BURMA PRESS SUMMARY
From the Rangoon "The New Light of Myanmar"
Compiled for the Burma Studies Group by Hugh C. MacDougall
Published by the Center for East Asian and Pacific Studies, University of Illinois
Volume VII, No. 9, September 1993

 


NATIONAL CONVENTION
Preparations
Plenary Session Resumed
Appraisal by Alternate Chairmen
Clarifications by U Aung Toe
Speech by Lt-Gen. Myo Nyunt
Convention Adjourned to January

 

NATIONAL CONVENTION

Preparations

Sept. 2: At its 15th Work Meeting, Chairman U Aung Toe of the National Convention Convening Work Committee said that the Plenary Session would resume Sept. 6, when "the Panel of Chairmen would give an overall appraisal of the discussions presented by delegates groups." (NLM 9/3)


Plenary Session Resumed

Sept. 6: The Plenary Session of the National Convention met at the Central Meeting Hall in the President's Residence compound on Ahlon Road, with 648 of 698 delegates present.


Appraisal by Alternate Chairmen

The Panel of Alternate Chairmen presented an appraisal of the proposal papers submitted by the various delegate groups [text as published in NLM]:. "overall appraisal and clarification" [text as published in NLM]:

[Overall appraisal and clarification] by U Thein Lwin

National Convention Convening Commission Chairman and members National Convention Convening Work Committee Chairman and members and National Convention delegates.

I would like to express great pleasure at seeing National Convention Convening Commission Chairman and members, National Convention Convening Work Committee Chairman and members and National Convention delegates, refreshed and fine, in attendance at this plenary session of the National Convention, and extend my greetings to all present at the meeting with my best wishes for their physical and spiritual well-being.

Esteemed delegates,

Now, delegates in the respective delegates' groups have presented to their satisfaction all that they wish to discuss and propose, in discussion papers submitted to the National Convention plenary session, on principles that should form basis in formulating State fundamental principles to be contained in the enduring State Constitution that is of vital importance to the State and the citizens.

As the discussions and proposals are found to have been presented within the framework of the six objectives of the National Convention including Our Three Main National Causes of Non-disintegration of the Union, Non-disintegration of National Solidarity and Perpetuation of Sovereignty, I would foremost like to express thanks to all delegates to the National Convention.

As the proposals discussed and presented by the delegates at the plenary session of the National Convention are ones to be placed on historical record, they need to have strong factual support, they need to have grand significance, and they need to succinctly convey the intended meaning. Moreover they need as well to be free as far as possible of the Four Kinds of Unrighteousness due to subjective Sentiment, Aversion, Apprehension, and Delusion.

However, it was found that some presentations by some delegates, though well-intentioned, were lacking in factual support and were erroneous and there have been a few cases where the respective delegate group chairmen had to call in those delegates to meet, discuss and coordinate with them in a family spirit. The delegates on their part were satisfied and accepted it, and for that I would like to express my praise for and pride in them.

[Proposals Presented by Delegate Groups] by U Thein Lwin

Esteemed delegates,

You have heard 22 papers of discussions on principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles, presented by delegates in the respective delegates groups. In the papers so presented:

Six papers were presented from representatives-elect group, out of altogether eight groups attending the National Convention:

-- one by representatives-elect from Shan Nationalities League for Democracy,

-- one by representatives-elect from National Unity Party,

-- one by representatives-elect from Mro or Khami National Solidarity Organizations,

-- one by representatives-elect from Union Pa-O National Organization, representative-elect from Shan State Kokang Democratic Party and five representatives-elect namely Dr Hmu Thang from Thantlang Constituency, U Khin Maung Cho from Dimawhso Constituency No 1, U Thawng Hko Thang from Tamu Constituency, U Tun Kyaw from Namhsan Constituency, and U Aung Thein of Ywangan Constituency,

-- one by representatives-elect from National League for Democracy and independent representative-elect from Kya-in Seikkyi Constituency No 1 U Hla Maung,

-- and one by independent representative-elect from Bahann Constituency No 1 U Tun Hlaing.

Six papers were presented by six groups out of eight groups attending the National Convention.

-- one by nationalities delegates group,

-- one by peasant delegates group,

-- one by worker delegates group,

-- one by intelligentsia and technocrat delegates group,

-- one by State service personnel delegates group,

-- one by other invited delegates group.

Ten papers were presented from political party delegates group, out of eight groups attending the National Convention.

-- one by Shan Nationalities League for Democracy,

-- one by National Unity Party,

-- one by Union Pa-O National Organization,

-- one by Shan State Kokang Democratic Party,

-- one by Mro or Khami National Solidarity Organization,

-- one by Lahu National Development Party,

-- one by Union Kayin League,

-- one by Kokang Democracy and Unity Party,

-- one by Wa National Development Party,

-- one by National League for Democracy.

In appraising the papers so presented, it was found that just as there were discussions and proposals in connection with the 14 chapter headings as suggested by the Chairman of the National Convention Convening Work Committee on 7 June 1993, there were also discussions with addition of proposals that have some connection with these chapter headings.

For a comprehensive appraisal of discussions and proposals of political parties and delegate groups, I will give a presentation of main points from the papers on one matter after another. I will also present excerpts of proposals for inclusion of principles that have some connection with the State fundamental principles. In so doing, I will mention the principles which, according to discussions and proposals submitted by Convention delegate groups, should form basis in laying down State fundamental principles.

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall appraisal of discussions by various delegate groups in connection with the objective of non-disintegration of the Union, it is found that the delegate groups have held discussions highlighting the fact that the national races since the beginning of history have always lived together in amity hand in hand in tranquillity or adversity, that the Three Main National Causes should be prescribed as fundamental policy of the State, and that the objective of non-disintegration of the Union that is to be held uppermost by all the people of the country should be laid down as a fundamental principle.

[States and Regions] by Col. Thaik Tun

Esteemed delegates,

As regards constituting of territories within the country, among the principles on the State structure, you have heard the discussions and proposals from the respective delegate groups. The essence of these presentations in connection with constituting of territories are found as follows:

(a) To constitute the Pyidaungsu State comprising states and divisions, as have all along been designated as states and divisions

(b) To constitute the existing 7 states and 7 divisions as 14 equal-status states or 14 equal-status regions

(c) To constitute the Pyidaungsu State with Kachin, Kayah, Kayin, Chin, Bamar, Mon, Rakhine and Shan national states,

(d) To constitute the Pyidaungsu State with Kachin, Kayah, Kayin, Chin, Bamar, Mon, Rakhine, Shan and Wa etc states,

(e) To keep the states and divisions as they are and additionally constitute Wa state as a Pyidaungsu member state.

Of the five above, the proposal to constitute the Pyidaungsu State comprising states and divisions as have always been designated as states and divisions was presented by the National League for Democracy from the political party delegates group and by representatives-elect from the National League for Democracy and an independent representative-elect from the representatives-elect delegates group.

The proposal to constitute the existing 7 states and 7 divisions as 14 equal-status states or 14 equal-status divisions was presented:

-- by representatives-elect of National Unity Party

-- by representative-elect of Union Pa-O National Organization, representative-elect of Shan State Kokang Democracy Party and five independent representatives-elect,

-- from the representatives-elect delegates group,

-- by delegates from nationalities delegates group,

-- by delegates from peasant delegates group,

-- by delegates from worker delegates group,

-- by delegates from intellectual and intelligentsia delegates group,

-- by delegates from State service personnel delegates group,

-- by delegates from other invited delegates group,

-- by National Unity Party,

-- by Union Pa-O National Organization,

-- by Kokang Democracy and Unity Party from political party delegates group.

The proposal to constitute the Pyidaungsu State with Kachin, Kayah, Kayin, Chin, Bamar, Mon, Rakhine and Shan national states was presented by representatives-elect of Shan Nationalities League for Democracy, from the representatives-elect delegates group and by Shan Nationalities League for Democracy from the political party delegates group.

The proposal to constitute the Pyidaungsu State with Kachin, Kayah, Kayin, Chin, Bamar, Mon, Rakhine, Shan and Wa etc states was presented by Lahu National Development Party from the political party delegates group.

The proposal to keep the States and Divisions as they are and additionally constitute Wa state as a Pyidaungsu member state was presented by Wa National Development Party from the political party delegates group.

What I have presented just now are points highlighted by the delegates as regards the constituting of territories within the Pyidaungsu State. Some delegates have discussed and proposed that states and divisions should be constituted as they have always been constituted as states and divisions, that the State would be constituted with regions or states, and the Pyidaungsu Myanmar Naing-Ngan-Daw should be constituted with states in accord with provisions in the State Constitution.

Esteemed delegates,

A comprehensive review of proposals of the delegate groups shows proposals made for constituting the existing seven states and seven divisions on equal status and constituting the State in accord with Pyidaungsu system.

In connection with the existing states and divisions, it is found, some delegates groups proposed that states should be called states as they are now.

Some delegate groups proposed that states and divisions should be called regions and some proposed that states and divisions should be called as they are being called now and the State should be called Pyidaungsu Thamada Myanmar Naing-Ngan-Daw.

With serious consideration of discussions and proposals of the delegate groups, it is appraised that principles should be laid down

-- to name the State as Pyidaungsu Thamada Myanmar Naing-ngan-daw,

-- to constitute the State in accord with Pyidaungsu system,

-- to prescribe that the territory of the State is as it is on the date the State Constitution comes into force,

-- to designate the existing seven divisions as seven regions and the existing seven states as states,

-- to prescribe that these seven regions and seven states are of equal status.

In a comprehensive review of proposals presented by delegates from delegate groups that discussed the matter of calling the existing states and divisions by their historical names, it is found, delegates from states maintained that their states' names should be kept as they are now; that it could not harm national solidarity, that if the names are changed, it would take quite some time to make it understood by the people of the states that have difficult accessibility and low literacy, that the seven states and the seven divisions should be called regions or states and that the names of these regions or states should be retained as they are now, and that if it is desired to change the name of a region or state, it should be done only after seeking the mandate of citizens residing in that region or state.

It is found that proposals of the delegates are suitable. As it is believed that there is no reason to adversely affect Our Three Main National Causes of non-disintegration of the Union, non-disintegration of national solidarity, and perpetuation of sovereignty which we all hold highest, it is appraised that, as proposed by the delegate groups, principles should be laid down.

-- to keep the names of regions and states as they are at present,

-- in case it is desired to change the name of a region or state, to do so after seeking the mandate of the citizens residing in that region or state and enacting a law.

[Self-Administered Areas] by U Wan Tin

Esteemed delegates,

You have already heard the discussions of the National Convention delegate groups on constituting of self-administered areas within regions and states if necessary, as one of the fundamental principles of the State Structure. National Convention delegate groups were found to have made it clear that self-administered areas should be permitted to be constituted within regions or states as necessary. In discussing the rights of the self-administered areas, the delegates maintained that national unity would be more consolidated and the Union would be everlasting if provisions were made to emphatically satisfy especially the desires for self-administration; and that way the national races residing closely together will be able to manage affairs of their own villages and townships, social and cultural affairs in accord with the wishes of the majority. It is therefore appraised that, in laying down principles that should form basis in formulating State fundamental principles concerning the State structure, the following principles should be laid down in order to provide for the right to constitute in accord with the State Constitution self-administered areas depending on necessity within regions or states:

-- To provide for the right to constitute in accord with the State Constitution self-administered areas depending on necessity within regions and states.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[No Right of Secession] by U Mya Sein

Esteemed delegates,

What I have just presented are the discussions of the Convention delegates in connection with the point that no territory of the Myanmar Naing-Ngan ever secedes from the Union. It is found that the Convention delegate groups expressed their sentiments that no part of territories of the State such as regions, states and self-administered areas included in Myanmar Naing-Ngan should ever be permitted to secede from the State.

So, among the principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles in connection with non-secession from the Union, a principle should be laid down to enact that:

-- No part of the territories of the State such as regions, states and self-administered areas included in Myanmar Naing-Ngan shall ever secede from the State.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Multiparty Democracy] by U James Bond

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of excerpts from presentations by delegate groups as to what political system should be practised in the country, Convention delegate groups, it is found, clearly proposed that genuine multiparty democracy system be practised.

So, it is appraised that, in laying down principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles, a principle should be laid down for the State to practise genuine multiparty democracy system.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Presidential Executive] by U Ba Han

Esteemed delegates,

In a comprehensive review of proposals submitted by the delegate groups, it is found they have clearly proposed that the system of executive headed by the President should be practised.

So, it is appraised that, among the principles that should form basis in formulating State fundamental principles concerning the Head of State, the following principles should be laid down:

-- The Head of State shall be the President.

-- The President shall be elected by a presidential electoral college.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Separation of Powers] by U Tun Yin Law

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of the proposals presented by the delegate groups in connection with principles on sovereign State powers that should be included in the chapter on State fundamental principles, it is found that they have clearly stated that sovereign State power emanates from the people and covers the whole of the country, and that, in the exercise of its three branches namely, legislative, executive and judicial powers, they should be exercised, as much as possible separately and distributively, with the practice of a system of reciprocal control, check and balance.

So, it is found that, in laying down principles to form basis in formulating the State fundamental principles in connection with sovereign State powers, the following principles should be laid down:

-- To prescribe that Myanmar Naing-Ngan is a sovereign independent nation,

-- To prescribe that national sovereignty emanates from the citizens and covers the whole country,

-- The three branches of sovereign State power--legislative, executive and judicial powers--are to be exercised separately as much as possible with reciprocal control, check and balance,

-- The three branches of State powers so separated shall be distributed among Pyidaungsu, regions and states, and self-administered areas.

[Two-chamber Hluttaw; Local Hluttaws] by U Tin Oo

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of discussions and proposals by delegate groups in connection with the concept of having one Hluttaw representing seven regions and seven states equally and one Hluttaw representing the people--a fundamental principle that should be included in formulating State fundamental principles--it is found the delegate groups have spoken clearly for the principle of having two Hluttaws at the central level--one Hluttaw representing seven regions and seven states equally and one Hluttaw representing the people of the whole country--for exercising legislative power. In so doing, they also maintained that by having two Hluttaws there would be reciprocal control between the two.

So, it is found, the following should be laid down as principles to form the basis in formulating fundamental principles concerning legislative affairs:

-- To distribute the State's legislative powers to the Pyidaungsu Hluttaw, region Hluttaws and state Hluttaws,

-- To delegate legislative power prescribed by the State Constitution to the self-administered areas,

-- To have two chambers of Pyidaungsu Hluttaw--one Hluttaw elected on the basis of population and one Hluttaw elected with equal numbers of representatives from regions and states.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[State/Regional Hluttaws] by U Myo Thant

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of proposal of the National Convention delegate groups on the matter of having a legislative Hluttaw in each of the seven regions and seven states --a principle that should be included as a fundamental principle in formulating the State fundamental principles, it is found the delegate groups have proposed having a legislative Hluttaw in each of seven regions and seven states for them to have the right to prescribe their regional legislative matters.

So, in connection with the matter of having a legislative Hluttaw in each of seven regions and seven states, it is found, it should be laid down as a principle as follows:

-- To have a region Hluttaw in each of the seven regions and a state Hluttaw in each of the seven states.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Tatmadaw Legislative Participation] by U Myo Thant

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of discussions by the National Convention delegate groups as regards participation of Tatmadaw representatives in legislative branch, they clearly presented the view that the interests of the State and the citizens will be better served by the Tatmadaw participating as appropriate in legislative matters of Hluttaws so as to serve the interests of the State to the maximum in future, and that a principle should be laid down to the effect that Tatmadaw member Hluttaw representatives nominated by the Defence Services Commander-in-Chief shall be included in the legislative Hluttaws at different levels.

So, it is appraised that, in laying down principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles, in connection with the matter of Tatmadaw member Hluttaw representatives participating in legislative Hluttaws, the following should be laid down as a principle:

-- To prescribe that Tatmadaw member Hluttaw representatives nominated by the Defence Services Commander-in-Chief in numbers stipulated in this State Constitution are included in Pyidaungsu Hluttaw, region Hluttaws and state Hluttaws.

(NLM 9/7)

Sept. 7: On the second day of the plenary session, with 649 of 698 delegates present, members of the Panel of Alternate Chairmen continued their "appraisal and clarification" of the proposal papers [texts as published in NLM]:

[Executive Branch] by U Ba Han.

Esteemed delegates,

In connection with fundamental principles on executive matters among State fundamental principles, delegate groups have held discussions and presented proposals clearly to the effect that the three powers should be should be exercised separately and distributed among central, regions and states and provisions should be made to have reciprocal control, check and balance among them; that in such exercise with distribution of executive powers, precise provisions should be made to define rights and responsibilities of central and lower levels in accord with the State Constitution; that in doing so, it is necessary to take into consideration the right of national races to prescribe for themselves and to proceed in accord with democratic practice within the framework of perpetuation of sovereignty; and that the presidential executive system should be practised.

So, it is appraised that it should be laid down as follows, as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles concerning executive branch:

-- The head of executive of the State is the President of the State,

-- The executive power of the State is distributed among Pyidaungsu, regions and states. Self-administered areas are to be given self-administration powers as prescribed by the State Constitution.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Tatmadaw Executive Participation] by U Ba Han

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of discussions on the matter of Tatmadaw members participating in the executive branch at Pyidaungsu, regions, states, self-administered areas and districts level--among fundamental principles on the executive--it is found the delegate groups have held discussions and made proposals clearly to the effect that the importance of the role of the Tatmadaw by tradition in the course of history of the nation should be respected; that the Tatmadaw is a consolidated and united national force; whenever the nation encountered difficult times, the Tatmadaw had to step in and shoulder responsibilities of security of the State, maintenance of law and order and administration in addition to its original duties; at present too, the Tatmadaw is safeguarding sovereignty, and national identity and the sasana and carrying out nation building works and economic restructuring measures; in future too, it is necessary to take timely action to ward off dangers of destruction from within and without; and so, for the Tatmadaw with its fine traditions and mature experiences to participate hand in hand with the people inclusive of nationals in border areas in executive organs at different levels and to remain undissociated from national politics, Tatmadaw members nominated by the Defence Services Commander-in-Chief should participate in suitable proportion in suitable places in the executive branch, from central to district level.

So in connection with the matter of Tatmadaw members nominated by the Defence Services Commander-in-Chief participating in performance of duties of Pyidaungsu and regional defence, security, border area administration etc, it is appraised that it should be laid down as follows as a principle to form basis in laying down State fundamental principles:

-- Tatmadaw members nominated by the Defence Services Commander-in-Chief are included to shoulder duties of defence, security, border administration etc in the executive organs of Pyidaungsu, regions, states, self-administered areas and districts.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Judicial Affairs] by Mya Sein

In connection with fundamental principles on judicial affairs, there was no discussion by

--Union Pa-O National Organization,

--Shan State Kokang Democratic Party,

--Lahu National Development Party,

--Union Kayin League

--Kokang Democracy and Unity Party.

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of discussions and proposals of respective delegate groups on fundamental principles concerning judicial affairs, among the State fundamental principles, it is found they have clearly stated that the following should be prescribed as fundamental principles:

-- For administration of justice independently in accord with law, for more flourishing of the worthiest of worldly values in the State,

-- For administration of justice in public except where restricted by law,

-- For there to be right of defence and right of appeal in cases,

-- For no penal law to have retrospective effect,

-- For no punishment to violate human dignity, if there be punishments included in laws to be enacted.

Some delegate groups submitted that administration of justice should be conducted by benches, that no-one shall be deemed guilty until and unless so found by the court, that every one shall be equal before the law, and that a person who has committed an offence should be punished in such a way as to repent and reform to become a good person; and moreover that no-one shall be held in custody or kept in restraint for more than 24 hours without a court order. Of these related discussions and proposals, what is suitable will be mentioned in related chapters.

So, it is appraised that it should be laid down as follows, as principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles in connection with administration of justice:

-- For administration of justice independently in accord with law,

-- For administration of justice in public except where restricted by law,

-- For there to be right of defence and right of appeal in cases,

-- Not to prescribe provisions with retrospective effect in penal laws,

-- Not to prescribe punishments that violate human dignity.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Law Courts] by U Wan Tin

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of discussions and proposals on the principle of setting up courts, which should be included in the State fundamental principles, it is found the delegate groups have clearly spoken for setting up Pyidaungsu Taya Hluttaw at the central level, a region taya hluttaw in each region and a state taya hluttaw in each state, and courts in self-administered areas, districts and townships.

In proposals as fundamental principles on administration of justice, it was proposed to have the Pyidaungsu Taya Hluttaw should have right to issue writs and take action for prompt and effective redress and protection in case of violation of fundamental rights of the people. Moreover, it was also proposed that a Constitutional Tribunal be set up to exercise rights to safeguard provisions of the Constitution, interpret the Constitution and decide on disputes concerning the Constitution. It is found that, in the light of experiences, it is really necessary to lay down as a principle for our country.

So, it is appraised that the following should be laid down as fundamental principles for setting up law courts:

-- To distribute legislative [sic] powers of the State to law courts at different levels including the Pyidaungsu Taya Hluttaw, region taya hluttaws, state taya hluttaws and self-administered area law courts,

-- To have a Pyidaungsu Taya Hluttaw as the highest law court of the State,

-- For the Pyidaungsu Taya Hluttaw to have the power to issue writs,

-- For each region to have a region taya hluttaw and for each state to have a state taya hluttaw,

-- To set up a Constitutional Tribunal to interpret provisions of the Constitution, to scrutinize whether or not laws enacted by legislative Hluttaws and activities of executive organs from the central level to self-administered areas are in conformity with the Constitution, decide on disputes in connection with the Constitution and perform other duties prescribed in the Constitution.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Unitary, Modern Tatmadaw] by Col. Thaik Tun

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of proposals submitted by the delegate groups, it is found they made it clear that a solidly and strongly organized modern Tatmadaw is a national force pre-requisite for a steadfast and strong State; that the sole modern Tatmadaw built up with offspring of the people is the armed organization representing the people in the State; so a principle should be laid down for building up strong, modern and sole Tatmadaw; and that, moreover, the Tatmadaw is to safeguard the Constitution and it should have the right to plan and manage for participation of the entire people in State security and defence.

So, it is appraised that the following should be laid down as fundamental principles for formulating the State fundamental principles in connection with matters of building strong, modern and sole Tatmadaw, safeguarding the Constitution, and Tatmadaw having the right to plan and manage for participation of the entire people in State security and defence:

-- To build up the Tatmadaw as a strong, modern and sole Tatmadaw;

-- To prescribe that the Tatmadaw is mainly responsible for safeguarding the Constitution;

-- For the Tatmadaw to have the right to plan and manage for participation of the entire people in State security and defence.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Tatamadaw Responsibility] by U Thein Lwin

Esteemed delegates,

You have already heard discussions of the delegate groups on the matter of assigning the Tatmadaw the responsibility to safeguard Our Three Main National Causes-- non-disintegration of the Union, non-disintegration of national solidarity, and perpetuation of sovereignty. In an overall appraisal of the discussions of the delegate groups, it is found they have clearly highlighted the fact that the Tatmadaw has historical traditions of having safeguarded the State whenever it encountered dangers; that it had rescued the nation from dire situations wherein the Union was about to disintegrate and fall into servitude--once in 1949, once in 1958, once in 1962 and once in 1988; that the Tatmadaw is paving the way practically as necessary for building a new State of genuine multiparty democracy; and that the Tatmadaw is a national force that has gained maturity in military, economic, social and administrative fields through its experiences; and so the Tatmadaw should be assigned the responsibility to safeguard Our Three Main National Causes.

So, it is appraised that the following should be laid down as a principle to form basis in formulating the State fundamental principles regarding the matter of assigning the Tatmadaw the responsibility to safeguard Our Three Main National Causes:

-- The Tatmadaw is mainly responsible to safeguard the causes of non-disintegration of the Union, non-disintegration of national solidarity and perpetuation of sovereignty.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Tatmadaw Independent Management] by U James Bond

The remaining political parties of the political party delegates groups and delegates of the representatives-elect delegates group have held discussions on the Tatmadaw's role but there was no discussion concerning the Tatmadaw's right to manage its own affairs independently.

Esteemed delegates,

It is found that, in connection with the right of the Tatmadaw to manage its affairs independently--as a matter of principle in State fundamental principles--discussions have clearly highlighted the fact that the Tatmadaw should deservingly participate in the national political leadership role; that no-one should be able to influence and dominate the Tatmadaw; that the Tatmadaw should be given the right to plan and manage its own affairs independently.

So, it is appraised that the following should be laid down as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles regarding the right for the Tatmadaw to independently plan and manage affairs concerning the forces:

-- For the Tatmadaw to have the right to independently plan and manage all affairs concerning the forces.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Authority of Commander-in-Chief] by U Tun Yin Law

Esteemed delegates,

I have presented salient points taken from proposals of delegates groups on the matter of assigning the Defence Services Commander-in-Chief to be the head of all armed organizations in the State. Mro or Khami National Solidarity Organization and Union Pa-O National Organization from the political party delegates group, representative-elect of Mro or Khami National Solidarity Organization from the representatives-elect delegates group and six delegates groups made it clear that all armed organizations in the State should be responsible to the Defence Services Commander-in-Chief; otherwise, if they are separate, there could be danger for the country; so the Defence Services Commander-in-Chief should be assigned as the head of all armed organizations in the State.

So, it is appraised that the following should be laid down as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principle for assigning the Defence Services Commander-in-Chief as head of all armed forces:

-- The Defence Services Commander-in-Chief is the head of all armed forces.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Justice, Liberty and Equality] by U Tin Oo

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall appraisal of discussions and proposals of the delegates groups, it is found they made it clear that further flourishing of the worthiest of worldly values such as justice, liberty and equality in the State should be laid down as a fundamental principle.

So it is appraised that the following should be laid down as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principle in connection with further flourishing of the worthiest of worldly values such as justice, liberty and equality in the State:

-- For every citizen to have the right to enjoy equality, liberty and justice etc prescribed in this State Constitution.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Citizenship] by U Myo Thant

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of the discussions by delegates groups on citizenship, naturalization and revocation of citizenship, it is found that they made it clear that all born of parents both of whom are nationals should be citizens and that citizenship, naturalization and revocation of citizenship etc. shall be as prescribed by law.

The main points from the proposals above which are to be included in the fundamental principles and the details are to be discussed when we get to respective chapters.

So it is appraised that the following should be laid down as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principle on citizenship, naturalization and revocation of citizenship:

-- All persons born of parents both of whom are nationals are citizens. All persons who have become citizens on the date this State Constitution comes into force are citizens. Citizenship, naturalization and revocation of citizenship shall be as prescribed by law.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of the discussions of the delegate groups on the rights of citizens, it is found they have covered every citizen's right to equality in status, equality in opportunity, equality before law, and social justice, economic justice and political justice on the basis on [sic] eternal principles of justice, liberty and equality; in doing so, they included matters to be guaranteed by law in accord with the nature of democracy, such as rights of expression, publication, assembly, worship, ownership and livelihood and they also included proposals to avoid excessive and indisciplined exercise of these rights and live up to integrity that should be upheld the people in accord with law [sic]. They also made it clear that there should be the right for all the people, with no-one high or low, to enjoy them equally.

So it is appraised that the following should be laid down as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principle on rights of citizens:

-- To prescribe that necessary law will be enacted for effectiveness, firmness and completeness of freedoms, right, privileges, responsibilities and restrictions of citizens.

(NLM 9/8)

Sept. 8: The plenary session continued, with 645 of 698 delegates present. The Panel of Alternate Chairmen continued appraisals and clarifications of proposal papers [text as published in NLM]:

[Equality Before the Law] by U Wan Tin

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of the discussions by delegate groups on laying down a fundamental principle that every citizen is equal before the law, it is found that they have expressed sentiments that every citizen should be equal before the law, and that only when there is equality before law irrespective of race, religion, sex, social or economic status will it be a country where law prevails.

That is included in the principle for every citizen to have the right to enjoy equality, liberty and justice etc, prescribed in this State Constitution and so it is appraised it need not be laid down as a separate principle.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Duty of Citizens] by U Wan Tin

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of the discussions and proposals of delegate groups for laying down fundamental principles for not just the Tatmadaw but all the people of the Union to safeguard the Three Main National Causes, it is found that they have made it clear it is necessary to lay down a principle that it is the duty of every citizen to safeguard non-disintegration of the Union, non-disintegration of national solidarity and perpetuity of sovereignty.

So it is appraised that it should be laid down as follows as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles for every citizen to have the duty to maintain the Three Main National Causes:

-- Every citizen has the duty to safeguard non-disintegration of the Union, non-disintegration of national solidarity and perpetuation of sovereignty.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Citizens' Rights and Responsibilities] by U Mya Sein

Esteemed delegates,

What I have just read out are associated proposals in connection with citizens, citizens' fundamental rights and responsibilities. It is found that these proposals should be laid down as principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles concerning citizens. So, it should be laid down as principles that:

-- Every citizen shall be responsible to abide by the State Constitution,

-- Every citizen shall be responsible to learn military science in accord with law,

-- Every citizen shall be responsible to undergo military service in accord with law,

-- To prescribe that public peace and tranquillity and prevalence of law and order is the responsibility of every citizen,

-- there shall be no right to hold a citizen in detention for more than 24 hours without the permission of a law court,

-- The State is to help promote the interests of intellectuals and intelligentsia,

-- The State is to care for mothers and children, orphans, fallen Tatmadaw members' children, the old and the infirm, and the disabled,

-- The State is to arrange to permit citizens the right of ownership, right of inheritance, right of private enterprise, right of invention and right of patent in accord with law.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Culture] by U Thein Lwin

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of discussions by delegate groups on fundamental principles concerning cultural matters, it is found they made it clear that principles should be laid down for the rights of every national to freely cultivate, preserve, speak and write one's own language, literature, culture and customs, that there should be arrangements to safeguard them, that it is necessary to preserve national culture so as to ward off cultural colonization, nationalities language and literature should be prescribed and taught as subjects at the University of Culture; only then would it be possible to preserve national pride and national characteristics along with development of the country and that it is appropriate to undertake the work concerning literature, culture, fine arts that are cultural heritages within the framework of national culture.

So it should be laid down as follows as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles concerning culture:

-- The State shall assist in development of nationalities language, literature, fine arts and culture,

-- The State shall assist in development, consolidation and preservation of national culture.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Nationalities Development] by Col. Thaik Tun

Esteemed delegates,

Delegate groups have discussed and proposed fundamental principles that should be laid down for development of our national brethren of less developed areas.

Moreover, they have proposed that the State help promote mutual friendship and respect, mutual cooperation and solidarity among the nationalities. In an overall review of the delegate groups' discussions, it is found they have clearly spoken for the State to help develop education, health, economy, transport and communications of the nationalities in the less developed areas and promote mutual friendship and respect, mutual cooperation and solidarity among the nationalities.

So, it is appraised that it should be laid down as follows, as principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles on nationalities in the less developed areas:

-- The State is to help promote social and economic development including education, health, economy, transport and communications of less-developed nationalities,

-- The State is to help promote solidarity, mutual friendship and respect and mutual cooperation among the nationalities.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Peasants and Workers] by Col. Thaik Tun

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of discussions by delegate groups on fundamental principles concerning peasants and workers, it is found they have spoken for the peasantry to have guarantees for equitable value of their agricultural produce and for workers to have equitable wages, safe and pleasant working conditions and social security benefits.

It is found that, just as they have submitted points concerning uplift of the life of the peasantry such as the right to freely sell agricultural produce and form associations, they have clearly discussed fundamental principles that should be laid down to make laws and rules on work-site conditions, wages, right to form associations, reduction of unemployment, and opportunity to get gender-compatible employment, for betterment of the life of workers.

So, it is appraised that it should be laid down as follows, as principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles:

In connection with the peasantry:

-- The State is to enact necessary laws to protect the rights of the peasantry,

-- To help the peasantry get equitable value for their agricultural produce.

In connection with workers,

-- The State is to enact necessary laws to protect the rights of workers,

-- The State is to help as much as it can to reduce unemployment.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[State Service Personnel] by U Tun Yin Law

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of discussions by the delegate groups to get fundamental principles concerning the State service personnel, it is found they want personnel in the service of the State to have security in life, develop their physical and intellectual abilities and enjoy rights in full and they also want them to serve the State and the people, to be free from party politics, to be good service personnel and to conduct themselves with integrity. They have clearly discussed fundamental principles on the need to ensure fair sufficiency while in service as well as after retirement from service of the State and to lay down suitable codes of conduct for them.

So, it is appraised that it should be laid down as follows as principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles concerning personnel in the service of the State:

-- State service personnel are to be free from party politics,

-- The State is to enact necessary laws for State service personnel to have due guarantee in service and sufficiency of food, clothing and shelter, for married women in service to get maternity benefits, and for welfare to ease living conditions of persons who have retired from service.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Education and Health] by U Ba Han

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of discussions by various delegate groups concerning fundamental principles on education and health, it is found the delegate groups spoke mainly for having education and health policies that will contribute towards building of the State and raising of the living standards of the people.

In connection with the fundamental principle on education, delegates spoke for giving free compulsory primary education to all children of school-going age to give them all-round physical, intellectual and moral education; providing education contributory to livelihood; providing monastic school education; establishing a system of education that is firm and up to international standards; and upgrading the teaching of arts, sciences, technology and medicine up to international standards; and stressed that, in so doing, there should be no lack of teachers in remote, hardly accessible areas and there should be opportunities to get vocational education and learn nationalities languages as optional subjects, and it is necessary to concentrate on school education and contribute to growth of good citizenry with grounding of civics.

As regards fundamental principles on health, discussions highlighted the fact that it is necessary to lay down policies for free medical service for the people, primary health care and prevention of diseases and for sports and physical education to bring out national characteristics, and it should also be included as fundamental principles to have no lack of doctors in states; to permit private sector to undertake medical services in addition to the services provided by the Government and to produce more doctors and engineers from among the national races.

So, it is appraised that it should be laid down as follows as principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles on education and health:

-- The State is to earnestly strive to improve education and health of the people,

-- The State is to enact necessary law to enable the national people to participate in matters of education and health of the people,

-- The State is to implement free compulsory primary education system,

-- The State is to implement a modern education system that will promote all-round correct thoughts and good morals and contribute to building the nation.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Agriculture and Industry] by U James Bond

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of discussions and proposals of delegate groups on agriculture and industry, it is found the delegate groups have stressed that it is advisable to change over to mechanised agriculture as much as permitted by conditions, that only when there is development of agriculture will there be development of the economy of the State and that only when there is development of agriculture and industries will there be development of the national economy.

Moreover, they made it clear it is necessary to aim at modern development of agriculture, fish and meat and forest production and development of domestic industries and to encourage innovations and research in industry and strive for progress in keeping with the times.

So it is appraised that the following should be laid down as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles regarding agriculture:

In connection with agriculture,

-- The State is to provide inputs such as technology, investment, machinery, raw materials etc as much as it can for changeover from manual to mechanised agriculture.

In connection with industries,

-- The State is to provide inputs such as technology, investment, machinery, raw materials etc as much as it can for development of industry.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Youth and Religion] by U Tin Oo

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of discussions and proposals of the delegate groups on fundamental principles concerning youths, it is found they have stressed that youths should be trained and cultivated to have strong and patriotic spirit, correct thoughts and Five Strengths and opportunities should be created to enable them to participate in an appropriate role in activities of benefit to the country for the future State.

So it is appraised that the following should be laid down as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles regarding youth:

-- The State is to strive to imbue youths with strong and dynamic patriotic spirit, correct thoughts and the Five Strengths.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Esteemed delegates,

On laying down a fundamental principle for avoiding misuse of religion in political matters, delegate groups clearly proposed that there should be freedom of worship and that it is necessary to avoid misuse of religion for political purposes and draw a line to keep politics and religion separate.

It is held that in freedom of religion it should not be freedom without control; moreover, the State should as much as it could help and look after religions it has recognized. So it is appraised that the following should be laid down as principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles concerning religion:

-- In religious affairs, every citizen shall have equal right to freedom of thought and freedom of worship and composition, provided it is not contrary to the rule of law and order, public morals or public health or other provisions of the State Constitution.

-- The above right shall not cover allied economic, financial, political and other secular undertakings, though they may be associated with religious worship and composition,

-- Although such freedom and rights have been given, it should in no way hinder enactment of law by the State in public interest and reformation matters,

-- The State shall recognize that Buddhist sasana is the religious sasana replete with its specific glory worshipped by most citizens of the State,

-- The State shall recognize Islam, Christianity, Hinduism and nat worship as religions existing in the country on the day this Constitution comes into force,

-- The State shall help and protect as much as it can the religions it recognizes,

-- Religion shall not be misused for political purposes. Moreover, any act that is meant to or is likely to cause enmity, hostility or discord between one side and another or between one order and another is contrary to the State Constitution.

Law may be enacted to punish such acts.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Economy] by U Myo Thant

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of discussions and proposals by delegate groups regarding fundamental principles on economy, it is found they have stressed it should be arranged to enable various forces namely the State sector, regional organizations sector, cooperative organizations sector, joint ventures sector and private enterprises sector to participate actively to practise and economic system compatible with national objectives can be practised [sic]; in laying down economic policies, the State should help and coordinate for development of internal general resources, and enable all national economic forces to participate in boosting commodity production and finished products exports in commercial activities.

They have proposed that in the process there should be plans for the State to assist the private sector, to ease material living conditions of the people, to promote cooperative sector, to stabilize commodity prices and to narrow the standard of living gap between various regions and also that the State should be able to implement the economic system in such way that it does not become a burden for the people.

The delegates spoke for the State to have an independent economic policy, to have a market-based independent economic system and to be able to change economic strategy as necessary according to situation and in conjunction they also discussed matters of building the economic base for national economic development and having guarantees so as to be able to make full use of investments, expertise and innovations.

In addition, they clearly made the points that financial policies and economic plans should suit the market-based economic system and that economic enterprises should not be nationalised and there should be given guarantees in monetary matters.

So, it is appraised that it should be laid down as follows as principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles concerning economy:

-- The State economic system shall be market-based economic system,

-- The State shall permit all economic forces such as the State itself, regional organizations, cooperative organizations, joint venture organizations and private concerns etc to take part in economic activities for the development of national economy,

-- The State shall prevent acts that harm public interests through monopolisations of markets or manipulation of prices by an individual or group with intent to jeopardize fair competition in economic activities,

-- The State shall strive towards uplift of living standards of the people and development of general investments,

-- The State shall assist to acquire technology, investments, machinery and raw materials for development of national economy,

-- The State shall not nationalise economic enterprises,

-- The State shall not demonetize currency that is legal tender.

(NLM 9/9)

Sept. 9: The plenary session resumed with 643 of 698 delegates present, and appraisals and clarifications by the Panel of Alternate Chairmen continued for a final day, following which the plenary session adjourned to Sept. 16 [texts as published in NLM]:

[Natural Resources] by U Myo Thant

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of discussions by delegate groups on fundamental principles on State's natural resources, it is found the delegates spoke for laying down a fundamental principle that the State is the ultimate owner of all the land, resources above and below the ground, above and beneath the waters and in the atmosphere; they made proposals to have necessary laws, plans, policies and supervision in order to extract and utilize them beneficially; they said it should be arranged to have scientific protection of natural environment and to make it possible to use natural resources most beneficially for generations.

It is therefore appraised that the following should be laid down as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles on natural resources:

-- The State is the ultimate owner of all the land, natural resources above and below the ground, above and below the waters and in the atmosphere,

-- The State shall enact necessary laws to supervise economic forces' extraction and utilization of State-owned natural resources.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Elections] by U Wan Tin

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of the delegate groups' proposals it is found they have made it clear every citizen should have democratic rights such as the right to stand for election, the right to freely vote and the right to recall representatives according to law, and the secret ballot system should be practised in voting and necessary principles therefore laid down.

So it is appraised that the following should be laid down as principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles in connection with elections:

-- Every citizen shall have the right to vote and to stand for election according to law,

-- Voters concerned shall have the right, in accord with provisions of the State Constitution, to recall elected peoples' representatives.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Political Parties] by U Tun Yin Law

Esteemed delegates,

In connection with principles concerning political parties, the delegate groups made it clear that necessary laws must be made for disciplined and systematic formation of political parties under genuine multiparty democracy in the State; that, just as there will be political parties covering the whole country, there can also be parties formed locally; that political parties should have appropriate guiding philosophy, basic political programme and practices; and that only if political parties are systematically formed in accord with laws, rules and discipline will democracy flourish and sere the interests of the State and the people.

So it is appraised that it should be laid down as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles in connection with political parties:

-- The State shall enact necessary law for systematic formation of political parties concerning flourishing of genuine multiparty democracy system.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[State of Emergency] by U Mya Sein

Esteemed delegates,

An overall review of discussions and proposals of delegate groups on the fundamental principle concerning state of emergency provisions--a fundamental principle that should be involved in writing of the Constitution--will now be given.

In a study of discussions concerning state of emergency, it is found they have made it clear that there have been instances when the Tatmadaw, capable of standing unitedly as a national force, unavoidably had to take over State power and restore stability in the State when political means became incapable of solving political problems that arose due to political instability in the country or when there were splits of political parties and the rule of law and order, public peace and tranquillity broke down in the country; and that when it becomes necessary to unavoidably take over State power due to general situation that really comes about in the country, the Tatmadaw will be free of criticism from both within and without by proceeding in accord with provisions of the Constitution. Moreover, in a study of discussions and proposals put forward by delegate groups, it is found, they proposed that, in case a state of emergency comes about endangering security, life and property of the people, the Tatmadaw should be given rights to deal with the situation and provide protection. They have discussed and proposed with clarity for laying down fundamental principles empowering the Defence Services Commander-in-Chief to take over and exercise State power in accord with the provisions of the Constitution if there arises a state of emergency harmful to the Three Main National Causes due to takeover of State power or attempt therefor by wrongful and forcible means such as insurgency.

In addition to states of emergency discussed by other delegate groups, it is found the worker delegates group pointed out that, just as there had been states of emergency arising form political instability in the State, there had also been states of emergency arising from mixing of politics, religion and business interests; and that the government of the State should issue necessary orders, rights [sic] and laws and take necessary steps, in the interests of the people, for the rule of law and order, for security and defence of people's life and for stability and peace if such situations arise in future. In a study and appraisal of the discussions, it is found that there can also arise states of emergency characterised by inability to carry out administrative functions in accord with provisions of the Constitution in a region, a state or a self-administered area. It is appraised that a fundamental principle should be laid down to empower the President of the State to exercise executive power in the area of such a state of emergency and if necessary also to exercise legislative power concerning that area, in accord with provisions of the Constitution.

So, the following should be laid down as principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles concerning state of emergency:

-- When there arises a state of emergency characterised by inability to carry out administrative functions in a region or a state or a self-administered area in accord with provisions of the Constitution, the President of the State is empowered to exercise executive powers in that region, state or self-administered area and if necessary in doing so, the President of the State is empowered to exercise legislative powers concerning that region, state or self-administered area in accord with provisions of the Constitution,

-- When there arises or there is sufficient reason to arise a state of emergency endangering life and property of the people in a region, a state or a self-administered area, the Tatmadaw shall have the right, in accord with provisions of the Constitution, to pre-empt that danger and provide protection,

-- When there arises a state of emergency that could cause disintegration of the Union, disintegration of national solidarity and loss of national sovereignty, due to takeover of sovereign State powers or attempts therefore by wrongful forcible means such as insurgency or violence the Defence Services Commander-in-Chief shall be empowered to take over and exercise State power in accord with provisions of this State Constitution.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Amendment; National Symbols] by U Ba Han

Esteemed delegates,

We find that some delegate groups have discussed matters in connection with fundamental principle on amendment of the Constitution. It is noted that some delegate groups, though, have deferred discussions thereon as it will come up for detailed discussions later when we get to relevant chapter heading.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Esteemed delegates,

We find some delegate groups have discussed matters in connection with the fundamental principle on the State Flag, Emblem, National Anthem and Capital but it is noted that most of the delegates, though, have deferred discussion thereon as it will come up for detailed discussions later when we get to relevant chapter heading.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Foreign Affairs] by U Thein Lwin

Esteemed delegates,

You have already heard the delegate groups' discussions on foreign affairs. In an overall review of the discussions, it is found they clearly expressed sentiments for practising the following fundamental principles:

-- Myanmar Naing-Ngan is to practise independent, active and non-aligned foreign policy,

-- To maintain friendly relations with nations, with aims at world peace,

-- To uphold the principle of peaceful co-existence of nations.

Moreover, some delegate groups spoke for upholding the five principles of peaceful co-existence. There also emerged in association proposals to lay down fundamental principles that the State shall never start aggression against any nation and that the State shall not allow deployment of any foreign troops in the country, in accord with the essence of the principles of "non-aggression by one nation against another" and "non-interference in one another's internal affairs" as contained in the five principles.

So, it is appraised that the following should be laid down as principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles on foreign affairs:

-- The State shall practise independent, active and non-aligned foreign policy,

-- To aim at world peace and friendly relations with nations,

-- To uphold the principles of peaceful co-existence among nations,

-- The State shall never start aggression against any nation,

-- Not to allow deployment of any foreign troops in the country.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Environment; National Language] by U James Bond

Esteemed delegates,

It is found that delegates' discussions on protection of the natural environment are points to be earnestly considered for the future of the nation.

So, it is appraised that the following should be laid down as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles on protection of the natural environment:

-- The State shall protect the natural environment.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Esteemed delegates,

It is found that presentations on prescribing Myanmar language as the official language of the State should be included as a fundamental principle.

So, the following should be laid down as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principle on connection with Myanmar language:

-- Myanmar language is the official language.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[Interpretation; Transition Period] by U Tin Oo

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of the delegate groups' proposals on the matter of laying down that the fundamental principles are guidelines for interpreting the Constitution and other laws, it is found that they have clearly spoken for prescribing the State fundamental principles as guidelines in making laws or interpreting provisions of the Constitution and other laws. In a study of the constitutions of other nations, too, it is found that the State fundamental principles contained in them are prescribed as guidelines to be followed in making laws or interpreting provisions of the constitutions and other laws.

So, it is appraised that the following should be laid down as a principle to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles in connection with interpretation of the Constitution and other laws:

-- The State fundamental principles are to be guidelines to be followed by the legislative hluttaws in enacting laws and in interpreting provisions of the Constitution and other laws.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Esteemed delegates,

Some delegate groups have discussed principles concerning provisions in the period of transition. It is taken that most of the delegate groups, though, have deferred discussions thereon as they will come up for detailed discussions later when we get to relevant chapter heading.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[The Six Objectives] by Col. Thaik Tun

Esteemed delegates,

In an overall review of the delegate groups' discussions on the six objectives of the National Convention, it is found that they have proceeded on the basis of the six objectives in discussing and proposing principles to form basis in formulating the State fundamental principles for inclusion in writing the Constitution.

So, it is appraised, in conclusion, that these six objectives, stated below, should be laid down as objectives in the State fundamental principles:

-- Non-disintegration of the Union,

-- Non-disintegration of national solidarity,

-- Perpetuation of sovereignty,

-- For a genuine multiparty democracy system to flourish,

-- For the further burgeoning of the noblest and worthiest of worldly values such as justice, liberty and equality,

-- For the Tatmadaw to be able to participate in the national political leadership role of the future State.

(NLM 9/10)


Clarifications by U Aung Toe

Sept. 16: The plenary session of the National Convention resumed, with 649 of 698 delegates present, and heard clarifications by Convening Work Committee Chairman U Aung Toe and a speech by Convening Commission Chairman Lt-Gen. Myo Nyunt.

U Aung Toe said [full text]:

Esteemed Chairman and National Convention delegates,

In connection with the matter of laying down the principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles for the drafting of the State Constitution, proposals contained in 22 papers presented by eight Convention delegate groups have been analysed thoroughly by the Panel of Alternate Chairmen at the National Convention Plenary Session held from 6 to 9 September 1993 and principles that should be laid down as basic principles have been presented in an overall appraisal covering each of the subject matters. The National Convention Convening Work Committee met and coordinated with the Panel of Alternate Chairmen and it is found that appraisals of the Panel of Alternate Chairmen are ones that should be taken seriously. It is also found that virtually all these appraisals are congruent with discussions and proposals of delegate groups on fundamental principles concerning chapter headings as expounded in the National Convention Convening Commission Chairman's address and my clarification in the matter of laying down basic principles for formulating State fundamental principles at the National Convention Plenary Session on 7 June. So, taking the appraisals of the Panel of Alternate Chairmen as a basis, the National Convention Convening Work Committee hereby submits that basic principles for formulating State fundamental principles are laid down as follows:

(1) In connection with the State, it is laid down that--

(a) Myanmar Naing-Ngan is a sovereign, independent nation;

(b) the State shall be known as Pyidaungsu Thamada Myanmar Naing-Ngan-Daw;

(c) sovereign power of the State is derived from the citizens and is in force in the whole country;

(d) the territorial boundary of the State is as it is on the day this State Constitution comes into force.

(2) In connection with the aims and objectives of the State, it is laid down that: the State is consistently aimed at--

(a) non-disintegration of the Union;

(b) non-disintegration of national solidarity;

(c) perpetuation of sovereignty;

(d) flourishing of a genuine multiparty democracy system;

(e) further burgeoning of the noblest and worthiest of worldly values namely justice, liberty and equality in the State;

(f) for the Tatmadaw to be able to participate in the national political leadership role in the State.

(3) In connection with multiparty democracy, it is stipulated that--

-- the State practises genuine multiparty democracy system.

(4) In connection with State structure, it is laid down that--

(a) the State is constituted by Pyidaungsu (Union) system;

(b) the existing seven divisions are designated seven regions and the existing seven states are designated seven states. Those seven regions and seven states are of equal status and authority;

(c) the names of those seven regions and seven states are retained as they are at present;

(d) if it is desired to change the name of a region or a state, it shall be done so with enactment of law after ascertaining the wishes of citizens residing in the region or state concerned;

(e) in regions or states, self-administered areas are to be prescribed for national races who reside together in communities on the same common stretches of land in appropriate sizes of population, other than national races who have already got regions or states;

(f) depending on size of population and inhabited area, they are to be prescribed as self-administered divisions or self-administered zones as suitable;

(g) no part of the territory of the State, namely regions, states and self-administered areas etc. shall ever secede from the State.

(5) In connection with the Head of State, it is laid down that--

(a) the Head of State is the President of the State;

(b) the President of the State is elected by presidential electoral college.

(6) In connection with separation and distribution of sovereign State power, it is laid down that--

(a) the three branches of State power, namely, legislative power, executive power and judicial power are separated as much as possible and exert reciprocal control, check and balance among themselves;

(b) the three branches of State power so separated are distributed among Pyidaungsu (Union), regions, states and self-administered areas.

(7) In connection with legislature, it is laid down that--

(a) the legislative power of the State is distributed among Pyidaungsu Hluttaw, Region Hluttaws and State Hluttaws; legislative power stipulated by the State Constitution shall be distributed to self-administered areas;

(b) Pyidaungsu Hluttaw consists of two Hluttaws--one Hluttaw elected on the basis of population and the other one with equal number of representatives elected from regions and states;

(c) there will be a Region Hluttaw in each of the seven regions and a State Hluttaw in each of the seven states;

(d) Pyidaungsu Hluttaw, Region Hluttaws and State Hluttaws include Tatmadaw servicemen Hluttaw representatives nominated as such by Defence Services Commander-in-Chief in numbers stipulated by the State Constitution;

(e) for national races with appropriate sizes of population, national race representatives are to be permitted to participate in legislatures of regions, states or self-administered areas concerned.

(8) In connection with executive branch, it is laid down that--

(a) the head of executive of the State is the President of the State;

(b) the executive power of the State is distributed among the administrative organs of the Pyidaungsu, regions and states; self-administrative power shall be distributed to self-administered areas as stipulated by the State Constitution;

(c) Pyidaungsu, regions, states, self-administered areas and districts' executive organs include Tatmadaw servicemen nominated by Defence Services Commander-in-Chief to undertake responsibilities of defence, security, border administration etc.

(d) for national races of which representatives are so permitted to participate in legislatures of regions, states or self-administered areas in accord with above paragraph (7) sub-paragraph (e), representatives are to be permitted to participate, mainly to undertake their national race affairs, in administration of respective region, state or self-administered area;

(e) the State is to set up commission and undertake matters stated in above paragraph (4) sub-paragraphs (e) and (f) and paragraph (7) sub-paragraph (e) and this paragraph sub-paragraph (d).

(9) In connection with the judiciary, it is laid down that--

(a) the judicial power of the State is distributed among Pyidaungsu Taya Hluttaw (Supreme Court), Region Taya Hluttaw (Region High Court), State Taya Hluttaw (State High Court) and law courts of different levels including law courts of self-administered areas;

(b) in the Pyidaungsu is constitute one Pyidaungsu Taya Hluttaw. Pyidaungsu Taya Hluttaw is the supreme law court of the State;

(c) Pyidaungsu Taya Hluttaw has powers to issue writs;

(d) a Region Taya Hluttaw is constituted in each of the regions and a State Taya Hluttaw is constituted in each of the states;

(e) the following are stipulated as judicial principles:

-- independent administration of justice in accord with law;

-- administration of justice in public except where restricted by law;

-- giving of right of defence and right of appeal by law in cases.

(10) In connection with the Tatmadaw, it is laid down that--

(a) the Tatmadaw is strong, modern and must be the sole existing Tatmadaw;

(b) the Tatmadaw has the right to independently administer all affairs concerning the forces;

(c) the Defence Services Commander-in-Chief is the Supreme Commander of all armed forces;

(d) the Tatmadaw has the right to administer for participation of the entire people in State security and defence;

(e) the Tatmadaw is mainly responsible for safeguarding non-disintegration of the Union, non-disintegration of national solidarity and perpetuation of sovereignty;

(f) the Tatmadaw is mainly responsible for safeguarding the State Constitution.

(11) In connection with citizens and citizens' fundamental rights and responsibilities, it is laid down that--

(a) all persons born of parents both of whom are nationals are citizens; all persons who have become citizens in accord with law on the date the State Constitution comes into force are citizens; and citizenship, naturalization and revocation of citizenship shall be as prescribed by law;

(b) every citizen shall enjoy rights of equality, rights of liberty and rights of justice etc. as prescribed in the State Constitution;

(c) there shall be no right to hold a citizen in detention for more than 24 hours without the permission of a law court;

(d) every citizen has the duty to safeguard non-disintegration of the Union, non-disintegration of national solidarity and perpetuation of sovereignty;

(e) every citizen is responsible to abide by and uphold the State Constitution;

(f) every citizen shall have the duty to learn military science as prescribed by law;

(g) every citizen shall be responsible to undergo military service as prescribed by law;

(h) public peace and tranquillity and prevalence of law and order is the responsibility of every citizen;

(i) necessary law shall be enacted to make citizens' freedoms, rights, benefits, responsibilities and restrictions effective, firm and complete.

(12) In connection with the national races, it is laid down that--

(a) the State shall help develop language, literature, fine arts and culture of the national races;

(b) the State shall help promote solidarity, mutual amity, and respect and mutual help among the national races;

(c) the State shall help promote socio-economic development including eduction, health, economy, transport and communications of less developed national races;

(13) In connection with the peasantry, it is laid down that--

(a) the State shall enact necessary laws to protect the rights of the peasantry;

(b) the State shall help the peasantry get equitable value for their agricultural produce.

(14) In connection with workers, it is laid down that--

-- the State shall enact necessary laws to protect the rights of workers.

(15) In connection with intellectuals and intelligentsia, it is laid down that--

-- the State shall help promote the interests of the intellectuals and intelligentsia.

(16) In connection with the State service personnel, it is laid down that--

(a) State service personnel shall be free from party politics;

(b) the State shall enact necessary laws for State service personnel to have due security in service and sufficiency of food, clothing and shelter, for married women in service to get material benefits, and for welfare to ease livelihood of persons who have retired from service.

(17) In connection with national culture, it is laid down that--

-- the State shall help for development, consolidation and preservation of national culture.

(18) In connection with education and health, it is laid down that--

(a) the State shall earnestly strive to improve education and health of the people;

(b) the State shall enact necessary law to enable the national people to participate in matters of education and health of the people;

(c) the State shall implement free compulsory primary education system;

(d) the State shall implement a modern education system that will promote all-round correct thoughts and good morals and contribute towards building of the nation.

(19) In connection with agriculture and industry, it is laid down that--

(a) the State shall provide inputs such as technology, investments, machinery, raw materials etc. as much as it can for changeover from manual to mechanized agriculture;

(b) the State shall provide inputs such as technology, investments, machinery, raw materials etc. as much as it can for development of industries.

(20) In connection with employment it is laid down that--

-- the State shall, as much as it can, help reduce unemployment among the people.

(21) In connection with mothers, children, the old and the infirm, it is laid down that--

(a) the State shall care for mothers and children, orphans, fallen Tatmadaw servicemen's children, the old and the infirm, and the disabled;

(b) the State shall arrange for disabled Tatmadaw servicemen to be able to make a respectable livelihood and get free vocational training.

(22) In connection with the youths, it is laid down that--

-- the State shall strive to imbue youths with strong and dynamic patriotic spirit, correct way of thinking and the five noble strengths.

(23) In connection with religion, it is laid down that--

(a) every citizen is equally entitled to freedom of conscience and the right freely to profess and practise religion, subject to public order, morality or health and to the other provisions of the State Constitution;

(b) the above right shall not include any economic, financial, political or other secular activities that may be associated with religious practice;

(c) the freedom so guaranteed shall not debar the State from enacting laws for the purpose of social welfare and reform;

(d) the State recognizes the special position of Buddhism as the faith professed by the great majority of the citizens of the State;

(e) the Sate also recognizes Islam, Christianity, Hinduism and Animism as some religions existing in the State at the date of the coming into force of the State Constitution;

(f) the State shall help and protect as much as it can the religions it recognizes;

(g) the abuse of religion for political purposes is forbidden; and any act which is intended or is likely to promote feelings of hatred, enmity or discord between racial or religious communities or sects is contrary to the State Constitution and may be made punishable by law.

(24) In connection with the economy it is laid down that--

(a) the State economic system shall be market economic system;

(b) the State permits all economic forces such as the State itself, regional organizations, cooperative organizations, joint venture organizations and private concerns etc. to take part in economic activities for the development of national economy;

(c) the State shall prevent acts that harm public interests through monopolization or manipulation of prices by an individual or group with intent to jeopardize fair competition in economic activities;

(d) the State shall strive towards uplift of living standards of the people and development of general investments;

(e) the State shall assist to acquire technology, machinery and raw materials etc. for development of national economy;

(f) the State will not nationalize economic enterprises;

(g) the State will not demonetize currency that is legally put into circulation.

(25) In connection with the land, the waters, the atmosphere and natural resources, it is laid down--

(a) the State is the ultimate owner of all the land, and natural resources above and below the ground, above and beneath the waters and in the atmosphere within its territorial boundary;

(b) the State shall enact necessary law to supervise economic forces' extraction and utilization of State-owned natural resources;

(c) the State shall permit citizens' right of private property, right of inheritance, right of private enterprise, right of initiative and right of patent in accord with law.

(26) In connection with elections, it is laid down that--

(a) every citizen shall have the right to vote and to stand for election according to law;

(b) voters concerned shall have the right, in accord with the provisions of the State Constitution, to recall elected people's representatives.

(27) In connection with political parties, it is laid down that--

-- the State shall enact necessary law for systematic formation of political parties for flourishing of genuine multiparty democracy system.

(28) In connection with state of emergency, it is laid down that--

(a) when there arises a state of emergency characterised by inability to perform executive functions in accord with provisions of the State Constitution in a region or a state or a self-administered area, the President of the State is empowered to exercise executive power in that region, state or self-administered area and if necessary in doing so, the President of the State is empowered to exercise legislative powers concerning that region, state or self-administered area in accord with provisions of the State Constitution;

(b) when there arises or there is sufficient reason to arise a state of emergency endangering life and property of the people in a region, a state or a self-administered area, the Tatmadaw has the right, in accord with provisions of the State Constitution, to pre-empt that danger and provide protection;

(c) when there arises a state of emergency that could cause disintegration of the Union, disintegration of national solidarity and loss of national sovereignty, due to takeover of sovereign State power or attempts therefor by wrongful forcible means such as insurgency or violence, the Defence Services Commander-in-Chief has the right to take over and exercise State power in accord with provisions of the State Constitution.

(29) In connection with foreign affairs, it is laid down that--

(a) the State practises independent, active and non-aligned foreign policy, aims at world peace and friendly relations with nations, and upholds the principles of peaceful co-existence among nations;

(b) the State never starts aggression against any nation;

(c) no foreign troops are permitted to be deployed within the borders of the Union.

(30) In connection with punishments, it is laid down that--

(a) there is no right for any penal law to provide for retrospective effect;

(b) there is no right to prescribe punishments that violate human dignity.

(31) In connection with the natural environment, it is laid down that--

-- the State shall protect the natural environment.

(32) In connection with general provisions, it is laid down that--

(a) Myanmar language is the official language;

(b) the State fundamental principles are guidelines to be followed by the legislative hluttaws in enacting laws and in interpreting provisions of the State Constitution and other laws;

(c) a Constitutional Tribunal shall be set up to interpret provisions of the State Constitution, to scrutinize whether or not laws enacted by Pyidaungsu Hluttaw, Region Hluttaws and State Hluttaws and functions of executive authorities of Pyidaungsu, regions, states and self-administered areas are in conformity with the State Constitution, to decide on disputes in connection with the State Constitution between Pyidaungsu and regions, between Pyidaungsu and states, between regions and states, among regions, among states, and between regions or states and self-administered areas and among self-administered areas themselves [and?] to perform other duties prescribed in the State Constitution.

Esteemed Chairman and National Convention delegates,

After the basic principles have been so laid down for formulating State fundamental principles, it will be carried on as follows:

-- of those basic principles are to be taken as basis in discussing basic principles in respective chapters;

-- of those basis principles, those that should be mentioned in the preamble of the State Constitution should be mentioned also in that preamble;

-- principles concerning the State are to be mentioned separately in the chapter heading "The State";

-- likewise, principles concerning respective chapters are to be transferred to respective chapters when discussions are held for those respective chapters;

-- principles concerning the chapter "State fundamental principles" are to be retained in the chapter on State fundamental principles.

The National Convention Convening Work Committee has reported to the National Convention Convening Commission that the work will be carried on as detailed above. The Commission accepted and confirmed it and directed that it be presented to the National Convention Plenary Session. Hence, this clarification.

Esteemed Chairman and National Convention delegates,

As it is known to all delegates, the basic principles for formulating State fundamental principles are the very life of the State Constitution, key points of the State Constitution, and the essence of the Constitution and the work for laying down those basic principles is extremely important and the most primary. For having worked heart and soul for successful completion of such an extremely important and vital task like this, special thanks to all National Convention delegates and all members of the Panel of Chairmen who have led and supervised the proceedings are expressed in conclusion on behalf of the National Convention Convening Work Committee.

(NLM 9/17)


Speech by Lt-Gen. Myo Nyunt

Concluding the plenary session, and adjourning the Convention to January 18, 1994, National Convention Convening Commission Chairman Lt-Gen. Myo Nyunt delivered the following address [full text]:

Esteemed delegates of the National Convention,

I extend my best wishes for auspiciousness and well-being in body and mind of the delegates to the National Convention.

Now is the time of extremely good momentum in the convening of the National Convention.

Such a success is due to the delegates and respective committees working systematically, stage by stage, in cooperation between one another.

With goodwill, perseverance, tenacity, wisdom and foresight, the delegates have for three months held discussions in coordination to obtain basic principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles, compiled proposals and presented them at the plenary session.

It is learnt that the Panel of Alternate Chairmen has thoroughly studied proposals for State fundamental principles in 900 pages of 22 discussion papers at the Convention plenary session. The essence of these proposals were analysed by the Panel of Alternate Chairmen and the National Convention Convening Work Committee Chairman and it was due to the fact that primarily the proposals of the delegates in themselves are complete and good in essence.

Esteemed delegates,

As is the law of nature, such values as sentiments and views are not wont to be of only one kind, only one form or concurrent. That being so is only natural. Moreover, it is not in the nature of thoughts and views of ordinary human beings with the usual failings and foibles to be perfect. Accordingly it is not surprising that different thoughts and views occurred among our delegates. As for us, we have to earnestly consider, along with the sentiments of delegates of political parties and sentiments of representatives elected in the election, sentiments of national race delegates, peasant delegates, worker delegates, intellectual and intelligentsia delegates, State service personnel delegates and other invited delegates as well. In this way we have been able to bring out what are prominent sentiments and associated proposals.

As principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles have been presented only after repeated rounds of discussions and coordination group-wise by the eight delegate groups at this National Convention of ours, these presentations are not just quantitative but qualitative as well, as is inherent in themselves.

Delegates to the National Convention have systematically presented their respective proposal papers on the State fundamental principles to the Plenary Session. Thereafter, the Panel of Alternate Chairmen took time to scrutinize them and made overall appraisal to get principles to form basis in formulating State fundamental principles, and has already submitted them to the Plenary Session most comprehensively. After that, the National Convention Convening Work Committee met for coordination with the Panel of Alternate Chairmen. Moreover, it made in-depth study and appraisal of points proposed by the delegate groups and fully reported to the National Convention Convening Commission on basic principles for the State fundamental principles and the programme of work to be carried on. Thereupon the National Convention Convening Commission made earnest studies and appraisals of presentations concerning the State fundamental principles.

In so doing, it made serious scrutiny to see whether the principles proposed by the National Convention delegates to form basis in formulating the State fundamental principles can bring about realization of the following which are included in the six objectives of the National Convention:

-- the objective of non-disintegration of the Union;

-- the objective of non-disintegration of national solidarity;

-- the objective of perpetuation of sovereignty;

-- the objective for flourishing of a genuine multiparty democracy system;

-- the objective for further burgeoning of the noblest and worthiest of worldly values such as justice, liberty and equality;

-- the objective for the Tatmadaw to be able to participate in the national political leadership role of the future State.

Esteemed delegates,

The National Convention Convening Commission being an organ formed and assigned by the State Law and Order Restoration Council, it is responsible to the State Law and Order Restoration Council, which in fact, is the Tatmadaw that has great historic traditions. Thus, the Tatmadaw is the organization that saved the country from the danger of disintegration in the nick of time and has been safeguarding and building the nation, so much so as to have already brought about political, economic and social progress that all can see today. So, the State Law and Order Restoration Council being the most responsible and shouldering the greatest responsibility in the country, it is a great responsibility for the National Convention Convening Commission to take charge on its behalf and work for getting the fundamental principles for the State at the National Convention. Truly as being such a responsible organization, it has to responsibly make serious consideration and appraisals.

Esteemed delegates,

The National Convention Convening Commission, with a basic attitude of promoting the interests of the nation and the people that are all national races, accepted and approved the recommendations that have been presented by the National Convention Convening Work Committee.

Just as these principles need to be not only noble and correct but also appropriate for the motherland and the life situation of the people, it is highly essential that they serve the interests of the State. There often are instances that some things in the world, good as they may be, are not compatible with one's objective conditions.

Now a considerable way has been covered in coordination to get principles to form basis in writing the State Constitution as is the main task of the National Convention. As we move ahead, the principles that have been brought out are to serve as central pillars in coordination and discussions to get principles chapter-wise in detail. So, it is seen that bases have been obtained for the way forward of the National Convention.

Esteemed delegates,

As you have taken part in the National Convention with enthusiasm and vigour, with might and main, with strenuous efforts of the body and mind, you will more or less be feeling the strain. Moreover, you have had to stay here away from home for many days. So in order that you may go back home for some time to take rest and attend to family, business and social affairs and in order that you may have time to study more to get the best of ideas concerning matters in the chapters entitled 'The State', 'The State Structure', etc, which will be discussed when the National Convention is resumed soon, the Convention will go into recess beginning tomorrow up to 17 January 1994.

I conclude expressing ardent wishes to see you all together again in the best of health and good cheer when the National Convention is resumed in coolness and purity of January.

(NLM 9/17)


Convention Adjourned to January

Sept. 16: The National Convention was adjourned, to resume on January 18, 1994. (NLM 9/17)

Sept. 20: The Invitations, Receptions and Accommodations Sub-Committee met and "said that the National Convention has been adjourned till 17 January 1994 and therefore, it was necessary to renovate the hostels, to check whether the electrification was good or not and to effect repairs, to store the furniture and to wash and systematically store bed clothes." (NLM 9/21)

Sept. 21: Chairman U Aung Toe of the Work Committee "said that on resumption of the Plenary Session the remaining chapter headings on the fundamental principles for writing of the Constitution will be discussed in detail and in order and it is necessary for the Work Committee members to study them while the session remained adjourned." (NLM 9/22)