[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index
][Thread Index
]
[theburmanetnews] The BurmaNet New
Reply-To: theburmanetnews-owner@xxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: [theburmanetnews] The BurmaNet News: June 18, 2000
______________ THE BURMANET NEWS ______________
An on-line newspaper covering Burma
______________ www.burmanet.org _______________
June 18, 2000
Issue # 1556
The BurmaNet News is viewable online at:
http://theburmanetnews.editthispage.com
NOTED IN PASSING:
*Inside Burma
SHAN HERALD AGENCY FOR NEWS: "DRUG CONFERENCE" IN MONGTON
SHAN HERALD AGENCY FOR NEWS: POPPY ACREAGE TO BE INCREASED UNDER
JUNTA DIRECTION
*Regional
THE BUSINESS TIMES (SINAGPORE): EU RENEWS FOCUS ON RELATIONS WITH ASIA
AP: US DRUG POLICY MAKER IN CHINA
BANGKOK POST: CROP RAIDS BY BURMESE TROOPS SOAR
BANGKOK POST: BURMESE BLAMED FOR ILLNESS
*International
SOUTH CHINA MORNING POST: UN CRITICISED OVER TOURISM SEMINAR
*Economy/Business
BANGKOK POST: OPEN BORDER SEEN AS ROAD TO PROSPERITY
NEWS & VIEWS FROM MYANMAR: AVERAGE NATIONAL ECONOMIC GROWTH STANDS
6.47%
*Opinion/Editorials
MYANMAR INFORMATION COMMITTEE: "A RESPONSE TO MR. JOSEF
SILVERSTEIN'S OPEN LETTER TO MYANMAR EMBASSY IN LONDON
EUROBURMANET: PUBLISH THIS IF YOU PLEASE?RESPONSE TO FRANCIS
CHRISTOPHE'S "TOTAL AND THE CYBERPLOT"
LETTER: RE BOOK EXCERPT: FRANCIS CHRISTOPHE, "TOTAL AND THE
CYBERPLOT"
BURMANET: A NOTE ON EDITORIAL POLICY FROM THE EDITOR REGARDING "TOTAL
AND THE CYBERPLOT
*Other
MIZZIMA: BURMESE WOMEN PLAN RALLY ON "WOMEN OF BURMA DAY"
FOREIGN CORRESPONDENTS CLUB OF THAILAND: BOOK LAUNCH: "EARTH RIGHTS:
LINKING THE QUESTS FOR HUMAN RIGHTS AND ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION" BY
TYLER GIANNINI
__________________ INSIDE BURMA ____________________
SHAN HERALD AGENCY FOR NEWS: "DRUG CONFERENCE" IN MONGTON
June 17, 2000
According to a report received by S.H.A.N. during the last week of
May, a meeting between drug operators was held in Mongton under the
auspices of a junta official.
The meeting, presided over by Capt Kyaw Myint, Company 1, IB 65
(Mongton), was convened at the Battalion command post on 18 May and
was attended by 10 "representatives" from both sides of the border,
namely:
1. "Lao Wu", 47, Banmai Nawngbua, Chaiprakarn District, Chiangmai
2. "Lao Yung", 49, San Makawkwarn, Fang District, Chiangmai 3. "Lao
Koi", 51, Wawi, Mae Suay District Chiangrai
4. Janu, 47, Nawngphai, Mawngpin Tract, Fang District, Chiangmai 5.
Jala, 41, Nawngphai, Mawnpin Tract Fang District, Chiangmai 6. Jawu,
44, n.a.
7. Jashay, 47, n.a.
8. Li Hsien, 50, Huey Khailong, Mongton
9. Johnny, 40, Wa representative
10. Capt. Kyaw Myint, Junta representative
According to the "resolutions", the buyers from across the border
would purchase their "commodities" from Li Hsien and Johnny, both of
whom would set identical prices; security from the place of purchase
to the border would be handled by the army; and, if the participants
of the meeting could find other buyers, they would also receive a
commission.
Refineries in the area had the capacity to produce 5,000,000 pills of
amphetamines and 30 blocks of heroin each moth for sale, according to
Capt. Kyaw Myint.
Reported by: Maihoong
____________________________________________________
SHAN HERALD AGENCY FOR NEWS: POPPY ACREAGE TO BE INCREASED UNDER
JUNTA DIRECTION
June 18, 2000
The population in Mongton has been on the increase since outsiders
drawn by the local commanders' policy of indulgence, have been moving
into the area to clear land for the next poppy season, said sources
from across the border.
People from Taunggyi and Loilem districts have been swarming by the
hundreds to warlord Khunsa's former "Free Territory" west of Mongton
during the last month and busy preparing new poppy fields from
Mongkyawt and Monghe to Sankang and Khailong, they said.
The new commander in Mongkyawt, Capt Aung Myint, Company 3, IB 225,
who recently replaced Capt Thein Win, Commander Company 5, IB 65, was
reported to have his junior officers informed the populace that
poppies would be allowed to grow at the tax rate of 0.30 viss (1 viss
= 1.6 kilogram) per acre and each family was expected to work at
least 3 acres.
The price of rice is also rising high, at B. 20 per liter, which is
more than twice the price along the border communities in Thailand,
said sources. "But these people don't mind, because they are being
financed by the Chinese 'pawliang's (bosses)," said one source.
The area, especially Mongkyawt and Monghe, was once depopulated when
the war between Khun Sa's Mong Tai Army and Rangoon was at its height
in 1994. Due to the extrajudicial killings and other abuses by the
junta troops, hundreds had fled into Thailand.
Reported by: Seng Khao Haeng
____________________________________________________
___________________________ REGIONAL ___________________________
THE BUSINESS TIMES (SINAGPORE): EU RENEWS FOCUS ON RELATIONS WITH ASIA
[Abridged]
17 Jun 2000
Series of meetings ahead as bloc seeks to extend its global political
reach
>From Shada Islam in Brussels
RELATIONS with Asia are back on the European Union's crowded foreign
policy agenda as the 15-nation bloc seeks to extend its global
political reach. Meetings with Asean, India and members of Asem, the
process of Asia Europe Meetings launched in 1996, will be held in
Lisbon from June 26-28, followed in July by summit talks with
Japan...
Portugal, current president of the EU, has laboured hard to put
relations with Asean back on track. After months of diplomatic
efforts, a meeting of EU and Asean officials has been scheduled for
Lisbon on June 26-27 to relaunch region-to-region political talks.
Preparations are also under way to hold long-awaited ministerial
talks between the two groups, probably in Laos, just after the Asem
summit in Seoul on Oct 20-21.
Political contacts between the EU and Asean have been at a standstill
for the last three years following Myanmar's entry into Asean.
However, diplomats say there is growing recognition in both regions
that it is time to push EU-Asean relations forward despite
disagreements over Myanmar.
As such, representatives from Myanmar will be attending the meeting
in Lisbon and the ministerial dialogue in Laos despite the EU policy
of economic sanctions against the country.
EU insiders say Britain and The Netherlands, which were initially
hostile to political contacts with Myanmar, have agreed to
participate in meetings attended by Myanmar diplomats and its foreign
minister, following a recent EU decision to toughen sanctions against
Yangon. The new sanctions package includes a comprehensive blacklist
of some 200 of Myanmar's military leaders who are banned from
travelling to Europe. But EU insiders say no such restrictions are in
force for either Myanmar's foreign minister or diplomats from the
country.
"Essentially the EU has taken an important decision to delink its
policy towards Myanmar from its wider desire to have closer relations
with Asean," an official stressed.
But Myanmar can be expected to be quizzed in detail about both its
economic difficulties and continuing refusal to open a dialogue with
pro-democracy forces, say sources. A delegation of EU officials is
expected to visit Yangon in September as part of the union's policy
of trying to maintain a discussion on human rights with the
country...
____________________________________________________
AP: US DRUG POLICY MAKER IN CHINA
[Abridged]
Saturday June 17 11:27 AM ET
BEIJING (AP) - The United States' senior anti-drug policy-maker
arrived Saturday in China to forge strategies for combating drug
trafficking and setting up effective treatment programs.
Barry McCaffrey, director of the White House National Drug Control
Policy Office, is the first U.S. ``drug czar'' to visit China. His
five-day stay, months in the making, comes just ahead of Secretary of
State Madeleine Albright's stopover in Beijing next week.
The two visits are part of intensifying diplomacy between the United
States and China, whose relations have only slowly recovered from the
U.S. bombing of the Chinese Embassy in Yugoslavia 13 months ago. But
the missions also underscore the difficulties in reviving ties.
Over two days of meetings in Beijing with China's national police
force, McCaffrey said he hopes to broaden cooperation in law
enforcement, sharing intelligence on trafficking in heroin and
methamphetamines and exchanging experiences on treatment programs.
To advance that effort, he will tour a treatment center in Kunming,
capital of southwestern Yunnan, ``an embattled frontier province that
is a gateway for the massive amounts of heroin ... that are produced
in Burma,'' McCaffrey said shortly after arriving in Beijing...
``This drug issue has such profound impact on allies who are
important for other reasons: because their political, economic future
is vital to regional stability,'' McCaffrey said. ``Standing with
China will pay huge benefits to the region and therefore indirectly
to the United States.''
McCaffrey, who will also visit Hong Kong, Vietnam and Thailand,
described trafficking networks in the region as organized, complex
and international...
Yang Fengrui, director of the Chinese Ministry of Public Security's
anti-drug office, reported in March that China had 681,000 drug
addicts last year, a 14 percent increase over the year before.
While believed to underestimate the problem, the figure shows China's
growing problems with drugs. Using harsh measures, the government
wiped out rampant opium addiction in the first decades of communist
rule. But drug abuse returned over the last 20 years as free-market
reforms brought increased trade and travel.
Yang, the Chinese official, raised an alarm in March over a surge in
drug trafficking into China from Southeast Asia. Last year, he said,
police confiscated 5.3 tons of heroin and 16 tons of methamphetamine,
also called ``ice.'' The amount of ``ice'' seized was 10 times higher
than the previous year...
____________________________________________________
BANGKOK POST: CROP RAIDS BY BURMESE TROOPS SOAR
June 18, 2000.
Farmers say Thai forces not protective
Subin Khuenkaew
Doi Lang, Chiang Mai
Farmers living near this disputed t border hilltop complain that the
military is failing to protect them from Burmese soldiers who are
raiding their plantations with impunity.
Their patience is wearing thin.
The thefts have been going on for four years and are becoming more
frequent. Local authorities are fully aware of the situation but have
taken no action to stop it, villagers said.
Thailand and Burma have both deployed troops at Doi Lang.
But both countries have agreed not to use force to settle the dispute
over sovereignty of the 32-sq km hilltop which was once the
stronghold of drug warlord Khun Sa.
A villager at nearby Ban Pang Ton Dua said the situation could not be
allowed to continue as their livelihood was being affected.
"The Burmese soldiers regularly come and steal lychees and tea leaf
from our plantation.
"Sometimes there are five, six or seven of them, all carrying
weapons.
"We have been suffering from this for four years and it has gone
beyond the point of toleration," said the villager, who refused to be
named.
Ban Pang Ton Dua residents said many of them had business loans from
the Bank for Agriculture and Agricultural Co-operatives and the
thefts were affecting their ability to repay.
"We really are suffering but no one seems to be helping us," said a
villager.
The most recent, and blatant, raid occurred on Friday, when local
authorities organised an evacuation drill for 400 villagers in the
area. "We were busy taking part in the drill when the Burmese
sneaked in and stole all our tea leaves," said a villager.
Maj-Gen Somboonkiat Sitthidecha, commander of the Pha Muang task
force, conceded that the problem existed. But he said he had given
orders it must be settled peacefully. The Burmese troops had a
serious food shortage, he said.
He was in contact with the Burmese commander, and most of the time
the miscreant soldiers were heavily punished, Maj-Gen Somboonkiat
said. He denied the military had sat idly by while the thefts
occurred. Thai soldiers interviewed by the Bangkok Post said they
feared the problem would get worse if the border dispute was not
settled soon.
Each side has deployed more than 1,000 troops in the area. The
villagers have begun hiring armed guards to protect their
property. "With everyone holding weapons in their hands, an accident
could happen anytime," said an officer.
____________________________________________________
BANGKOK POST: BURMESE BLAMED FOR ILLNESS
June 17, 2000
Supamart Kasem in Tak and Anucha Charoenpho in Bangkok
The presence of 150,000 Burmese workers and refugees in Tak has put
malaria at the top of a list of serious communicable diseases in the
province.
Deputy Public Health Minister Kamron na Lamphun said the presence of
the workers was a factor in the spread of epidemic diseases including
malaria since many of them were carriers.
"The most serious communicable disease is malaria. Last year, there
were more than 83,000 malaria patients, of which 50,000 were Burmese.
"The infection ratio per population was 90.44:1,000. This was the
highest in the country and there was a tendency that the germs would
be more resistant to medicines," Mr Kamron said.
He said there were 60,000 refugees at shelters in Tha Song Yang, Phop
Phra and Umphang, 35,000 workers at 115 industrial factories in five
border districts and seasonal immigrants.
"In terms of population density, Mae Sot district is considered a
district that has more aliens than Thais.""These people [aliens] are
packed in residences with poor sanitary conditions which allow the
disease to spread," Mr Kamron said.
Yesterday he visited several hospitals in three border districts of
Tak to gather information about health and environmental problems and
the spread of communicable diseases.
Dr Withaya Sawatwuthipong of Mae Sot hospital said disease
observations during 1997-1999 showed that malaria ranked top in terms
of the number of patients and cause of death in Tak, followed by
diarrhoea, severe diarrhoea, TB, Aids, measles and tetanus.
__________________ INTERNATIONAL __________________
SOUTH CHINA MORNING POST: UN CRITICISED OVER TOURISM SEMINAR
Friday, June 16, 2000
WILLIAM BARNES In Bangkok
The United Nations cultural arm has shocked critics of Burma's
military regime by becoming involved in a seminar to promote
tourism. "This is wholly unacceptable. It's outrageous. What can
they be thinking of," said Yvette Mahon of Burma Campaign UK.
The furore erupted after the ruling junta announced on Tuesday that
it would host a seminar in Rangoon next week on "safeguarding"
cultural heritage and the tourism industry. The junta said it would
be held "in co-operation" with the United Nations Educational,
Scientific and Cultural Organisation (Unesco).
Western human rights organisations have mounted a vigorous campaign
to persuade tourists to shun Burma, citing opposition leader Aung San
Suu Kyi's warnings that the bulk of tourists' money goes "straight
into the pockets of the generals".
The anti-tourist campaign can claim some success since visitor
arrivals remain pitifully low, although poor facilities may also be a
factor.
"Anyone who promotes tourism in Burma must do so in flagrant
disregard of the human rights abuses involved," said Lara Marsh of
Tourism Concern, a British-based holiday watchdog.
UN agencies are usually careful to only provide humanitarian
assistance inside Burma.
The regional adviser for culture in Asia and the Pacific, Richard
Engelhardt, said the news was a surprise to him: "I was not
consulted," he said. Other UN officials said privately that Burma's
military regime was keen to rope in international organisations to
bolster its legitimacy.
Unesco has exposed itself to criticism at a time when the anti-tour
crusade has hotted up, with last month's call for the boycott of the
Lonely Planet guides until the Burma publication is withdrawn.
_______________ ECONOMY AND BUSINESS _______________
BANGKOK POST: OPEN BORDER SEEN AS ROAD TO PROSPERITY
S U N D A Y, J U N E 1 8 . 2000
[Abridged]
The business sector in Kanchanaburi has teamed up with provincial
authorities to push for the opening of more border trade points to
exploit the potential in Burma. But they are facing an uphill climb.
Frustrated by the long delays in the government's border development
plans, local business circles have accused certain state agencies of
obstructing development and growth.
A case in point is Hay Mong/Ban Bonti in Saiyok district. The local
Industrial council has long pushed for a permanent checkpoint to
facilitate a trade route to Tavoy in Burma, where many development
projects are underway. A deep sea port is to be built and some Thai
entrepreneurs have been granted concessions for tin mining.
Yet, the area, located in tambon Ban Bonti, is classified as Grade 1A
watershed. In addition, the government insists border conflicts in
the area are yet to be settled.
But Prateep Pongwittayapanu, local businessman and secretariat of the
Provincial Chamber of Commerce, strongly disagrees. Like many
business people, he sees Kanchanaburi becoming the gateway not only
to Tavoy but to the India sub-continent, the Middle East and
ultimately Europe.
"Government agencies are merely obstructing development and growth.
The locals on both sides of the border have crossed Huay Mong to
trade with one another for more than a century," he says.
There are several frontier points on the requested opening-list. The
local Industrial Council and the Chamber of Commerce say the
permission will promote trade, tourism and industrial development.
Other provincial and district agencies such as the livestock
department believe they can stem the cattle and buffalo smuggling.
But debate over the prospects of each area continues as some fear
several lush forests will be destroyed if the ' proposals get the
green light. For example, concerns have been raised that the opening
of around 30 frontier points along Kanchanaburi's 370-kilometrelong
border- will worsen drug and livestock smuggling from Burma and
Bangladesh. At present, most trade in the area is small-scale.
Huay Mong/Ban Bonti is one of the four main crossings in the province
which entrepreneurs believe should be granted permission to open as
either temporary or permanent checkpoints. Others are:
ò Three Pagoda Pass in Sangklaburi district. At present, the volume
of trade in the area is small and it serves mainly as a temporary
checkpoint for tourism. However, the provincial committee is
conducting a feasibility study to develop it into a permanent
checkpoint in the near future. ò Ban Hin Kong ( E-tong) in Thong Pha
Phum district where the Thai-Burmese Yadana gas pipeline lies. The
province wants the border opened as a trade pass. But the Burmese
government opposes the idea for fear of the pipeline being
sabotaged. ò Ban Mae Thamee or Ban Nam Pu Ron in Muang district.
This crossing was chosen after efforts to open Huay Mong/Bonti
failed. The House Committee on Tourism and Industry in western
provinces granted permission to facilitate trade with Tavoy. The
area is considered quite suitable being only 75km from town with
adequate infrastructure, particularly roads. The land is also flat,
not mountainous as in many border areas. The area is also considered
to have potential for trade and tourism.
Yet, local business circles prefer Huay Mong/Bonti. However,
considerable investment would be needed for road construction.
IMPATIENT FOR EXPLOITATION
Entrepreneurs are getting impatient with the government's lack of
enthusiasm for exploiting Burma's great economic potential. Officials
have only included Three Pagodas Pass and Ban Nam Pu Ron as main
crossings in the province in their urgent plan for development. Other
regions include Chong Mek in Sirinthorn district in the northeastern
province of Ubon Ratchathani and Sa Dao in Sadoa district in the
southern province of Songkhla.
>From a tourist point of view, the busiest points are Three Pagoda
Pass and Wat Wiwekaram of Laung Poh Uttama which together received a
total of 50,417 visits in 1999. At the same time, some 10.8 billion
baht worth of exports passed through from Burma.
A committee was recently set up to map out a tourism development plan
for the area. One particular project was the renovation of a wooden
bridge across the Songalia River. Yet, Mr Prateep says local
entrepreneurs fell the pass should be made into a permanent
checkpoint as soon as possible.
"I don't understand why it has not been made a permanent crossing
like Mae Sot in Tak. From a geographic point of view, Three Pagodas
Pass through many advantages. The route to Burma is more convenient.
We don't have t pass through mountainous areas like there are in Mae
Sot, so heavy goods such as construction materials can be
transported," he says.
Provincial authorities say the disputed border is one of the main
obstacles hampering concrete developments in the area. But Prateep
argues that the problem should not be allowed to obstruct progress.
"The Thai government should persist with negotiations for mutual
benefit," he says.
Local business circles have several times suggested the establishment
of trade zones which can help settle conflicts over both borderlines
and ethnic minorities in the area.
Other main benefits from trade zones include income from taxes and
future investors on both sides. Part of the earnings can be used for
further development and welfare.
Looking to the future, Mr Prateep and other businessmen from the
Provincial Industrial Council say the Three Pagoda Pass can be
developed into a industrial zone if a sea port is constructed at Koh
Kale Kok in Burma . The port would become a major transportation
route to the Andaman Sea, inter national markets in South Asian
countries and even further afield to the Middle East and Europe.
"Koh Kale Kok, like our Si Chang Island, is suitable for 30,000-
40,000-tonne cargo ships. These liners can carry goods for Southeast
Asia and South Asia and cross to Rangoon and so on," he says.
Rangoon has already granted concessions to the Mon minority to build
roads in the area. But due to economic recession two years ago, Power
P. Company, a Thai sub-contractor, withdrew from the project causing
delays.
The road from the Three Pagoda Pass to Koh Kale Kok will save time
and expense. Goods can be transported a shorter distance from Kok
Tale Kuak sea port to the Andaman Sea.
A study of the Savoy deeps port by the Kanchanaburi lndustrial
Council notes that, compared with journeys through the Malacca
Straits, Tavoy can save 20% of shipping costs and six days at sea on
journeys to Europe. Tavoy is also equipped to accommodate 200,000-
tonne cargo vessels.
TRADE POTENTIAL.
Tavoy has long been touted as a new trade route. The National
Economic and Social Development Board (NESDB) has looked into a
possible connection between Kancharnaburi and Tavoy as one of three
proposed land bridge schemes. The others are Mae Hong Son-Laos, and a
Sahaviriya Group project in Prachaub Khiri Khan.
Kanchanaburi has prepared itself for a permanent checkpoint According
to a city planning official, a community city plan of Ban Nampu Ron
has recently been drafted. The plan covers 16,880 rai of military
reserves. Border villages have been built on the western side of the
Kwai Noi River. The lush forest is rich with natural resources,
including minerals and water. Most villagersmainly Thais, Karen and
Mon are farmers and cattle raisers.
But the official warns that the opening up of the forest may lead to
deforestation. Weaving bamboo for wickerwork is abundant in the area
and this can encourage illegal cutting. More importantly, the land is
located in an earthquake area.
Local business circles, however, want more speedy action from the
government to get the development moving. They say the projects are
urgently needed and ask why they should still be subjected to
unnecessarily long delays.
"The provincial authority should be given full authority to open
necessary checkpoints. A fuller development plan and implementation
cam follow," recommends Mr Prateep.
ONGOING DEBATE
Although permission has been granted by the house Committee on
Tourism and Industry to go ahead with the opening of the checkpoint
at Ban Nampu Ron, the proposal has yet to be considered by several
other local agencies.
Meanwhile, the debates about the suitability of various proposed
sites continues to rage. Some businessmen say they are unconvinced
that Ban Nampu Ron will be convenient and safe enough for goods
transportation.
Sompong Chawantanpipat, chairman of Ranong Chamber of Commerce, says
he prefers Ban Huay Mong of Bonti. He insists the Tavoy-Ban Nampu Ron
idea will only be possible if a bridge crossing the Tanao Si River in
Burma is built.
But the river in the area is very deep and such a bridge would be
hugely expensive.
Mr Sompong, who has been granted a tin mining concession in Tavoy,
says the Burmese authorities also support the Hauy Mong/Bonti route
since minority groups in the area are under their control. In lower
areas, there are dangers from minority groups and safety cannot be
assured.
But according to the Kanchanaburi Industrial Council, the 124-km
stretch from Ban Nampu Ron to Tavoy is safe from attacks by ethnic
minorities as Karen troops have been moved to a new location opposite
Ratchaburi. From Ban Nampu Ron across the border to the Tanao Si
River on the Burmese side is a distance of some 16 km. From the Tanao
Si River to Ban Metta, where they have to cross the river, is another
70 km, and it's another 43 km to Tavoy.
To facilitate the trade route, the Burmese government has built
several villages and government outposts in the area.
Yet, Mr Sompong insists that the Huay Mong/Bonti-Tavoy route is more
convenient. He says there is a road from the Kaiwa crossing. At the
same time, a survey has already been conducted for a possible road
from Ban Metta to Tavoy without having to build a bridge.
Despite Mr Sompong's request for a review of the Bonti checkpoint,
the provincial authority and members of Kanchanaburi Industrial
Council say they should concentrate on what they can do now. To go
back to Huay Mong/ Bonti would mean starting again from scratch. The
Council says that the road from Tavoy to Ban Nampu Ron is the most
suitable to build. More significantly, there will be no problem with
forestry regulations at Ban Nampu Ron since the land belongs to the
military.
But Mr Sompong wonders whether the Burmese authorities will agree to
the alternative route. According to his concession agreement, the
goods must be transported through the Huay Mong /Bonti crossing.
Last February, Mr Sompong told a provincial committee meeting on
border development that there are 40-50 tonnes of tin in his mines in
Tavoy. However, due to transportation difficulties, he will only be
able to take about 5.2 tonnes worth about US$10,000through
Kanchanaburi to smelters in Phuket.
Since the Ban Nampu Ron border crossing has not yet been opened as a
checkpoint, Mr Prateep says Mr Sompong wil] instead have to bring his
tin through a border checkpoint in Ranong. As such, both investors
and the province stand to lose considerable business opportunities.
"Investor should be able to save transportation time and costs and
the province should earn taxes," he says.
STEMMING ILLEGAL FLOWS
Meanwhile, illegal cross-border trade continues along the
Kanchanaburi-Burma border, costing the authorities considerable loss
of customs and excise taxes. What's more, the illegal trade affects
the safety and wellbeing of villagers in the area.
The province reports continuous smuggling of cows and buffaloes from
Burma, mainly through mountainous and thickly forested border
crossings in Thong Pha Phurn and Saiyok districts.
The districts have proposed the opening of the checkpoints to put an
end to the illicit trade. And in addition to earning more taxation,
legalising the trade would help prevent spread of livestock diseases,
they add.
The proposed crossings include Khoa Pla Noi and Toadam forest in
Saiyok district, Pa Suk in Thong Phu Phum district, Hok Pan Rai and
Morakha, Anamai and Ban Ton Yang in Sanghlaburi district.
Sangkhla Buri district reports that a large number of cows and
buffaloes have been brought into the country through many crossings.
Last year some 24,050 cows and buffaloes worth 71.9 million baht were
brought into Kanchanaburi, earning the province about five million
baht.
However, a large number of cattle are also believed to have been
smuggled through other crossings. Border checkpoints are expected to
help stamp out the illegal trade.
Similarly, the Ban Ton Ban crossing can be upgraded into a trade
pass. At present, villagers here engage in trade on a minor scale.
Consumer products are sold by Thai merchants, while cows, buffaloes,
rattan and seafood are imported from Burma.
Once the area is upgraded into a trade pass, the local authority
expects trade to increase considerably. It will also encourage
tourism. It will open a route to Maung Ye, one of Burma's main
tourist areas about 60km from the Thai border.
District authorities suggest that the Three Pagoda pass should also
be upgraded into a permanent checkpoint. Again, trade volumes are
quite small so far and villagers pay no tax. If trade were to expand
and more investors came, the authorities would be able to collect
substantial taxes.
Nevertheless, concerns over deforestation persist. Environmentalists
cite the disastrous impact on forests of the Yadana gas pipeline
project. A large tract of Saiyok national park has been destroyed,
they say. Other cases of deforestation in the name of development
include the Taodam and Khao Pla Noi crossings in national parks.
Opening yet more border checkpoints, particularly in watershed areas
and national parks can only damage the forests vet more.
Thai investors target Burma
During the past few years, Thai investors have proposed several big
projects in Burma, which they say is about to become a hot trade and
investment zone.
The projects include:
1. A deepsea port and industrial estate at Mugui-Tavoy in southern
Burma.
2. Construction of a 10-km BontiAmno road. Bonti is in Kanchanaburi
and Amno in Burma.
3. Construction of highway No 88, a 43-km road linking Ban Metta to
Tavoy in Burma.
4. Construction of a bridge across the Tanao Si River on the Burmese
side.
5. The Sahaviriya Group has conducted a feasibility study for the
Golden Gateway project which involves construction of a bridge
from Bang Saphan district in Prachuab Khiri Khan to a deepsea port
in Burma.
6. Power P Company plans to construct a 90-km road from the Three
Pagoda Pass in Kanchanaburi to a deepsea port in Kok Tale Kuak,
Burma.
____________________________________________________
NEWS & VIEWS FROM MYANMAR: AVERAGE NATIONAL ECONOMIC GROWTH STANDS
6.47%
Vol.2 15 June 2000 No.23
The Ministry of Commerce held its first four-monthly meeting for the
year 2000 on 13 June. Speaking on the occasion, Secretary-2 of the
State Peace and Development Council Lt.-Gen. Tin Oo explained the
State's policy in relation to the functions of the ministry, which
was reformed to carry out tasks in a consolidated way in accord with
the new economic policy.
Thirty-five per cent of the nation's GDP is from the agriculture
sector and 21 per cent is from the trade sector. The national
economic growth was five per cent in 1996-97 which was the initial
year of the five-year national economic plan, five per cent in 1997-
98, 6.3 per cent in 1998-99 and 9.6 per cent in 1999-2000; thus the
nation enjoyed a 6.47 per cent annual average economic growth which
exceeded the projected economic growth of five per cent. The private
sector participation also reached 77.2 per cent of the national
trade sector in 1999-2000 up from 66.00 percent in 1988-89. The
nvestments of the private sector increased to 77.00 per cent of the
total investment capital of the nation in 1999-2000 up from 41.9
percent in 1988-89.
_________________OPINION/EDITORIALS________________
MYANMAR INFORMATION COMMITTEE: "A RESPONSE TO MR. JOSEF
SILVERSTEIN'S OPEN LETTER TO MYANMAR EMBASSY IN LONDON
[BurmaNet adds?The Myanmar Information Committee comes under the
jurisdiction of the regime's Minister of Information, who is also
director of the Psychological Warfare Department]
YANGON
June 18, 2000
SPECIAL FEATURE
This office is presenting the reply letter "A response to Mr.
Josef Silverstein's open letter to Myanmar Embassy in London which
appeared in the Nation of 7th June 2000 " for your reading pleasure.
Dear Sir,
The response to the open letter addressed to us from a '' Burma
Expert" need not be very elaborate. It was the election commission
composed of four highly respected civilian citizens who drew up the
election laws of 1990 and defined as to who qualified to stand for
the election although it was the government of the State Law and
Order Restoration Council that formed the commission and declared
it's objectives for the election.
It was considered by most at that time that the election laws of
1947 (which was electing a"parliament", or more correctly
a "Hluttaw", for the then multiparty political system), more
relevant for adaptation than the laws of 1974 which was meant for
electing a Hluttaw, relevant to the single party political system
that was to be adopted. It is therefore clearly a futile exercise
now to rest any argument in his or her favour by mixing up the two
constitutions and drawing justifications purely on legal and
political grounds.
For example, would the United States, to which the expert
apparently belong, elect anyone married to an oriental citizen and
lived abroad for thirty years to suddenly return home and assume the
Presidency especially when the " First Spouse" and the children are
foreign citizens?
Be that as it may, laws were drawn up for the 1990 elections to
which the political parties apparently agreed, otherwise they would
not have participated.
The expert is also stuck to the blunder that the former
Socialist Programme Party and the State Law and Order Restoration
Council were synonymous and cannot simply see that the government in
power stayed out of the elections and only supervised them for
reasons already explained in the " News Release". Anyway it is not
surprising that some so-called experts are too politically biased to
see things as they really are.
At the same time it is clear as day light to see that the Union
of Myanmar is still tolerant enough to allow a political party that
many feel to be a political ally of armed insurgents, a parallel
government and dissidents abroad with colonial sentiments to remain
legally standing.
Above all, when change takes place the change has to be fresh-
not stuck to something that happened a decade ago in the last
millennium.
Yours sincerely,
(Kyee Myint)
Minister Counsellor
____________________________________________________
EUROBURMANET: PUBLISH THIS IF YOU PLEASE?RESPONSE TO FRANCIS
CHRISTOPHE'S "TOTAL AND THE CYBERPLOT"
[BurmaNet adds?The June 14 issue of BurmaNet carried an excerpt from
a book by Francis Christophe about the French oil firm Total's
involvement in Burma. The excerpt, entitled "Total and the
Cyberplot" was about Total, BurmaNet and an American activist in
France who uses the pseudonym "Dawn Star." This is Dawn Star's
reply, which was posted to a number of mailing lists and sent by him
to BurmaNet.]
Dawn Star [dawnstar@xxxxxxxxxxxxx]
This was my response and I stand on it. I dont have time to write
essays about kind of thing. You have my response. Thank you.
***
It appears that the [BurmaNet News] has taken a serious dive if it
believes it [Christophe's book] be true.
However, I do thank BNN for having published it because up until now
I was not aware of its existence, and this now proffers the chance
of response.
I dont know who edited or translated it from French to English, but
its very hard to believe that it was Strider. Futher, the BNN should
have confirmed that information directly with me, Dawn Star.
Strider knows me from our first meeting, in New Delhi, during the
Fernandez hosted pro-freedom democracy conference, at which occasion
I arranged, through the OSI office in Paris, a passage to New Delhi,
for the actor, U Aung Ko. He and I flew down there together. (I paid
my own ticket.) There, I had a private late dinner, with George
Fernandez at his home, now India's Defense Minister. (You might
remember he kicked Coca-Cola out of India in the seventies, and then
was active in the antiPepsi campaign). If anyone wishes to know more
about Dawn Star, all you have to do is contact Hans Janitschek,
former Secretary General of the Socialist International. I worked
for years with him at the United Nations Secretariat, in NYC.
Otherwise, this kind of nonsense shows you why, again, as a
justification, it was necessary to work in FRance, against the
falsifications, and errors of bad reporting. Which is a big subject
in the book, TOTAL, L'ETAT ET LA NOUVELLE ECONOMIE, CHRONIQUE
OFFICIELLE DE L'HORREUR.
For years I had asked for funds from OSI, for our website, and for
the book. WE NEVER GOT A DIME. And this after several proposals
during many years. Further, I often criticized Mr. Soros for the
confused policy he took towards Total. We at EuroBurmanet, were on
the masthead of the BurmaNet news in 1995, 1996, and 1997 for the
Total campaign. We were working together, but not financially or
legally affiliated. We were and always have been independent.
At EuroBurmanet we finance our activities with our own funds and
meager contributions from our friends and supporters. We do not have
Soros, the Rockefeller Brothers or other major capitalists paying
our bills, and telling us what is politically correct or out of line.
In politics and business there is a lot of mud-slinging and
character assassination, and with the Total problem in Burma, the
stakes are high. But I thought, and it now appears I have been
wrong, that our movement had higher standards.
Well, there is still room for hope.
By the way, yesterday, on the Boulevard ST Germain, in the Paris
Left Bank, I was passing out AntiTotal posters in front of some book
stores, and a chap took one, saw the picture of Suu Kyi and the
sinking Erika ship, and thanked me, saying, "I studied five years
with the husband of Aung San Suu Kyi, in Oxford". He spoke several
languages, Tibetain, Sanskrit, etc. That was a nice postive
encounter. and quite different from this direct attack by Burmanet
against Dawn Star that comes at a time now, when I clearly attack
Total and the French state, AND IT SEEMS ONCE AGAIN THE SOROS OSI
BURMANET GROUP needs to distance itself from a direct hit on the
company and its longtime association in Burma.
Politics and business is are strange bedfellows, and Soros is a big
investor in France. Remember that.
So its not unthinkable that forces in Burmanet have chosen to openly
and publicly distance themselves from the aggressive frontal attack
that Dawn Star has undertaken, and had undertaken from the very
beginning, against its investment in Burma.
But its a low cheap shot, and uses weak and empty arguments to do
it, long after the years of those articles cited here indirectly,
without any direct handling of the material. Its all too vague and
empty.
Yet it comes at a time, right during the publication and
distribution throughout France of the book, by Dawn Star, that
clearly and directly attacks Thierry Desmarest as a man of war, and
his company as bent on the politics of war.
Is Soros and Burmanet now siding on the side of oil companies and
other capitalist partners, the banks and others in the money
laundering business, in an attempt to undermine Dawn Star, and those
fighting against the vested interests in crimes against humanity?
If Burmanet is a democratic forum, - and I still believe it is, -
you will see this Response published on the Burmanet News. If it is
not, then you will not. Or is OSI and Burmanet interested in
dominating the Free Burma movement at the expense of other genuine
activities in the human rights movement?
Its a cheap, dark shot against Dawn Star by a French writer who has
not done his research. For whatever motive now (a jealous writer
bent on destroying a fellow writer covering the same territory -
TOTAL-, a transnational rivalry imbued with the alarming scandal of
international politics, corporate power, blood and drugs, oh! how
terribly exciting!!! But how very ignorant and low minded. Better to
have light!
Lets not be humbled by such ignorance.
Be bright and positive and work hard towards the future of Free
Burma. But remember, we know who are true friends are, and who are
the weakened foes.
I gave a copy of my book to Katie Redford of ERI, after the
TotalFinaElf general assembly meeting. I even stood up at the
shareholders meeting and denounced the 2000 people in the hall for
their rude abusive reception of the courageous woman, this in a
direct interogation with the CEO Desmarest. And I met her husband
who is featured in the book. Futher, I am told this morning that the
Nouvel Observator has published a photo of Dawn Star. I have not
seen it. And the Belgium magazine also mentioned Dawn Star in its
report of the Belgium senators who I also met, and who know very
well Mr. Janitscheck in New York.
So this kind of attack on Dawn STar is very weak and specious and
certainly undermines the individual who made it and anyone who cares
to believe it.
metta, dawn star*
The fact is now, some people by error or intention, prefer to mix
things up and confuse the truth. I hope this makes things more
clear. The writer, Christophe... is referring to some stories in the
press which lacked rigorous reporting standards, and I feel as a
journalist that we have an obligation to dig for the truth, and
criticize ourselves and others in our profession, if we ever hope to
get closer to the truth and honest reporting.
Obvious some people have not heeded that lesson.
Dawn Star
____________________________________________________
LETTER: RE BOOK EXCERPT: FRANCIS CHRISTOPHE, "TOTAL AND THE
CYBERPLOT"
Eric Bruce Johnston [ericbj@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx]
July 17, 2000
[Abridged. Johnston is a journalist living in France.]
Title: TOTAL: Entre Maree Noire et Blanchiment
Having read Francis Christophe's generally excellent, polemical
little book and being in the proceeds of wading through the 562 pages
of Dawn Star's "Total: l'Etat et la Nouvelle Economie," and in view
of the former's derogatory remarks concerning 'Dawn Star', I feel
impelled to make some comment. Living in a remote corner of rural
France, and being new to, and not having had the opportunity to meet
any of the protagonists in, the campaign against the Burmese junta, I
have no axe to grind.
Dawn Star's voluminous book, just out, seems to be well documented
and well argued. A monumental nail in the coffin of TotalFinaElf's
Burmese aspirations. It includes voluminous appendixes, but
unfortunately lacks an index which is something of a disadvantage for
a documentary work of this scope. It is perhaps the most detailed
work to date on TotalFina's involvement in Burma.
One thing seems clear. 'Dawn Star' is calling unequivocally for a
boycott of TotalFinaElf whereas open support for this from other
quarters seems not unnaturally somewhat muted, since it is a criminal
offence under French law. (French legislation thus denies the French
citizen one of the prime weapons of defence against the might of
international commerce, and its attendant political corruption)
Maybe this helps to explain why 'plucky little Belgium' is the centre
of gravity for the campaign against TotalFinaElf in the French-
speaking world. It may also be the underlying reason for Aung San Suu
Kyi's frustration, recently expressed to Le Nouvel Observateur:
"Fifty-five percent of the tourists are French, and France is the
principal European investor in the country. Perhaps the French are
not well-informed of the situation in Burma."
If the powers-that-be have thus far hesitated to invoke the
legislation, it is perhaps in order to avoid offering free publicity
to Total's detractors. Besides, it might awaken French people to what
they thought did not concern them,and when they decide to protest
they generally do not go in for half-measures. In a country with
government organizations such as the DGST (remember, they blew up and
sank 'The Rainbow Warrior' in Auckland harbour) they may prefer to
adopt other methods, if the tide appears likely to turn against
them.
Judge for yourself whether "Total, l'Etat et la Nouvelle Economie",
or its author, was subsidized by the firm in question.
[Blurbs from dust jacket deleted]
____________________________________________________
BURMANET: A NOTE ON EDITORIAL POLICY FROM THE EDITOR REGARDING "TOTAL
AND THE CYBERPLOT"
July 18, 2000
BurmaNet is aimed at a community of readers that closely follows
politics and events in Burma. The litmus test for determining what
articles to put in BurmaNet is not simply whether the editor believes
them to be true, but whether, in my judgment, they are significant.
BurmaNet leaves it to the readers to determine the credibility of the
articles included. The excerpt of Francis Christophe's book run by
BurmaNet on June 14 meets the test of significance and it is up to
the readership to estimate credibility.
Leaving aside the debate between Christophe and Dawn Star (which
BurmaNet takes no side in), the reason for including unaltered
material from a range of sources is that an article is often more
important for what it reveals about the author's state of mind than
for its correspondence with reality. By way of example, the regime's
claim carried in today's BurmaNet regarding the economy (See above
NEWS & VIEWS FROM MYANMAR: AVERAGE NATIONAL ECONOMIC GROWTH STANDS
6.47%) is demonstrably not credible. This article is in BurmaNet
not because of the truth of its proposition, but rather, because an
important political actor (the regime) is--however improbably--
asserting the claim.
Strider
_____________________ OTHER ______________________
MIZZIMA: BURMESE WOMEN PLAN RALLY ON "WOMEN OF BURMA DAY"
New Delhi, June 18, 2000
Mizzima News Group (http://www.mizzima.com)
Burma women organizations based in India will hold a peace rally in
New Delhi on Monday morning, the 55th birthday of Daw Aung San Suu
Kyi and "Women of Burma Day".
Daw Aung San Suu Kyi has been leading a courageous non-violent
struggle in Burma against one of the world's most tyrannical military
dictatorships. In May 1990, her party the National League for
Democracy (NLD) got a landslide victory, winning 392 of the 485
parliamentary seats. But, the military junta continues to ignore the
popular verdict.
The women activists are holding the rally at the Jantar Mantar in New
Delhi from 11:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. tomorrow in support of Daw Aung
San Suu Kyi and her democratic movement, according to a joint release
of Burma women organizations based in India.
Burma women organizations in exile have been celebrating Daw Aung San
Suu Kyi's birthday, June 19, as "Women of Burma Day" since 1997.
Moreover, many prominent women activists in India have proposed her
birthday to celebrate as "Women of Asia's Day".
"She is a symbol of inspiration for us because she is not just a
leader of women, she provides courageous leadership to all the
Burmese people and this daughter of Asia has established high
civilizational norms through her leadership of the movement and done
us all proud", said Ms. Madhu Kishwar, the editor of MANUSHI women
and society journal in India.
In her message to Burmese women in exile on the occasion of Daw Aung
San Suu Kyi's birthday, Samata Party president Ms. Jaya Jaitly
said: "We should call this "Women of Asia's Day", because, we women
of Asia most of all, are fighting against violence, economic
domination and the ugly side of armed conflicts. All women of Asia
support Daw Suu Kyi as she gives women courage to face difficulties".
____________________________________________________
FOREIGN CORRESPONDENTS CLUB OF THAILAND: BOOK LAUNCH: "EARTH RIGHTS:
LINKING THE QUESTS FOR HUMAN RIGHTS AND ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION" BY
TYLER GIANNINI
The BULLETIN June 16, 2000 - Number 168
FCCT in Cyberspace
www.fccthai.com
Thursday June 29, 2000 (8pm)
Poisoned or pillaged ecosystems are a breeding ground for all kinds
of human rights abuses. And when human rights abuses are not
respected the natural environment loses its defender, leading to a
downward spiral of more human rights violations and ecological
degradation. Given such linkages, this presents the concept of
earthrights that reflect the connection between human well-being and
a sound environment. Drawing on examples from across the globe, it
highlights the ways in which campaigns for human rights and
environmental protection are often one and the same. The book
concludes that environmentalists and human rights activists alike
must begin to recognize that healthy ecosystems and human rights are
inextricably linked.
Mr. Tyler Giannini will be joined by Pibhop Dhongchai, Chairperson of
Campaign for Popular Democracy and a leader of nearly 100 NGOs which
have been campaigning against the Yadana gas pipeline. Khun Pibhop
was a key figure in pressuring the Thai government to establish a
committee, led by Mr. Anand Panyarachun, to review the gas contract
signed between PTT and the Yadana consortium.
Khun Pibhop will address the government's response to opposition of
the pipeline project and the financial burden of 50 million USD
assumed by the PTT in the "take or pay" contract for the gas. Pibhop
will present slides illustrating environmental damage in the pipeline
area.
________________
The BurmaNet News is an Internet newspaper providing comprehensive
coverage of news and opinion on Burma (Myanmar).
For a subscription to Burma's only free daily newspaper, write to:
strider@xxxxxxx
You can also contact BurmaNet by phone or fax:
Voice mail or fax (US) +1(202) 318-1261
You will be prompted to press 1 for a voice message or 2 to send a
fax. If you do neither, a fax tone will begin automatically.
Fax (Japan) +81 (3) 4512-8143
________________
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Make new friends, find the old at Classmates.com:
http://click.egroups.com/1/5530/6/_/713843/_/961383372/
------------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
theburmanetnews-unsubscribe@xxxxxxxxxxx