ဖော်ပြချက်/အကြောင်းအရာ:
"Is it possible for Myanmar to take a path to
sustainable development that would avoid
the pitfalls of the orthodox development
paradigm? This report argues that this is not
only necessary but possible.
Before elucidating this alternative paradigm,
the report discusses Myanmar?s economic
past and where it?s headed under the current
paradigm. Starting with land and agriculture,
it explains how the repressive extraction of
the agricultural surplus coupled with massive
land-grabbing produced a crisis-ridden and
stagnant agriculture during the military
regime. It then argues that the
Agriculture
Development Strategy and Investment Policy
(ADS) proposed by the multilateral agencies
will simply insert Myanmar into a regional
process of agricultural and natural resource
extraction that is termed, euphemistically,
the ?value chain,” and further a process of
?accumulation by dispossession” of peasant
households and ethnic communities stemming
from a fatal combination of coercive and
market mechanisms.
The paper then moves to a discussion of
industrial policy, where it probes how and
why the military regime?s experiments with
industrialization failed, after which it lays
out a critique of the foreign investment-led
and export-oriented industrialization process
promoted by the Japanese government,
subjecting to close scrutiny the key pillars of
this strategy: economic corridors to promote
regional connectivity, special economic
zones (SEZ?s), and the ?fragmentation” of
the process of production that is supposed to
benefit Myanmar.
In the next section, the report takes up the
debate over Myanmar?s energy future and
closely examines the pros and cons of the coal,
hydro, and renewable energy paths, showing
how the coal and hydro options, are strongly
influenced in part by corporate, institutional,
and geopolitical interests, while raising some
issues with respect to one of the proposed
renewable energy strategies.
Moving from energy policy to a discussion
of an extremely influential economic group,
the so-called cronies, the paper takes a close
look at the different conglomerates that have
been favored by the military regime which
now dominate Myanmar?s economy, touches
on the National League for Democracy (NLD)
government?s current relations with them,
and discusses the likely future of the cronies
in the foreign investment-led strategy favored
by the Japanese and the international donors.
It comes to the conclusion that without
significant restitution for past plunder and
strict tax rules aimed at redistributing a
significant part of their wealth, the cronies
will not desist from their predatory ways, thus
jeopardizing the country?s economic future.
Finally moving on to the proposal for an
alternative development paradigm, the report
first lays out its critique of the neoliberal
paradigm that guides the proposed strategies
coming from the donors, using Karl Polanyi?s
concept of the ?dis-embedded market.”
An alternative strategy or Post-Neoliberal
Paradigm (PNP) in contrast, would essentially
be one where the market is re-embedded
in and governed by a matrix of overarching
values.
The paper then recommends an agriculture-
led PNP for Myanmar, laying out the key
principles that would guide it, such as the
priority of equality, synergy between the
economy and the environment, subsidiarity,
and democratic decision-making in all aspects
of economic management. With respect
to the role of the agricultural sector in the
PNP, the report contends that among the key
institutional preconditions for the success of
such an approach would be the establishment
of a body to dispense agrarian justice and the
repeal and amendment of a number of land-
related laws.
Moving on, the paper proposes an agriculture-
and countryside-led industrialization process
promoted by local community enterprises,
cooperatives, small and medium private
enterprises, and state enterprises that focus
on socially useful production such as making
e
xecutive
s
ummary
transnational
institute
Paradigm Trap: The development establishment?s embrace of Myanmar and how to break loose
|
7
industrial inputs for organic agriculture,
medicinal products for treating tropical
diseases and relieving pain, and solar and
renewable energy devices for a decentralized
renewable energy path.
The elements of an alternative trade strategy
are then highlighted, followed by a discussion
of what a solar-based energy infrastructure
would entail. The report concludes with a
discussion of process and proposes principles
that would guide the elaboration and
implementation of an alternative PNP..."
ရင်းမြစ်:
Transnational Institute (TNI) and Paung Ku (PK)
Date of Publication:
2018-05-24
Date of entry:
2018-05-26
Grouping:
- Individual Documents
အကြောင်းအရာ/အမျိုးအစား:
Language:
English
မှတ်တမ်း:
ပုံစံ:
pdf
အရွယ်အစား:
882.16 KB
