Then the soldiers guarding us told us to leave the house. Two
of us had to go handcuffed in front of them, and we were also tied with a rope.
There were soldiers behind us, then three more men with handcuffs also tied
with rope, then one man who wasn't tied up nor handcuffed and then more
soldiers. Six of us were taken together. I couldn't see who else was taken
behind us. When we got to the end of the village we saw a lot of smoke, and I
understood that they were burning the village.
We
were all forced to carry loads. I had to carry a bag that weighed more than 10
kg, a soldier's bag that probably had their clothes and things inside. After
the first day they made me carry two bags instead of one. The day after we left
Plat Hon Pai we met another group of porters. One
porter was a man from our village. When he came to get water for cooking we
talked to him and he said there were four Plat Hon Pai
villagers in his group. Then the soldiers started shouting at us because they
didn't want us to speak to each other in Mon, and he had to go back to his
group. The next day at
We
walked for four days, handcuffed all the time, even at night. We couldn't sleep
at night because it was always raining and we had no plastic sheet. We always
sat up all night, and we tried to sleep like that but we couldn't. We were
guarded all night. When we went to the toilet a soldier went with us, and we
were still handcuffed together. On the way we weren't beaten because our loads
weren't too heavy so we could walk easily. But when the porters with heavy
loads fell down, they were kicked and beaten. All the porters were from
There
was more fighting. The second time was in a Karen village called Kyat Thaing, but like the first time it was ahead of our group.
After the fighting, the soldiers entered the village and burned two houses. The
soldiers didn't say anything, just set them on fire. I saw them throwing a
child out of a house like you would throw your things, and then burning the
house. We were with IB 62. They were on their way to Thanbyuzayat.
We had to walk with them all the way to IB 61 Headquarters in Ye Town, then we
slept there one night and they took the train back to Thanbyuzayat.
The soldiers took our handcuffs off, went to get on a truck and left us in the
camp. While the soldiers were busy, we walked away. I don't know if they were
releasing us or not, we just walked away. Six of us left the camp together and
started walking. Two people went other places, then on the second day the other
three people went another way, and I finally arrived back on my own two days
ago. It was three days' walk, but I got stuck at Chaung
Zone for ten days because I couldn't cross the river. I built a bamboo bridge
together with the villagers there.
I
think the Burmese attacked Plat Hon Pai because they
wanted their gun back. The soldiers also told me that people couldn't stay
there any longer. They said, "If they want to stay they have to go the
Three Pagodas Pass. We don't want to see any buildings here." I don't know
why they also wanted to go to the main Halockhani
Camp. Maybe because it's part of the same camp. They
wanted to frighten the people. Now our situation is very difficult. We're very
afraid that the Thai authorities will push us back to Plat Hon Pai, but it's not safe. We hope we can stay here.
Interview: 5 HRV:
Livelihood, Refugees, Repatriation
Name: Nai Thein Dar
Sex: Male
Age: 41
Ethnicity: Mon
Religion: Buddhist
Family: Married
with 4 children (age 8 months to 12 yrs)
Address:
Interviewed: 5-7 August
1994
[Nai Thein
Daris camp secretary of Halockhani
refugee camp, which includes Plat Hon Pai.]
When
the troops came on 21 July, I was in Halockhani main
camp. After
Most
of the villagers went back but that day they heard about fighting nearby at Blad Ka Pow.
For a long time they heard the sound of guns, so then they ran away again to
here. The Thai BPP let them stay here, but later they said the attack was over
and told the refugees to go back. The camp leaders talked to the villagers but
they were afraid to go back. They refused.
On
25 July there was a meeting between the Thai authorities and the MNRC. The Thai
officials said that the refugees were not allowed to stay, so the MNRC talked to
the refugees to tell them. But the people refused to go back and asked to stay
on the Thai side. They said, "Even if they try to kill us we will
stay." They want to go back only when there will be peace in
After
the meeting there were many Thai soldiers here, and the Thais said everyone had
to go back on 27 July [1994]. The Thai police said it is impossible for us to
stay here because the situation here is difficult as there is no clean water
and diseases are spreading. They also said that SLORC IB 61 at
Here
the people have to stay in the rain with no proper roof, and they get malaria
more easily. The old people and children are having problems of malnutrition
because we're not allowed to grow vegetables and things here, and we have a
problem with diarrhoea because the water isn't clean. Some rice at Plat Hon Pai was burned with the village, and we don't have enough fishpaste and salt. The rice supply is still at Old Halockhani, and the chairman slept there every night to
look after it. The refugees had to go back to get their rations there every 15
days. [The site where the refugees now was at the time
of the interview, was extremely muddy, and they are all living through the
constant rains in small overcrowded shelters under plastic sheeting provided by
foreign NGOs. Disease and malnutrition are a serious problem; NGO workers at
the site say they have four times as many patients as before, but that it is
actually a healthier site than Old Halockhani on the
Some
of the people from Plat Hon Pai recovered a few of
their belongings but most of them lost everything. Here we've got plastic
sheeting, food, blankets, pots, plates and mosquito nets from NGOs, but 40
families don't have enough. For example, we could only give two plates and one
pot to each family. If the Thai authorities let us stay here it is a good
place. Old Halockhani is in a valley between
mountains which is too narrow, the water is bad and it is too close to SLORC,
only 2½ hours to Three Pagodas Pass. Here it is very good, more open and flat
and we can get good water.
As
for new arrivals three or four families just arrived from the Ye-Tavoy Railway and 6 or seven families who fled from being
taken as porters. Now there are 6,063 people in this camp, all on the Thai
side. Some people went back to Old Halockhani during
the day time to get vegetables from their garden, but they came back here at
night. Every Wednesday and Friday, the Thais bring 300 to 400 people from IDC
and leave them here. Every 25 IDC deportees chooses a
group leader and they get their rice and fishpaste
from the camp supply. Some stay in a shelter here or with other families, some
go back to
Interview: 6 HRV: Livelihood, Refugees, Slavery, Torture
Name: Nai Aung Nai
Sex: Male
Age: 55
Ethnicity: Mon
Religion: Buddhist
Family: Married
with 4 children (age 21 to 27)
Address: Ko
Interviewed: 5-7 August
1994
[Nai Aung Nai
was taken as a prisoner porter when the troops left Plat Hon Pai to go to Ye.]
I
was a farmer in my village, and we tried to work for ourselves. But it was
never for ourselves – we always had to give everything to the government. We
could only keep 25% of anything we grew or earned, and we often had to pay
porter fees or go as porters. So I left my village 6 years ago and went to Ba Leh Ngo, near Three Pagodas
Pass. Then I crossed into
I
walked with the soldiers for four day and five nights. I think they were going
to Ye. After one day they changed my pack for a heavier load. It didn't fit and
I couldn't carry it but the soldiers said "Go! Go!" and kicked me. My
load weighed about 30 kg. It was food, pots, plates and clothes for the
soldiers. We had to climb up many muddy mountains. I fell with my load and they
kicked me. Once I lost my shoe and they kicked me. I couldn't get it back. We got three mouthfuls of rice with fishpaste
to eat twice a day. At night if there was no rain we put some banana leaves on
the ground and slept. If it was raining, the soldiers gave one plastic sheet
for all 6 of us to sit under [these sheets are only big enough for one]. It was
raining a lot. I got a cold and later it got worse. I think I have a chest
infection. [Nai Aung Nai
was coughing badly throughout the interview.]
There
was fighting two times, but it was at the front and I was in the middle so I
couldn't see. After the second fighting, the soldiers burned two houses. They
also burned a house in another small village. In every village we passed they
were taking more people as porters. I escaped on the evening of the fifth day.
During the day while we were walking they untied us, then every evening they
tied up again. That night just before they tied us up, while they were busy I
ran away. I'm from Ye Township so I knew the area a bit. That night I slept in
the forest, then the next day I found a village and
came back with three of the villagers. It took me four or five days to get back
because I had no tools with me and I couldn't get across the river. Along the
way I didn’t meet any soldiers, but I found three dead bodies lying along the
path. I don't know who they were, but they were most likely porters. I arrived
here about three days ago and met my family. We went back to try to salvage
things from our house in Plat Hon Pai, but it had
been totally burned. My wife was left alone and so was my daughter. The
soldiers took away my son-in-law and he hasn't come back yet. I don't know why
they attacked Plat Hon Pai. I'm only a villager. I
helped at the monastery there. It's not so bad here, and we're too afraid to go
back there. The soldiers said they'll come back and shoot anyone on sight.
Interview: 7 HRV: Detention, Displacement, Livelihood, Slavery
Name: Mi
Mee Ong
Sex: Female
Age: 57
Ethnicity: Mon
Religion: Buddhist
Address: Ko
Kya In
Family: Married
with 7 children (age 16 to 37)
Interviewed: 5-7 August
1994
[Mi Mee Ong
watched the soldiers take away her son and burn down her house.]
I
left my village 15 years ago. First we went to
The
soldiers fired a gun and ordered everyone to come out of their houses. Then
they grabbed the villagers by their hands, took them to the road and made them
walk in front of them, firing their guns. They arrested many people. They had
villagers walk two-by-two, and behind every three or four people there was a
soldier, and they fired their guns. First they went to the school. After they
gathered many people, they left for Halockhani. There
was still a soldier in my house who stayed to cook and eat. He told me to stay
inside the house and not go outside. I stayed in the front of the house but I
couldn't see much. I saw porters underneath the houses of some people with
soldiers around them. The soldiers cooked the rice with the porters, then they gave them only a little rice to eat while all of
the soldiers ate together. The soldier stayed around my house for more than two
hours. I didn't hear the Halockhani fighting because
I'm a bit deaf. I just saw people running back from the fighting, so I went to
hide underneath another house.
When
the soldiers got back, they ordered the people to leave and burnt our houses.
First they searched the houses, then they put kerosene
on everything which burns – the leaves, the roof, the walls – everywhere. They
got the kerosene from our lamps. Then if they couldn’t get the house to burn,
they opened fire into the house to make sure that it set them on fire. There
were many soldiers in groups of four or six all burning houses. When they
finished one, they'd go to the next. First they forced us to leave the houses,
then they went inside and then they didn't leave until the house was burnt, so
I don't know what they stole when they went inside. I cried and pleaded with
them, "Please don't burn down my house!" but the soldier said,
"I have to do it. It is the order of our commander." When they left,
I went to my house while it was still burning and with a long bamboo I managed
to save a couple of plates and one basin. That's all I could save. Afterwards I
stayed near my house and I sat down. That night I slept close to my house on
the ground. Some people went to the monastery but others slept like me, on the
ground near their houses. I was so angry at the soldiers, and so depressed.
It's horrible, because they took my son and I also lost everything I had. I
gathered utensils and house equipment for many years and now I've lost it all.
My husband stayed by the house with me. He wasn't well. We got a plastic sheet
for cover. I hadn't eaten since that morning. I didn't think about coming to Halockhani at the time, I just felt lost. I couldn't sleep
that night, only sit there.
I
didn't feel safe. I was afraid the soldiers would come back. They said they
would come back in three days and that "If we see anyone around, next time
we'll bury you in fire." The next morning my daughter came and called me
to come here. My husband walked very slowly with the help of a stick, and our
youngest son came with us too. Now it's very hard to build another house,
because my son is gone and my husband is always sick. When we got here we
stayed in this shelter with four other families. Now, we are only two families in
this shelter. Two of the men built it. [Her shelter is about 3 x 6 m, 6 feet
high with a bamboo floor, plastic sheet roofing and no walls.] My son came
back, but now he's left again to make charcoal, get bamboo shoots, etc. He's
always working. They took him as a porter. He told me he has wounds, and even
now he still has pain in his chest. They only fed him a bit of rice with some
beans sometimes, and it smelled rotten. He escaped. He didn't tell me if they
beat him, but he said they threatened him with a knife. He probably didn't want
to tell me if they beat him, because he's worried his mother will be sad.
I
don't know why the Burmese attacked Plat Hon Pai. I
feel safer here. I'm afraid to go back, because the Burmese troops might come
back. I don't know if this place is really safe or not, but it's safer than
there.
Interview: 8 HRV: Forced Labour, Refugees, Slavery, Torture
Name: U
Mya Aung
Sex: Male
Age: 47
Ethnicity: Mon-Indian
Religion: Buddhist
Family: Divorced
with 2 daughters (age 10 to 15)
Occupation: Day labourer
Address: Ye
Township,
Interviewed: 5-7 August
1994
[U Mya Aung was taken as a porter in Ye, and was a
porter with the troops who attacked Halockhani.]
I am
a mixed blood between Mon and Indian. My grandfather was an Indian and my
grandmother was a Mon. When I was young, I was a Muslim, but now I don't have
any more religion. I'm Buddhist for now, because sometimes I go to the
monastery. I'm a daily labourer. Sometimes I sell things, like fish or
clothing. Sometimes I clean the compound for people who hire me, or go with a
fishing boat, or work making salt. Lately I was working clearing bushes and
grass for a rubber plantation owner. I was paid 50 Ks a day,
and they fed us and gave us cheroots. I gave as much of the money as I could
for my elder daughter's clothing and schooling. She's staying with other
people. I was staying at my friend's house. I usually ate at my workplace. One
night over a month ago when I came back to my friend's place he told me the
soldiers were looking for porters to go to Three Pagodas Pass. At
After
a few minutes at the office the soldiers' truck came over and they put us on
it, so we knew they were taking us as porters. They took us to IB 61
headquarters at the edge of Ye Town. They gathered porters from Ye and Azin there. They kept us in
the barracks for five days under guard. Even when we went to the toilets they
followed us with guns. They gave us rice and beans, but never enough. Sometimes
the soldiers' wives came around selling egg curry for 30 Ks. Then they took us
to IB 106 at Mao Ka Nin near La Mine, first by train
and then by truck. There were porters from La Mine, Po Taw and Taung Bo. We got to La Mine at 9 or
We
walked nine days on the way. The soldiers always said it wasn't much farther,
but we just kept on climbing up and down mountains and never saw any road. We
cooked and slept along the path. They just gave us rice with salt, sometimes
with a fingertip of fishpaste. It was terrible,
always undercooked or overcooked. They guarded us all the time. One night we
stayed in some abandoned houses, but every other night we had to cut banana
leaves to sleep on, and sleep on the ground just covered by plastic sheets that
we'd bought along the way. If someone didn't have a plastic sheet we shared
with him. It was raining all the time, and the path was very muddy. We had to
pull ourselves up to the mountains, and walk backwards going down. I fell with
my load at least 10 times a day, and more than that when it was raining. They
swore at me, and sometimes they kicked, beat or punched me. Two porters in
front of me were kicked all the way because they fell down all the time. They
looked so weak. Whether you were sick or not, you had to carry and follow. We
walked from
After
we reached
First
some soldiers went into the village to look, while we waited outside the village
for a long time. Finally they ordered us to go into the village and stay
underneath the houses, and they stayed all around us. There were 27 of us under
one house. They told us to cook, so we cooked. Then we heard gunshots. One of
the soldiers yelled, "Don't try to escape or I’ll shoot you dead!"
After the gunshots we ate, then we fell asleep for a
few minutes. They woke us up and we had to carry again. [This was when the
troops left Plat Hon Pai to go to Ye.] When we were
leaving we looked around and saw a lot of smoke. We started talking to each
other and the soldiers yelled at us: "Don't worry,
they're not your fathers-in-law's houses. Just keep carrying!"
We
followed the path to a river and slept the night there. The next morning they
made a bridge and we crossed. A soldier took my load across because he was
afraid I'd drop it in the river. We had to cross one-by-one. Then we started
climbing every steep mountain. It was very hard, and my shoulders were badly
wounded. I have so many scars all over my body. We didn't even notice when we
got a wound because they always yelled at us to hurry. We only had flip-flops
[loose, backless foam or rubber sandals] for our feet and we couldn't wear them
because it was always too slippery. Whenever a porter fell they kicked him and
beat him with their guns, and sometimes punched him. I fell once. and they kicked me and swore at me. Whenever porters were
going too slowly, they pushed them and said, "Go, go go!"
I started looking for a way to escape. I got a bit ahead of the soldiers and
when I looked back I couldn't see them, so I dropped my load and ran a few
yards into the forest. Then I saw a hole and hid. I hid there for one hour and
I was very afraid, then it was very quiet so I looked out and didn't see anybody.
I didn't know which way to go. I dared not go back to Plat Hon Pai because I didn't know if it was safe. My legs were in
such pain and I couldn't move fast. I found a hut where a couple were tending
their cows. Then I met two men and went with them to Plat Hon Pai. It was almost dark and we saw the monastery and asked
permission to sleep there. In the morning, they woke me and told me that I'd
better leave because the soldiers might come back. They gave me directions to Halockhani. On the way I saw that all the houses were
burnt, even the house I'd stayed underneath. Then I met two men who saw my
wounds and told me I should go to hospital in New Halockhani
to get treatment and some food. Finally I arrived here.
Now
I have scars all over my body, and my shoulders are badly bruised. After I
escaped I couldn't even lift my arms. When we were being held at Chaung Zone the others told me about three porters who'd
been left behind; two of them couldn't carry and one had twisted his knee. They
probably died, because there were no villages around. One of them was from
When
we came here with the soldiers we didn't know anything, we only knew we had to
face the fighting. When we left
Interview: 9 HRV: Livelihood, Refugees, Slavery, Torture
Name: Nai Win Tint
Sex: Male
Age: 31
Ethnicity: Mon
Religion: Buddhist
Family: Married
with 4 children (age 8 months to 12 yrs)
Address:
Interviewed: 5-7 August
1994
[Nai Win Tint was taken as a
prisoner/porter when the troops left Plat Hon Pai to
Ye.]
I
arrived in
They
took us to the school, and when we arrived they sent us two-by-two to see their
commander. They handcuffed four of us and called us to have our photo taken.
One of the four was the section leader. Then they started beating us. They
asked me if I had a gun. I told them I only had one that uses gunpowder [a
primitive flintlock used by hunters]. Then they said I was lying and beat me. I
told them, "I'm not lying. I don't have a gun. If you don't believe me,
ask the other. If I had one I'd give it to you. If I'm lying, you can kill
me." Then they kicked and beat us one by one. They put a knife on my
throat and pointed their guns. They asked, beat, then asked and beat. Five
soldiers were beating me. When they stopped, they put me in another room so I
couldn't talk to other villagers, then they started beating up the next person.
After he was beaten up they put him in the room where I was, one after another.
There were four of us. Afterwards, another three people arrived, and they beat
them as well. Other than the section leader, we were all just villagers.
I
was in the school when I heard the fighting near Halockhani.
The soldiers asked me if I was afraid, and I said yes because I was handcuffed.
When the other soldiers arrived back from Halockhani,
they told us to come out of the school. They prepared loads for us to carry, then we left. At the beginning, two of us were attached to
one pair of handcuffs. Then after we left the school each person had their own
handcuffs. Three of us in handcuffs were also tied with a rope attached to the
handcuffs, and the other three people were tied up with rope. My load was a
pack weighing about 15 kg. I don't know what was in it. Just after we left the
village, we saw the houses were burning. They started by burning the houses at
my end of the village.
I
think the soldiers were going to Ye. After two days I was separated from the
other Plat Hon Pai villagers and put with another
group that needed one more porter. Then I had to carry a heavy load of three
bags. I told the soldiers it was too heavy and I couldn't walk with handcuffs,
so they took the handcuffs off. They told me not to run away or they'd shoot
me. I was the only one from Plat Hon Pai in that
group and the others were behind us. We were only given a little rice and fishpaste to eat, and I had to sleep under the rain because
I had no plastic sheet. Along the way I saw them taking more porters. There was
fighting two days after we left Plat Hon Pai, and
then again on the fifth day. That's when I escaped. The soldiers all rushed to
the front and left the porters behind, so I ran away. I slept one night in the
forest, then I came back. I arrived in a village where
they'd heard that Plat Hon Pai had been burnt, and I
told them it was true. The headman said the troops had also taken one porter
from their village and he hadn't come back yet. They fed me and I slept there
for one night, then I walked here with two women. On the way we met a porter
who'd been left behind. His foot was badly wounded and he couldn't walk
anymore. He asked me to send him back to
In
Plat Hon Pai I saw that all the houses were burnt
down. Some were partly burnt, but my house was completely reduced to ashes. I
found two or three people in the monastery and they said everybody else had
come here, so I came here. I arrived four days ago. My wife managed to grab
some of our children's clothes while the house was already burning, but other
than that we've lost everything. I don't know why the Burmese attacked Plat Hon
Pai.
Interview: 10 HRV: Child, Displacement, Forced Labour, Livelihood, Refugeess, Torture
Name: Nai Kror
Sex: Male
Age: 29
Ethnicity: Mon
Religion: Buddhist
Address: Ye
Family: Married
with 2 children (age 2 and 5)
Interviewed: 5-7 August
1994
[Nai Kror
arrived in Halockhani recently after fleeing slave
labour on the Ye-Tavoy Railway.]
I
arrived in Halockhani from Ye-Tavoy
Railway about three months ago. Before I escaped I had to work there for two
months non-stop. Once I started, I never stopped. There were no rest days. I
had to work every day, and if I couldn't go for one day I had to pay 200 Ks.
First we had to cut down trees, clear the forest and scrub, then dig the ground
to level it, and we had to build shelters for ourselves to stay in. At first it
was close to my village, but then later it was farther away, close to other
villages. We couldn't go home at night. If I felt sick.
I had to ask authorisation to go home from the soldiers on guard, and then I
had to send another person to replace me. Once I was sick for seven days I
wanted to hire someone to go in my place, but I had no money so I had to send
my younger sister to replace me. I think I had malaria. I had to buy medicine
with my own money.
At
night we slept in small shelters of banana leaves that we made ourselves. They
didn't give us any food. I had to bring rice and fishpaste
from home. I brought enough for one month, then when
my food was nearly finished I asked permission from the soldiers to go back to
my village to bring more food. When we first went to the railway they told us
we'd have to work until it's finished. They didn't tell us how long that would
be. We had to work on three sections, from our village to three other villages
[there is a fork in the railway at his village, with one line coming into the
village and two lines going out in different direction]. While we were digging
the ground on the third section, there was a landslide and three men from my
village died. Their names were Soe Win, Chan Soi, and Hsa Aung, On the same section, a pregnant woman got diarrhoea or
dysentery and they didn't give her any medicine so she died. She looked about
28 or 29 years old. She wasn't from my village. When these people died the
soldiers made the villagers to take the bodies away.
There
are also children working on this railway – some are 10 or 15 years old. They
have to work the a man but they couldn't. Some
children got very serious sickness. One nearly died. His village was too far
away so he couldn’t go home. Some of his relative tried to treat him right
there. Sometimes the children didn't bring enough rice, and the soldiers
wouldn't give them any. Sometimes people who had money bought rice from the
soldiers when they ran out of food. The soldiers sell rice. We had to start
work at
There
are 550 houses in our village, divided into nine sections. At first, each
section had [to take] one [shift] and one person from every house [had to come
work] all the time. Then after 1½ months, they divided each section into half
and the halves had to rotate. After 15 days of that, I escaped. I just went
back to my village. First we sent our children to another village, then my wife and I went to join them. That was in May. It
was already raining. Just for awhile they stopped the work to let the people go
and plant rice because they're all farmers, but now they're back to work. Some
sections of the embankment are collapsing because of the rains and the people
have to go to repair it. In some places it's completely collapsed and they need
a lot of wood to repair it, so they demanded money for the wood from the
villagers. The poorest families have to pay 1,500 Ks, and others have to pay
2,000 to 5,000 Ks. I had to pay 1,400 Ks and my father had to pay 5,000 for
that. They're not laying any railway sleepers around there yet.
Before the railway. I had to go as a
porter, and I had to clear the compound at their camp, sometimes once a month,
sometimes twice. We had to pay them taxes for our own land, fields and gardens.
When the troops came to the village we had to give them rice and money for them
to buy their food. Sometimes they also took our pigs and chickens and ate
whatever they wanted. We also had to pay 4 tins of rice per year and 100 Ks per
family for their militia. SLORC set up their militia but didn't give them any
training. They made a draw and chose people from our village to be militia. No
one can refuse. They have to report to the SLORC headman everything that
happens.
When
I left my village I went to Pa Yaw refugee camp, but it was not so far from my
village and I was afraid of the Burmese troops, so I went to Loh Loe, but the Thais were
already destroying the houses there so I went to a Thai village and then
finally to Halockhani. We only brought one cooking
pot with us. With the children, it was too difficult to bring anything else. It
took us four days' walk to Pa Yaw Camp from the village, but the Burmese troops
could do it much faster. I didn't know Halockhani was
on the Burmese side of the border until after I got there, but by then I'd
already built my house. I wasn't in Halockhani when
the fighting happened because I'd gone to cut bamboo shoots. When I arrived
back the people were already fleeing, and my wife had already left. Now that
we're here on the Thai side it's not so bad but not so good either. I'm very
afraid to go back. Even here. I'm afraid. Even if the
Burmese troops don't come, they can fire artillery from
Interview: 11 HRV: Forced Labour,
Livelihood, Refugees, Torture
Name: Nai Win Aung
Sex: Male
Age: 27
Ethnicity: Mon
Religion: Christian
Family: Married with 1 child (age 2)
Occupation: Farmer
Address:
Tenasserim Division
Interviewed: late March 1994
I came here one
month ago with my family and six other families. We came because of our problems
with the railway. We were forced to work on the railway, we weren't paid and
they didn't give us any food so we couldn't provide for our family. Then if we
couldn't go for work we had to hire someone to go in our place. We also had to
pay porter fees all the time. Even when we were working at the railway our
families had to pay porter fees as well. It was very hard – we had to sell all
the rice we had saved and use the money we had saved to pay them. When this
wasn't enough we had to borrow money from someone and pay it back little by
little. We had to work for SLORC and pay porter fees to them until we nothing
left to eat. Now it is worse than ever before.
This year we had a very
bad harvest because the dam broke and flooded our fields. Then SLORC took part
of our crop, and we didn't have enough. We must sell 14 baskets of paddy per
acre to them at government price – if market price is 250 Ks for one basket,
then the government price is only 170 Ks. This year, we couldn't even sell them
the full quota they demanded. We had finished harvesting in December and were
preparing to plant other crops when SLORC came to get people for the railway. I
had to go three times, sometimes for one week and sometimes for 15 days. While
I was working there, my wife and child had to provide for themselves as much as
they could. It was very hard for us to solve this problem. The families just
had to help each other.
Our village is small.
Sometimes 27 people had to go to the railway, including women, children and old
people. Sometimes 15 people had to go, all men. The village head came around
collecting people every one or two weeks because he got orders from SLORC. He
tried to treat everyone equally, but 15 people went the first time, and then
the second time there weren't enough people so he had to choose some people who
already went the first time. The same happened the time after that. The usual
rule was one person from each family, but everything depends on the situation.
Some families have two or three men and the village head must plead for all of
them to go, but some pregnant women had to go as well. Some women even gave
birth at the railway.
At the work place we had
to cut trees and clear the bushes. It was forest with a few big trees and the
rest were bushes. We had to dig out the roots of big trees, and we had to cut
through a small hill. We had to clear two to three furlongs (440 to 660 yards)
every day with a width of about 100 yards – it was very wide. There were about
1,000 or 2,000 people from different villages working for this. The majority of
the workers are men, but I can't guess the number of women. The youngest was
about 15, the oldest over 40. We had to bring our tools from home, as well as
our rice.
There were always soldiers
around us. Some just guarded us, and some ordered us what to do. They didn't do
any work, they just walked around and ordered us. We
couldn't rest except at mealtime. They were always yelling at us and telling us
to hurry. If someone stopped to rest they beat him up or kicked him. Sometimes
the person fell down because they were kicking him. Some people were beaten
severely, but not so hard as to prevent them working. I was never beaten.
Nobody in my group got sick. People who got sick could tell their village head,
and if he vouched for them with the soldiers they could go home, but only if
the village head could get a replacement for them. Our village head was there
sometimes, but when he wasn't there we had to talk directly to the soldiers.
We worked from 7 till
I don't know what they are
planning to do with this railway, but it will take at least three years to
finish. Even when it is finished, we won't be able to live peacefully in our
village, because we'll still have to pay porter fees until they make peace with
the revolutionary groups. We were working for SLORC again and again and paying
porter fees until we had nothing left to eat. So we tried to escape from the
village one night and we got away. We had to cross the railway line and a car
road, so we had to wait until no soldiers were around. It took us 10 days to
get here. When I got here I worked very hard, earned 50 Thai Baht (US$ 2) for one day and bought some rice. Then we got
some rice from the refugee camp, so we are okay. Here it is better – at least
if you work and get 50 Baht you can use it for your
family, but there if you get 50 Ks you have to give it all to SLORC. I want to
go back when it becomes peaceful in my village, but if we still have to pay
porter fees and work for SLORC, we won't go back.
Interview: 12 HRV: Forced Labour,
Refugees, Women
Name: Mi Pan
Sex: Female
Age: 36
Ethnicity: Mon
Religion: Buddhist
Family: Married with 4 sons (age 5, 9,
11 and 14)
Occupation: Farmer
Address: Kaw Ka
Village, Ye Township,
Interviewed: late March 1994
My father arrived here one
month ago, but I just arrived four days ago. I came with my whole family. I
came here because I couldn't let them force me to work on the railway. It's too
hard. While we were there I didn't have to work on the railway, but both my
husband and my father had to. They had to start this work in October [1993].
The work is still going on, but they ran away from it and came here. They had
to go so many times, and each time they had to work for 15 days. After they
finished, sometimes they only came home for three or four days and then they
had to go back and work again. Each time when they went to work, they had to
take their own food. Those who refused to go had to pay 700 Ks.
From each house one person
had to go to build the railway. My father stays in a different house, so he had
to go too. My husband had to go about six times, and my father eight times.
SLORC gives authority to someone in the village to order who has to go and
when, and that person orders you to go. While my husband was away, I had to
borrow money to live, and afterwards I couldn't pay it back. Two tins of rice
costs 400 Ks, and I also had to pay "porter fees" – 700 Ks each time,
and I had to pay three times.
To go from the village to
the railway it takes six hours on foot. SLORC doesn't come,
the workers just have to go on foot by themselves. Then they have to carry the
rails for making the railway, dig the ground, carry dirt, cut wood, and many
other jobs. The most recent work is carrying logs. All the workers cut them,
and then they have to carry them to the railway or SLORC brings them on trucks.
My husband and my father had to do this, as well as all the other steps in
building the railway. They had to work all day long – they never had free time.
They start at
There were very many women
included in the work. They have to work together with the men. There were also
old people and children. The children were as young as 8 years old, up to 14
and 15 years old.
SLORC never gives food, they all have to bring their own. My husband and
father just took rice, salt, and fishpaste. Each time
they went they had to take half of the food in the house, and then if they
aren't allowed to come home and they run out of food and they have to borrow or
buy food from others. [Note: the reason she says they took "half the food
in the house" instead of 15 days' food is that they probably never even
had 15 days' food in the house. Due to SLORC looting and forced labour, these
people are already living from hand-to-mouth, close to starvation.] Those who
go to work knowing they don't have enough food and who can't ask for any from
relatives or friends will face starvation, so they just have to open their arms
and beg food from other people.
At the railway
construction site they have to sleep under the trees, in the bushes. They have
no mats, so they must sleep on the ground, and SLORC patrols around. To go to
the toilet they had to ask permission from the SLORC troops, and then the
soldiers followed them. The soldiers also guarded the area all the time while
they worked. You can't rest, even when you're tired you have to keep working.
Some soldiers forced the people to work by scolding or beating them, and some
of them don't. My husband and my father weren't beaten, but they saw others
getting beatings. Those who were beaten were working together with them, and
when they were beaten they were very close. They were beaten all over their
bodies, until they bled. When people got sick the soldiers didn't heal them,
they just left them. The sick weren't allowed to go home. They just had to stay
where they were until they got better. If they couldn't work, then they weren't
forced to work but they had to stay until they could work again. The soldiers
give them nothing.
I don't know why they're
making this railway, but it's not good. I don't want to go back. People will
have to work on it until it's finished. I came out here with five families altogether – my own family and my relatives. It was
difficult and it took a long time because we had to avoid the SLORC troops, so
it took at least 8 or 10 days. We didn't bring any belongings, just some
personal things. Now my husband and my father have gone back to the village to
help other families find their way here.
Interview: 13 HRV: Detention, Movement,
Torture
Name: Maung
A—
Sex: Male
Age: 29
Ethnicity: Burman-Indian Buddhist
Occupation: Trader
Address:
Interviewed: May 1994
I was arrested by IB 36 on
After two days I was
transferred to another column because the villagers had vouched for me, and the
officer there was good to me. He said, "We recognise you, you're not a
Karen soldier." Then they released me. After I was released I saw the woman
who had vouched for me. She had been tortured and still had wounds. I couldn't
even recognise her, and she couldn't even talk to me. Her eyes were closed and
she was lying on her bed.
Interview: 14 HRV: Torture
Name: Pi Say Wah
Sex: Female
Age: 60
Ethnicity: Karen
Religion: Buddhist
Occupation: Farmer
Address: Pa-an
Township,
Interviewed: May 1994
I was beaten by IB 36 on
All this happened in my
house. Then they left me there, and when they left they took the steps from my
house and put them over against the fence. [Karen houses are built raised above
the ground with a bamboo ladder to enter. They took the ladder away to make it
impossible to leave until others came.]
Interview: 15 HRV: Torture
Name: Maung
Than
Sex: Male
Age: 24
Ethnicity: Karen
Religion: Buddhist
Occupation: Farmer
Address: Pa-an
Township,
Interviewed: Spring 1994
I was tortured by Myint Way Oo. He is a platoon commander from Coy 4, IB 84, LID 99. The commander of his company is Maung Myint. Myint Way Oo arrested me
outside of the village, while I was working on my farm. It was
They didn't give me any
medicine for my wounds, they just rubbed sand and dust
on them. I still have scars on my legs, thighs, belly, my shoulders and my head
from the cuts and burns. This scar on my shoulder is where they put a burning
cheroot on it.
They didn't release me –
they just left me there after that because they thought I was dead. The next
morning, the monks and villagers came and picked me up. I was still
unconscious. The monks took me to the monastery, and after a few minutes there
I regained consciousness.
Interview: 16 HRV: Livelihood
Name: Saw C—
Sex: Male
Age: 53
Ethnicity: Karen
Religion: Buddhist
Occupation: Farmer
Address: Pa-an
Township,
They shot me on
Interview: 17 HRV: Slavery, Torture
Name: Maung Hla
Sex: Male
Age: 20
Ethnicity: Karen
Religion: Buddhist
Occupation: Farmer
Address:
Name: Saw Mu
Deh
Sex: Male
Age: 20
Ethnicity: Karen
Religion: Buddhist
Occupation: Farmer
Address:
Maung Hla:
The soldiers who captured
us were from IB 119 of LID 33 – their company commanders are Win Tay from Coy 1
and Min Than from Coy 2. We were captured on
Saw Mu
Deh:
Before asking any
questions, they punched us. Then they asked us, "Have you ever been a
Karen soldier?" Then they kicked me in the lower back over 10 times and
punched me in the face about 10 times. I lost half a tooth, and my nose and
mouth were bleeding. Then they kept on accusing me of being a Karen soldier but
I told them I wasn't. They said, "You must be!" and they carried on
punching me and asking questions again and again. Then they tied our hands
behind us, tied us up to trees and left us there. It was until the next morning
that they untied us. Then they didn't release us, they made us carry things for
them. We had to carry most of their supplies and some supplies that Karen
soldiers had hidden in a field and they'd found. We had to carry things to
their camp for four days, then they released us at
their camp. While we were carrying, sometimes they fed us twice a day but
sometimes only once, and it was never enough.
Interview: 18 HRV: Slavery, Torture
Name: Saw
Win Htun
Sex: Male
Age: 38
Ethnicity: Karen
Religion: Buddhist
Occupation: Farmer
Address: Pa-an
Township,
I was captured in the
village during a funeral, on
Interview: 19 HRV: Livelihood, Slavery
Name: Maung
D—
Sex: Male
Age: 37
Ethnicity: Karen
Religion: Buddhist
Occupation: Farmer
Address: Pa-an
Township,
I was arrested with the
others on 6 February. They were from LID 99, IB 84, commanded by Nyo Soe Min. They arrested us and
asked, "How many of you are Karen soldiers? Three of you are Karen
soldiers, isn't that right?" When I said no, they punched me in the face
and once in the chest. They asked me for 250 Ks and 8 bottles of alcohol, and
then I was forced to carry rice for them to their army camp for two weeks. Each
time I had to carry one and a half big tins full. After two weeks, I escaped.
Interview: 20 HRV: Livelihood, Minority,
Slavery, Torture
Name: Saw E—
Sex: Male
Age: 23
Ethnicity: Karen
Religion: Buddhist
Occupation: Farmer
Address: Pa-an
Township,
On