[Date Prev][Date Next][Date Index ]

Burma Related News - May 12, 2003.



--------------------------------------------------------------

BURMA RELATED NEWS - May 12, 2003.

--------------------------------------------------------------

HEADLINES

--------------------------------------------------------------

AFP - Tourist tower at historic Myanmar site throws preservation into question

AP - Heat, SARS fears to delay Myanmar school reopening

Reuters - Workplace discrimination still rampant, ILO says

DowJones - China To End Preferential Tax Policy For 20 Commodities

NYT - Burmese Women Are Reporting Systematic Rapes by Military

ST - Thailand keen on economic hub with neighbours

Asian Tribune - India - Myanmar - Thailand Highway to take "at least two years"

DVB News - Daw Aung San Suu Kyi welcomed by the USDA?

DVB News - Reactions on ICG's report: 'Myanmar backgrounder: Ethnic Minority Politics'

Mizzima News - India actively exporting arms to Burma

--------------------------------------------------------------

Monday May 12, 9:58 AM
Tourist tower at historic Myanmar site throws preservation into question

YANGON (AFP) - The awe-inspiring temples and stupas of Myanmar's ancient city Pagan are to be joined by a 60-meter high viewing tower that could help boost tourism revenue, but the plans are rekindling concern over commitment to cultural heritage preservation.

The spectacular collection of thousands of 11th and 12th century Buddhist monuments, covering some 40 square kilometers in remote central Myanmar, is rivaled only by Cambodia's Angkor Wat complex as mainland Southeast Asia's finest example of ancient archaeology and cultural heritage.

But the military government's plans to erect the tower, from where paying tourists will be granted a bird's eye view, have alarmed preservationists at UNESCO, the United Nations cultural body, an outraged other critics.

"We are definitely concerned about any plans to develop any kinds of new infrastructure within a protected area, or impacting on the protected area's buffer zone," Richard Engelhardt, UNESCO's Bangkok-based advisor for culture in Asia and the Pacific, told AFP recently.

A report in the state-run New Light of Myanmar last month said the Nanmyint Tower would be built near a golf course "in Bagan ancient cultural region".
The report carried mock-up photos of a 20-story cylindrical metallic tower. It would take a year to erect, it said.

Myanmar's leader, Senior General Than Shwe, made a visit to the site and inspected the plans, virtually assuring the project has the firm support of the military junta.

UNESCO's backing would be more complex. For decades the UN body has assisted in restoration work in Pagan, and for the past few years it has quietly liaised with Myanmar over eventual listing of Pagan as the country's first World Heritage site.

But key steps must be taken by the government first, including Yangon's provision of copies of national heritage legislation.

"What we're awaiting is not particularly controversial but we are waiting to receive these from the Myanmar government and when they are received, the nomination process will be picked up again," Engelhardt said.

The tower would not just be a representation of the growing tourist designs which the government has on Pagan; it throws into question the very nature of how the ancient city should be preserved.

"We are concerned that there becomes a confusion between heritage conservation of an ancient site ... and recreational tourism," he said.

Though built by a succession of Burmese kings, there are few if any trappings of royalty in Pagan. But critics say the name of the proposed tower (Nanmyint means "high palace") hints at a shift from reverence to pretension.

"Pagan is an _expression_ of humility by former kings and not a symbol of power," one Myanmar historian said, asking not to be named.

"The conceived royal tower would therefore be quite incongruous in that setting and stick out like a sore thumb," he added. "We want very much for Pagan to be preserved in its pristine form."

One diplomat described the plans to erect the tourist tower as "crazy."

"The beauty of Pagan will be disfigured," said the diplomat. "It is a crime. It is reminiscent of what happened to the Buddhas in Bamiyan and the looting in the Baghdad museum," he said, referring to giant statues destroyed by the Afghan former Taliban regime.

Whether the viewing tower would have to be scrapped for the site to earn a UNESCO listing is unclear, but Engelhardt, who is familiar with the tower's proposed location, is not happy.

"Normally the construction of a large new structure inside an archaeological site is something that we would not endorse."

UNESCO's blessing could be key for Pagan, as tourism revenues at World Heritage sites are often heavily boosted by such international recognition.

One source close to the process says Yangon is holding back on Pagan's World Heritage process.

"I think they are really in a fierce debate over what to do with Pagan, whether it's exploitation or educational conservation, and they think they'd better do that internally rather than open it up to public scrutiny," said the source.

Pagan is one of Myanmar's biggest money-spinners. Officials say over 70,000 foreign tourists visited Pagan last fiscal year, spending 750,000 dollars in entrance fees, an increase of some 40 percent over the previous year.

Total tourist revenues for Pagan have not been released.

The area some 400 kilometres (248 miles) north of Yangon is a must stop on many visitors' itineraries, but travel agents in the capital expressed frustration with the latest plans.

"Everybody seems to feel that it was not a very good idea," said one tour guide, adding that there is disappointment that authorities have not cooperated with UNESCO.

--------------------------------------------------------------

Heat, SARS fears to delay Myanmar school reopening

Mon May 12, 6:27 PM ET

YANGON, Myanmar (AP) _ SARS fears and fierce heat have delayed the start of the new school year in Myanmar by two weeks, officials said Monday.

Myanmar has not confirmed any cases of severe acute respiratory syndrome, though 46 people showing SARS-like symptoms have been admitted to the Contagious Diseases Hospital in Yangon since April 8, a doctor said on condition of anonymity.

He said 29 of the patients, including an unidentified high-ranking military officer, have been discharged. The status of the others was not immediately known. Information is tightly controlled in this military-ruled country.

The government has delayed the school season due to ``intense summer heat this year,'' and to ease parents' concerns about SARS, an Education Ministry official said .

The decision was made in late April, when temperatures hit record highs of up to 45 degrees Celsius (113 degrees Fahrenheit), he said.

Schools were due to reopen June 2 after a 2 1/2 month break, but will wait until June 16, said the education official, who declined to give his name.

Myanmar Deputy Health Minister Dr. Mya Oo said last month that the government, working with the World Health Organization, has taken stringent measures to prevent a SARS outbreak.

These included forming medical surveillance teams, checking for possible symptoms at entry points, preparing hospital isolation wards and starting public education campaigns.

SARS has killed more than 550 people and infected 7,400 infected worldwide, with most of the deaths in China and Hong Kong.

--------------------------------------------------------------

Workplace discrimination still rampant, ILO says
Sun May 11, 8:52 PM ET

GENEVA (Reuters) - Discrimination remains rampant in the workplace worldwide, depriving women, ethnic and religious minorities and migrants of equal jobs or pay, a report from the International Labour Organisation (ILO) said on Monday.

"There is not one country in the world that can say it is free of this problem," Manuela Tomei, ILO specialist and an author of the report, told a pre-launch news conference.

While the most blatant types of discrimination were fading, "subtle, less visible and more insidious forms" had emerged, including pre-employment testing for HIV/AIDS, the report said.

"Every day, around the world, discrimination at work is an unfortunate reality for hundreds of millions of people," said the United Nations agency's Director-General Juan Somavia in an introduction to the report, titled "Time for Equality at Work".

Women are the most common target of discrimination, suffering from both the "glass ceiling" preventing their advance and significant "pay gaps" even where their educational level was equal to that of men, the ILO said.

Some 158 of the agency's 175 member states have ratified its 1958 convention protecting workers from exclusion or preference on grounds of race, colour, religion and political opinion.

But the United States, China, and Japan, as well as Singapore and Thailand are among states yet to sign up.

The ILO's convention of 1951 on equal pay for equal work for men and women has been ratified by 160 states, again excluding the United States as well as Bahrain, Myanmar and Qatar.

Discrimination against workers with known or suspected HIV/AIDS -- affecting an estimated 42 million people around the globe -- can take many forms, according to the report.

"Pre-employment testing, which results in a refusal to hire, is widespread, even where national and workplace policies against discrimination based on HIV/AIDS are in place, including in southern Africa," it said.

People with disabilities, who account for some seven to 10 per cent of the world's population, are often denied jobs, education and training, the ILO said. Unemployment rates for disabled could reach 80 percent in many developing countries.

In countries with one dominant religion there was widespread discrimination against believers of minority faiths, it said.

--------------------------------------------------------------

China To End Preferential Tax Policy For 20 Commodities
Mon May 12, 3:10 AM ET

Shanghai, May 12 (Dow Jones) - China plans to abolish a preferential import tax policy applied to 20 commodities imported from neighboring countries via boarder trade, according to notices from Chinese customs and the Ministry of Finance Monday.

Effective June 1, 20 commodities - ranging from copper concentrate, wrought copper, lead and zinc to newsprint, pulp and some chemical materials - imported from neighboring countries will no longer enjoy a 50% rebate of the 17% value- added tax and import tariff.

"These commodities will be levied the full value-added tax and import tariff from that time," said an official at the Ministry of Finance in Beijing.

"We abolished the preferential tax policy because it's unfair to other countries which are not adjacent to us...To provide a fair competition environment is one of our commitments to the World Trade Organization," he said.

The policy caught industry analysts' attention after they noticed copper concentrate imports were involved, as China relies heavily on imported concentrates due to the poor quality of domestically produced ores.

The country imported a total of 2.1 million metric tons of copper concentrate in 2002, 506,598 tons of which were from the neighboring Mongolia, Kazakhstan, North Korea, India, Vietnam and Myanmar, according to statistics from customs.

Mongolia is China's largest copper concentrate supplier, with sales to China totaling 471,543 tons last year.

Base metals analysts said the move wouldn't have much impact on the copper producing industry, as major Chinese copper producers already enjoy a preferential tax policy involving 800,000 tons of copper concentrates a year, which is in effect from 2003 to 2005.

According to the policy, issued in April, 30% of the value-added tax for the 800,000 tons of imported concentrates will be refunded to importers, while the remaining 70% will be invested in a Beijing-based copper company that will develop overseas deposits.

--------------------------------------------------------------

The New York Times
Burmese Women Are Reporting Systematic Rapes by Military
By SETH MYDANS

BANGKOK, May 11 ? Women from the Shan minority and other ethnic minority groups in northeastern Myanmar are telling stories of rapes by the military that are sometimes characterized by sadism and that human rights groups say appear to be authorized and systematic.

The State Department investigated the reports, which it called "appalling," and said it found them credible.

The military government of the former Burma has denied that rape is tolerated, asserting that any perpetrators are harshly punished, and calling the reports fabrications by domestic and foreign enemies of their government.

"Isolated rape cases may have happened in certain areas, as is happening in many other countries around the world," the Myanmar government said in a statement last month. "But `systematically using rape as a weapon of war' is just too ridiculous."

The minister for labor, U Tin Win, said, "Severe punishment is always handed down to any member of the armed forces who rape women, be they officers or other ranks or privates.

"The Myanmar society upholds very high standards of decency and culture under the all-encompassing fold of Buddhist teachings," he said.

However, the reports have been supported by widespread and consistent descriptions given by victims and witnesses, including members of separate ethnic groups.

The government must contend with three separate and mutually corroborating reports ? the initial collection of accounts by a Shan human rights group a year ago, an unusual follow-up investigation by the State Department and most recently a report by an independent human rights group.

"Women are raped during forced labor assignments, they are raped while farming, they are raped in their own homes and raped also when they are trying to flee to Thailand," said Veronika Martin, an author of the most recent study, by the human rights group Refugees International, based in Washington.

That report, released last month, made the point that the allegations came from a range of ethnic groups and that the rapes ? sometimes conducted on military property by high-ranking officers ? appeared to be officially sanctioned.

It documented accounts of 43 rapes among women from the Karen, Karenni, Mon, and Tavoyan groups as well as the Shans. It said 75 percent of the women interviewed reported knowing someone who had been raped.

"Aside from the fact that rapes are happening across ethnic boundaries, our report also showed that rape is happening on a widespread basis and is not the result of rogue groups or occasional unruly soldiers," Ms. Martin said.

Because military units are often stationed near villages for long periods and use local people as forced laborers, the report said, three-fourths of the women interviewed were able to identify their attackers by their battalion number.

The initial allegations were made last year by the Shan Women's Action Network, a private human rights group based on the Thai-Myanmar border, which described rape as a systematic weapon of war.

Its report said it had documented 173 incidents of rape or sexual violence against 625 women and girls committed by soldiers from 52 military battalions between 1992 and 2001.

It alleged that 25 percent of the rapes resulted in death and that 83 percent were committed by officers.

In December, the State Department issued a statement saying that it was "appalled by the reports" and that its own interviews in three separate locations appeared to confirm them.

It said its investigators had talked to 12 women who said they had been gang raped by Burmese soldiers during the past five years.

"All of the victims under 15 appeared severely traumatized by their experiences, were disturbed mentally and spoke in whispers, if at all," the State Department said. "The older women sobbed violently as they recalled horrific incidents of their own rapes, as well as brutal rapes, torture and execution of family members."
The Refugees International report included graphic accounts by a number of women.

One, named Thay Yu, said she had witnessed the rape of a woman who was heading for the Thai border with her family, like tens of thousands of other refugees who have fled war, forced relocations and military abuses over the years.

The woman's husband was forced to watch as she was raped, sexually mutilated and killed, according to this account. The soldiers then killed him as well.

--------------------------------------------------------------

The Straits Times - MAY 12, 2003 MON
CROSS-BORDER COOPERATION
Thailand keen on economic hub with neighbours
Summit soon with Laos, Myanmar and Cambodia
By Nirmal Ghosh

BANGKOK - Thailand hopes to use a summit with Myanmar, Cambodia and Laos to steam ahead with plans to develop the border area into an economic catalyst and hub for the region.

Officials are working on the agenda for the summit - which was mooted at a meeting between Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra and his Cambodian counterpart Hun Sen during the Asean Sars summit in Bangkok on April 29 this year.

The summit is expected to take place within three months.

Thai officials are likely to use the opportunity to secure commitments from neighbouring countries to a slew of plans that will require cross-border cooperation.

Issues that may be on the agenda are border trade, the formation of special economic zones and the development of a tourism network.

Thailand is ready to extend technical aid and develop basic infrastructure to spur investment and trade, according to reports quoting National Economic and Social Development Board deputy secretary-general Pornchai Rujiprapa.

He said the country would need to invest about 6.7 billion baht (S$274 million) in the next five years to develop the necessary infrastructure.

Thai officials are looking at ways to exploit potential synergy in border areas.

Economic zones near the border at Mae Sot, Mae Sai and Chiang Rai in Thailand, for instance, will be able to absorb workers from Myanmar and benefit from being close to natural resources used in industries such as value-added agricultural products.

Thailand can help Myanmar grow cash crops in border areas in order to feed units in the economic zones.

Koh Kong and Poipet in Cambodia can have similar economic zones too, officials say.

Developing closer economic ties with these three neighbours dovetails with Bangkok's plans to turn the northern city of Chiang Mai into an international aviation hub.

Meanwhile, Thai officials say plans to establish a highway link from Kanchanburi through Myanmar to India's north-east are on track.

This road will release trading potential for north-eastern India, northern Thailand and the hinterlands of countries such as Laos and Cambodia.

These efforts mirror the administration's foreign policy.

Under Mr Thaksin, Thai foreign policy has been undergoing a change to 'forward engagement', characterised by a hard-nosed style driven by economic imperatives.

Thailand is seen as a potential leader in the immediate region and perhaps even in Asean because after Malaysian Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad and Singapore Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong, Mr Thaksin is the most senior incumbent Asean leader.

Speaking on foreign policy last March, Mr Thaksin said: 'The East-West Economic Corridor, stretching through India, Myanmar, Thailand, Laos and Vietnam, will help integrate the Mekong sub-region with the Indian sub-continent.

'These 'roads of opportunities' will be the basis in opening up trade...and stimulating tourism across the region.

'Sub-regional linkages will contribute to the narrowing of the development gap between the old and new members of Asean, the latter being Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar and Vietnam.

'Thailand is conscious of bridging the development gap within Asean.'

--------------------------------------------------------------

Asian Tribune
Date : 2003-05-12
India - Myanmar - Thailand Highway to take "at least two years"
By Thet Khaing

It would take at least two years to build the Myanmar section of a proposed highway linking Thailand and India, the Indian head of a technical task force set up for the project said last week.

Mr Subir Basu was speaking in Yangon last week after an eight-day survey by 14 officials from the three countries of the transnational highway?s planned route across Myanmar.

The 1400-kilometre-long highway would link the Kayin State town of Myawaddy, on the border with Thailand, with Tamu in Sagaing Division, bordering India.

Mr Basu said large sections of road would need to be built or upgraded in Kayin State and Sagaing Division.

A bridge more than 2000 feet long would also need to be built across the Ayeyarwaddy River linking Bagan and Pakokku, he said.

Mr Basu said work on the two-lane, 10-metre-wide highway would begin after the foreign ministers of the three countries agreed on its route and the funding for the project, he said.

The foreign ministers are due to discuss the project this year but the date and venue are yet to be decided.

The three countries agreed in April last year to build the highway.

- The Myanmar Times -

--------------------------------------------------------------

Democratic Voice of Burma
DVB News (10 May 2003)
Daw Aung San Suu Kyi welcomed by the USDA?

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi and team stopped at Kawlin (northern Burma) for the night yesterday and they are heading to Indaw today. When asked about the situation in Kawlin before the team's arrival in Indaw, the NLD spokesman, U Lwin told the DVB that Daw Aung San Suu Kyi was welcomed by local (government-sponsored) USDA members with signboards and placards which say 'oppose those pessimists and stooges who depend on foreign devils' in the middle of the road.

U Lwin : Harassment has become their traditions. 'When they entered Kawlin, they were welcomed by members of the USDA with signboards which say 'oppose those pessimists and stooges who depend on foreign devils. They staged with welcome right in the middle of the town near the high school.

When asked if Daw Aung San Suu Kyi delivered a speech to the local people, U Lwin said:

U Lwin : There must be one but I can't give you the details. The reporter was not allowed to talk to us, that's what I meant communication difficulties. The people from the telephone exchange told him that he was only allowed to talk about personal subjects. I only managed to talk to him at eight o'clock. We could not communicate with him for the whole day. The problems started from the time when she was at Zeegon, Kantbalu and the like. But the details of the speech by Daw Aung San Suu Kyi are still not known.

When asked if there is a NLD signboard (the NLD office is officially opened) in Kawlin, U Lwin said:

U Lwin : No. The signboard was forced to be taken down. It was not taken down in Indaw. The ones in Indaw, katha, Ayadaw and Sagaing were not taken down. The divisional office was not forced to close down either.

Moreover, as the authorities are banning them from communicating with Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, it is not known whether Daw Aung San Suu Kyi and team are heading to Indaw. But, when the DVB contacted with Kawlin NLD office by phone via the township's, a spokesman said that they are expecting the team to be with them at 5pm: Kawlin NLD office : We are estimating that they are somewhere near Nat Twin between Indaw and Kawlin. I can't hear you properly. We are preparing to welcome them. There are people who are coming to welcome them. There must be about 1000 people now.

As Indaw's NLD office was not forced to be taken down, she will be forming the local youth organising committees and talking to the people. During this trip, they were given permission to open township offices at Shwebo and Monywa but because of the objections from local authorities, they were not allowed to open the offices at Shwebo and Kawlin, said U Lwin. Daw Aung San Suu Kyi and team will be resting at Katha tonight and they are expected to continue to Monyin and Myitkyina tomorrow.

--------------------------------------------------------------

Reactions on ICG's report: 'Myanmar backgrounder: Ethnic Minority Politics'
DVB News
(2003 May 8)

In a statement: 'Myanmar backgrounder: Ethnic Minority Politics' issued yesterday by the International Crisis Group [ICG] says that 'while the world's attention for the past decade has focused on the struggle between the military government and the political opposition over national power, these underlying conflicts perhaps represent a more fundamental and intractable obstacle to peace, development and democracy.'

'The most fundamental grievance of ethnic minorities in Myanmar today is their lack of influence on the political process and thus on decisions that affect their lives. Like society at large, they have been disenfranchised by a strongly centralised military state that regards them with intense suspicion. They have felt the loss of political and economic power even more acutely than the majority population as both the government and the officer corps are overwhelmingly Burman in make-up and widely perceived as a foreign force,' added the statement.

U Aye Tha Aung, the Chairman of Ethnic National Committee of the CRPP gave his reactions on the statement in conjunction with current situation as follows:

U Aye Tha Aung : The main grievance of ethnic nationals is to do with politics. Currently, as for the politics inside Burma, many ethnic national parties won the elections. But, the current SPDC authorities abolished the parties who won the election. Because of that they are unable to participate in politics freely. They have no rights to rally. This is a kind of political loss. We, the ethnic nationals feel aggrieved about the loss.

Phado Mahn Sha, the General Secretary of the Karen National Union [KNU] agreed that ethnic nationalities are unable to form a nation-wide organisation that could take part in widespread talk for the nation's future:

Phado Mahn Sha : What the ICG said is true. The reason for that is not that the ethnic nationals do not want to do it or they are unable to do it or they don't have the abilities to do it. The SPDC itself tries to destroy and disrupt our efforts whenever we are trying to do it. The ethnic national organisations which are under
the SPDC's control are unable to organise and discuss freely among themselves. Or it would be very good for the international community to help to organise an ethnical conference or consultation which could be participated by either legal parties, or ceasefire groups inside the country or ethnic organisations abroad or all the groups.

Both Phado Mahn Sha and U Aye Tha Aung fully agree with the ICG that the ethnic nationals are essential in building peace in Burma:

U Aye Tha Aung : When you try to solve the future of Burma, without solving the desires of ethnic nationals, their political aims and their participations, the efforts for peace and democracy of Burma would not be perfect.

Phado Mahn Sha : In my view, the future nation we are trying to build will be based on democracy and federalism. Democratic system means that the nation's central power has to come from people.

Similarly, in the federal or union system, the desires of ethnic nationals are the main things. The role of the participations of ethnic nationals is high. Without the participations of ethnic nationals or without giving them full participation, we won't be able to build a true federal system. You won't be able to achieve the unity of ethnic nationals and national reconciliation. Therefore, we believe that we need to have the full participating role.

--------------------------------------------------------------

Mizzima News Group
India actively exporting arms to Burma
Vishnu Som
NDTV Sunday, May 11, 2003 (New Delhi):

In a clear sign of a growing strategic interest in southeast Asia, India is now actively exporting arms to Burma. According to sources, this includes the transfer of 80 Indian made mountain guns to the Burmese military junta earlier this year.

The Ministry of Defence has confirmed to NDTV that exporting weaponry to Burma is part of a strategy to establish closer links with Burma's military regime in order to counter the growing Chinese influence in the region.

In February 2001, India's former foreign minister Jaswant Singh kick-started what was seen as a new friendship with the Burmese government.

On that visit to Rangoon, India invested heavily - inaugurating a Rs 121 crore highway between the two countries besides looking into hydro-electricity and other infrastructure projects.

Two years later, the government has confirmed that the sale of weaponry is an essential element of the evolving relationship. In a statement to NDTV, ! the Ministry of Defence said, "As part of the government policy of export promotion and development, India is inclined to export arms to countries, including Burma."

Sources tell NDTV that this has included the sale of up to eighty 75 mm mountain guns that were transferred from Binaguri in West Bengal earlier this year, in addition to small arms and ammunition.

After years of shunning Burma on the grounds of human rights and the lack of democracy, the government is now actively trying to woo the top Burmese leadership. Top junta leaders and their families often come to India for medical treatment, their children are educated in Indian schools and colleges and high ranking Indian intelligence officials actively liaise with their Burmese counterparts.

As far as India's intelligence authorities are concerned, the reasons for this are clear:

Chinese warships and submarines dock regularly in Burmese ports.

China has an electronic listening post on the Burmese Cocos islands, which can monitor Indian missile tests off the coast of Orissa.

Pakistan has joined China in signing an intelligence agreement with Myanmar to monitor India's force deployments in the Northeast and the Bay of Bengal.

Two top Pakistani nuclear scientists - Dr. Suleiman Asad and Dr. Mohammed Ali Mokhtar - were given shelter in Myanmar in November 2001 once the US began probing Pakistan's links with the Al Qaida network.

"In our security concerns, there's this fixation with Pakistan and the West. Nobody talks about the East. It's an old invasion route. All our insurgencies at some stage had a basis in Burma," says Maj Gen (retd) Ashok Mehta, a defence analyst.

The full extent of India's military links with Burma remain a closely guarded secret but government sources tell us that the evolving relationship is working. The junta has been instrumental in destroying NSCN and ULFA camps in its territory though the long-term goal remains to prevent Beijing's long-term plan of developing Burma into a strategic gateway into south Asia.