??On the definition of ?Law ?, the author has quoted Holland, Woodron Wilson.Regarding rules of natural future the author sayes two: nemo Judex is Causa Sua (nobody is to be Judge in his own cause) and audi alteram partem (hear the other side, the parties are be given a fair hearing.) The question is the S.P.D.C is violator of both these rules and author makes no comment on these. For e.g. under State Protection Law, activists are put under detention by Security Board under Home Ministry. The dentening authority is the Home Ministry and decision made of detention is by the same body. It is judge of its own cause. About fair hearing, almost all trials are held in secrecy and hardly there is right of defense. The article is flawed as these fundamentals have not been brought out...??