[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index
][Thread Index
]
Burma Net News May 28, 1996
Received: (from strider) by igc2.igc.apc.org (8.7.5/8.7.3) id FAA16994; Tue, 28 May 1996 05:20:54 -0700 (PDT)
Date: Tue, 28 May 1996 05:20:54 -0700 (PDT)
------------------------ BurmaNet ------------------------
"Appropriate Information Technologies, Practical Strategies"
----------------------------------------------------------
The BurmaNet News: May 28,1996
Issue # 424
Noted in Passing:
If the Japanese government says it works, show us the proof or
some proof of development toward democracy. Constructive
engagement does not help us to achieve democracy in Burma.
- Aung San Suu Kyi reportedly told the Mainichi Shimbun newspaper.
(See JAPAN URGED TO RECONSIDER PLANS FOR AID)
HEADLINES:
==========
THE NATION:SUU KYI FEARS INDEFINITE JAIL FOR SUPPORTERS
THE NATION: BURMESE OPPOSITION CRITICAL OF ASEAN RESPONSE
THE NATION:SLORC UNCERTAINLY ON HANDLING SUU KYI DETECTED
THE NATION: JAPAN URGED TO RECONSIDER PLANS FOR AID
THE NATION: KIM YOUNG-SAM BACKS BURMA DEMOCRACY CAUSE
BKK POST: JUNTA SAYS REBELS BOMBED TRAIN
BKK POST: WHAT CAN THE BURMESE PEOPLE DO NOW?
MAINICHI SHIMBUN : SUU KYI VOWS TO STAY COURSE
ISBDA : HUNDREDS OF ARRESTS IN BURMA BESIDES THE NLD MEMBERS
BURMANET : BRIEF BUSINESS REPORTS
-----------------------------------------------------------
THE NATION: SUU KYI FEARS INDEFINITE JAIL FOR SUPPORTERS
May 28,1996
Agencies
Pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi predicted yesterday the
military regime will detain some of her jailed supporters
indefinitely and said her personal assistant had been thrown into
a prison notorious for torture.
On the second day of an opposition conference Suu Kyi said that
the ruling junta had arrested at least 262 members of her National
League for Democracy (NLD).
Among the detainees were 238 delegates to the party congress,
which was called to unite surviving opposition candidates who won
392 of 486 seats in parliamentary elections held in May 1990. The
regime never honoured the election results and many of the winning
candidates have already been killed, jailed or driven into exile.
"There are indications that the authorities are going to keep the
elected representatives for much longer than we thought," Suu Kyi
said. "Some delegates have had charges placed against them."
The charges probably would stem from Section 5 of the Emergency
Provision Power Act, which give the military authority to
indefinitely hold anyone alleged to be a threat to the peace and
security of the country. Suu Kyi said that it was "almost certain"
that Win Htein, her personal assistant, and several members of the
NLD's youth wing had been transferred to the notorious Insein
Prison near Rangoon.
Win Htein was taken into custody last week, the last after he
notified the international media of the government's mass roundup
aimed at stalling the party congress, which comes on the sixth
anniversary of the elections and was seen as a symbolic challenge
to the legitimacy of the ruling State Law and Order Restoration
Council (Slorc).
Suu Kyi, winner of the 1991 Nobel Peace Prize, defiantly said in
her opening conference speech on Sunday that the party will hold
several congresses _ implicitly daring the junta to repeat the
mass repression and ignite a fresh round of world condemnation.
Asked how the detainees at Insein would be treated, Suu Kyi
replied, "It depends on the people. Some aren't treated too badly,
but others have had to live in harsher conditions. Some were
forced to sleep on concrete floors, in cold rooms, without food."
The location of the detainees is unknown. The Slorc claimed last
week that they were only being "questioned ... as guests of the
government". None is known to have been released.
Regarding the congress, Suu Kyi said the delegate total had risen
to 18 after "a very brave and enterprising member of parliament
... made a lot of effort to get here."
She said the time had not arrived to discuss whether anyone could
mediate between the opposition and the junta, and discretion would
be required in any case.
In remarks carried yesterday by the state-controlled newspaper New
Light of Myanmar, junta leader Lt Gen Khin Nyunt called Suu Kyi
and her followers puppets of a US-led conspiracy to colonise
Burma. The same newspaper ran an editorial calling the democracy
movement "maggots that can eat away into the flesh".
The crackdown has focused international attention on Burma and
brought fresh criticism of foreign companies eager to profit by
helping the junta to develop Burma's economy, destroyed during
nearly 34 years of military rule.
Suu Kyi, daughter of Burma's independence hero, Aung San, emerged
as opposition leader during street protests in 1988 that crushed
when troops killed hundreds of people.
The United States, Japan, Britain, Germany, France and Australia
have denounced the crackdown, but Burma's Southeast Asian
neighbours, eager to trade with Burma, have been more circumspect.
The White House announced plans to send a special envoy to Europe
and Asia in an attempt to coordinate a response. (TN)
***************
THE NATION: BURMESE OPPOSITION CRITICAL OF ASEAN RESPONSE
May 28,1996
Exiled Burmese opposition member expressed strong disappointment
yesterday that Asean nations have remained silent about the
ongoing military crackdown in Burma.
They also criticised the international community for its lack of
an immediate response to the arrest and detention of over 250
members of the opposition National League for Democracy (NLD)
since last Monday by the Burmese junta.
Tin Maung Win, vice president of the Democratic Alliance of Burma,
which is a platform of a dozen of exiled Burmese dissidents and
ethnic groups, said he was "discouraged and saddened" that only
five nations had stood up to condemn the action of the ruling
Burmese regime known as the State Law and Order Restoration
Council (Slorc).
He said if the arrests of a similar number of MPs took place in
countries like Malaysia or Thailand, "the whole country would be
outraged" and the world community "would vocalise their
condemnation of the action".
"But now it is happening in Burma, and it's so unfair about what
is happening," Tin Maung Win, together with two other exiled NLD
MPs and a representative of the Pa-O ethnic group, said yesterday
in Bangkok.
He urged Asean countries to speak up against Slorc's suppression
of the pro-democratic movement in Burma.
"I'm very, very discouraged and so saddened that Asean nations are
distancing themselves and remaining silent over the recent
developments [in Burma]. I think if they [Asean members] are
really democratic countries, they should be move vocal about
condemning this outrageous action," he said.
Maung Maung Aye and Teddy Buri, two of the 18 exiled NLD MPs who
fled Burma and now take refuge in India, Thailand and the United
States, urged the international community to join with domestic
Burmese pressure and put forward harsher measures to force Slorc
into dialogue with the opposition and ethnic groups.
Maung Maung Aye said pressure from the world community "Is very
crucial at this stage" in order to force Slorc into releasing all
political prisoners and these latest detainees, and to engaged the
opposition in political dialogue.
He suggested that the international community boycott Slorc's
campaign for a "Visit Myanmar (Burma) Year", discourage foreign
investment in the Southeast Asian country, as well as refusing
visas for the ruling Burmese military.
Tin Maung Win urged Asean, especially Thailand, to review its
"constructive engagement" policy towards Burma, saying the recent
mass arrests have proved that the controversial approach "was a
total failure".
Also in Bangkok, about 50 Burmese students and dissidents staged a
protest in front of the Burmese Embassy yesterday afternoon, the
second rally in less than a week to protest at the Slorc
crackdown. (TN)
***************
THE NATION: SLORC UNCERTAINLY ON HANDLING SUU KYI DETECTED
May 28,1996
Reuters
Burma's military government has sent mixed signals to the country
's re-invigorated democracy movement, suggesting there may be some
uncertainty about how to deal with the challenge to its power,
analysts said yesterday.
A day after National League for Democracy (NLD) leader Aung San
Suu Kyi defined government detention of NLD supporters and vowed
to carry on with and even step up the campaign for democracy, the
military rulers seemed uncertain how to respond.
Commentaries in state-run Burmese-language newspapers yesterday
were at odds, one warning the democracy camp it was committing
treason while another took a milder tone, even suggesting support
for democratic principles.
"This dual track does generally reflect there are urgent
discussions going on within the Slorc," one diplomat said,
referring to the ruling military State Law and Order Restoration
Council.
He and other analysts said the reaction, and government attitudes
toward the weekend congress of NLD members, showed there could be
some change to the Slorc hard-line tactics. The Slorc in recent
months has attacked the NLD and tried to make life difficult for
Suu Kyi and her party.
It imprisoned one of Suu Kyi's close friends and other NLD
supporters, prevented her from going to Mandalay and made a steady
stream of attacks in official media on the opposition.
In a crackdown launched last week, the Slorc seized more than 250
NLD members who planned to attend the three-day party congress
that began at Suu Kyi's lakeside home on Sunday. After widespread
international condemnation of the arrests, Slorc spokesmen said
the NLD members had only been detained for questioning because the
meeting might lead to "anarchy".
"What happened last week backfired," one diplomat said. "I think
they underestimated the NLD" Far from being cowed by the arrests
of most of the members due to attend the congress, Suu Kyi opened
the meeting on Sunday saying the NLD would increase its activities
and hold a series of conference to plan party strategy.
"It seems the Slorc has bungled. Far from dismaying the
opposition, they have given it more strength," said another
diplomat, agreeing with a comment Suu Kyi made earlier last week
that the Slorc could be the NLD's secret friend." (TN)
***************
THE NATION: JAPAN URGED TO RECONSIDER PLANS FOR AID
May 28,1996
AFP
Burmese pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi has again urged the
Japanese government to reconsider its plan to resume aid loans to
Burma, Kyodo News said yesterday.
"Japan is one of Burma's aid countries. And that is why it is
important," Kyodo quoted her as saying on Sunday, the same day she
addressed up to 10,000 supporters outside her home in Rangoon.
Suu Kyi reportedly said she wanted Japan to see how far the ruling
junta would go in allowing democracy to develop before it approved
a 20 billion yen (Bt 4.75 billion) loan for the expansion of
Rangoon airport.
National League for Democracy (NLD) sources said that Suu Kyi
asked Japanese ambassador Yoichi Yamaguchi to convey some of the
democracy movement's requests to the junta at two meeting earlier
this month.
The meeting took place on May 17 and 20, shortly before the junta
began arresting NLD candidates who won seats in Burma's election
in 1990.
Suu Kyi's remarks came only days after she reportedly criticised
Japan and members of Association of Southeast Asian Nations for
their of "constructive engagement" with Burma.
"If the Japanese government says it works, show us the proof or
some proof of development toward democracy. Constructive
engagement does not help us to achieve democracy in Burma," she
reportedly told the Mainichi Shimbun newspaper.
Japan has so far brushed aside calls to halt aid to Burma although
Foreign Minister Yukihiko Ikeda urged visiting Burmese counterpart
Ohn Gyaw to release detained activists during talks in Tokyo last
Friday.
Last Thursday, Chive Cabinet Secretary Seiroku Kajiyama said Japan
would not freeze grants to Burma. (TN)
***************
THE NATION: KIM YOUNG-SAM BACKS BURMA DEMOCRACY CAUSE
May 28,1996
Agencies
South Korean President Kim Young-sam yesterday expressed deep
concern over the arrests of over 250 political activists in Burma,
in what his aides called a rare comment on the internal affairs of
another country.
"The president fully understands the situation of Aung San Suu Kyi
and the opposition leaders, as he spent years under house arrest
under military dictators from 1980 to 1983," presidential
spokesman Yoon yeo-Joon quoted the president as saying.
"President Kim is concerned about the arrests of pro-democracy
figures in Burma ... and expressed strong hopes that the Burmese
government will continue its efforts for democratisation and
respect human rights," Yoon added.
Kim, himself a former dissident, became South Korea's first
elected civilian president in 1983 after three decades of military
rule in south Korea. On several occasions he was placed under
house arrest.
In a presidential Blue House statement issued yesterday, Kim
expressed deep concern about the continuing virtual house arrest
of Suu Kyi, the 1991 Nobel laureate and pro-democracy leader and
said human rights should be respected.
"President Kim strongly called upon the Myanmar [Burma] Government
to exert a greater effort for democratisation and respect human
rights," it said.
The spokesman added that Kim, in a November meeting with Burmese
Foreign Minister U Ohn Gyaw, had urged the junta in Rangoon to
promote democracy and allow Suu Kyi political freedom.
Kim's comments came as Suu Kyi's National League for Democracy
(NLD) held the second day of a party congress despite the arrests
of 257 NLD activists.
The opposition roundup has been condemned by Western countries, in
particular the United States, which has announced the appointment
of an official to investigate the detentions. South Korean
opposition leader Kim Daw-jung, who was jailed under past South
Korean military regimes, has frequent contacts with Suu Kyi.
In Manila, a prominent senator urged Philippine President Fidel
Ramos to join the protest against what he called "fascist
repression" in Burma. "I believe it is imperative for us and all
governments that profess to respect human and democratic rights to
condemn the arrests," Sen Ernesto Herrera said. Herrera, a labour
leader and anti-drugs crusader, also chided Burma's military
rulers for "coddling heroin producers."
There was no immediate reaction from Ramos, who has protested at
the execution of Nigerian activist Ken Saro-Wiwa and several
others by the Abacha government. As a general at the time, Ramos
played a key role when the late Ferdinand Marcos imposed
authoritarian rule in the Philippines in 1972 and imprisoned
thousands of political dissenters.
Ramos, however, later joined the opposition that overthrew Marcos
in 1986 and helped quell a number of military coup attempts
against the popular government of Corazon Aquino. (TN)
***************
BKK POST: JUNTA SAYS REBELS BOMBED TRAIN
May 28,1996
The Burmese Government blamed Karen minority rebels for last
Tuesday's bombing of a passenger train near the city of Pegu in
which nine people were killed and nine others injured.
According to Burmese television news reports monitored here, the
bomb, planted on the railway tracks, exploded as the Rangoon-bound
train originating from Mandalay was approaching Pyu, Pegu
Division, about 145 kilometres north of Rangoon.
Southern Force commander Maj Kyi Aung suspected the bombing might
have been the work of either the Karen National Union or the
Karenni Progressive Party. (BP)
***************
BKK POST: WHAT CAN THE BURMESE PEOPLE DO NOW?
May 28,1996
U Aung
Burma obviously is on a collision course and it cannot be stopped.
In any given political situation, especially under dictatorial
regimes, if the predator is portrayed as victim, then this is one
of the hardest problems for anyone to solve. Current apprehensions
about political parties are deplorable and, honestly speaking, are
"ethically reprehensible and rationally disgusting".
In order to have a correct perspective of the current milieu, we
may need to go back to the crux of the problem: the general
elections of May 27,1990.
At the time Burma's junta announced the date of the elections, all
parties concerned said it would not be a free and fair election.
United Nations supervision was even demanded for the poll.
As we understand, and the normal procedures and standards pertain,
election time is a time for distributing party statements. Mass
rallies are called for. True, distribution of party statements was
allowed provided the parties had permission from the Literary
Censor Board under the junta's Ministry of Information.
There were rifts between the authorities and the politicians
during the elections and, yet, when the opposition won most of the
seats, many jumped to the conclusion that the elections were fair.
>From afar, we reached a different conclusion.
The elections were not free and fair whether the opposition won or
the pro-junta party won. As a matter of fact, if the pro-junta
party won the election, the election would surely be judged unfair
and rigged.
We must ask ourselves what happened to our stand that the junta
had no legal authority whatsoever to hold the election. The
purpose of holding a election is to test the public mandate and,
once completed, for the majority party or coalition of parties to
claim executive and legislative powers no matter. This is
regardless of whether the turnout is less than so and so percent
or this or that.
All the reasons for not recognising the results of the election
which the junta itself called are nothing but a farce. A true
democratic system allows the majority party to rule for the
prescribed tenure and also allows a method whereby the people can
remove that party legally. The beauty of the democratic system may
not necessarily be the way representatives are elected; it is how
the elected representatives can be removed legally.
The National League for Democracy (NLD) under the leadership of
Daw Aung San Suu Kyi won the general election held on May 27, 1990
sponsored by the junta. Not long after the victory, the NLD
convened a meeting at the Gandhi Hall attended by all the Peoples-
Representative-Elects (PREs).
The NLD had the moral duty to assume the executive and legislative
duties at the time, but it performed its legislative duty by only
making a few amendments to the constitution drawn up under the
directives of the founding father of Burma, U Aung San, in 1947.
As for the executive duties, instead of assuming power, the NLD
asked that the state power be transferred from the junta. But the
junta could not transfer power to which it had no legal title of
possession. The title to stolen property cannot be passed.
This was the basic constitution point which the NLD failed or
refused to declare, thus forfeiting its superior legal,
constitutional and moral standing and absolute legitimacy. It was
ten, not six years later, that the NLD should have assumed
executive duties.
There is a Burmese saying which states that the tiger will not
become a vegetarian out of pity for the wretched animals. By the
same analogy, the junta should have negotiated then in 1990, right
after the election, with the NLD, not three years later.
They ignored the results of their own creation. They wanted to
participate in the country's political affairs, especially in the
legislature. The NLD, with the overwhelming majority, could have
accommodated the desire of the military leader through
parliamentary proceedings if the junta's reasons were convincing
enough.
Now, instead of making direct deals and adopting an honest
approach, national affairs are conducted as through they are a
personal vendetta. Mud-slinging and name-calling are for lowly
cowards.
I am drawing a parallel for this situation with India's
independence movement. When India was about to gain independence
in August and September 1947, both Pakistan and India witnessed
killings. Winston Churchill, then out of power, made the following
remarks:
"The fearful massacres which are occurring in India are no
surprise to me. We are, of course, only at the beginning of these
horrors and butcheries, perpetrated upon one another with the
ferocity of cannibals, by races gifted with the capacity for the
highest culture and who had for generations dwelt side by side in
general peace under the broad, tolerant and impartial rule of the
British Crown and Parliament. I cannot but doubt that the future
will witness a vast abridgement of the population throughout what
has for 60 or 70 years been the most peaceful part of the world,
and that at the same time will come a retrogression of
civilisation throughout these enormous regions, constituting one
of the most melancholy tragedies which Asia has ever known.
Gandhiji retorted: "If he knew that India would be reduced to such
a state after freeing itself from the rule of the British Empire,
did he for a moment take the trouble of thinking that the entire
responsibility for it lies with the British Empire?"
The current eruption is a puzzle for the general masses because
when Daw Aung San Suu Kyi was released, she repeatedly stated that
"she and the junta have reached understandings but they cannot be
revealed as understandings should be revealed only by both parties
at the same time.
Nevertheless, the people should trust her." Trust, all right, but
what are the understandings? What happened to these
understandings? The people of Burma are not on the side of the
junta, that's for sure, but they deserve to be informed what
transpired and what took place so that we can judge for ourselves
the situation. No matter what, we will keep our loyalty to the
cause _ to restore democracy and human rights which includes the
right to dignity.
As the information flows in, more and more PREs are apprehended
or, according to the junta, temporarily detained for
interrogation.
That reminds me of a story about a villager from a remote area
travelling to another village. On the way he was stopped by a
soldier and asked for his national registration card. The villager
was puzzled and answered: "Why ask for my ID? I am here in front
of you in person." That is, why interrogate the PREs?
Daw Aung San Suu Kyi is right in front of you. If the authorities
are short of gasoline to get to her, they can either ask her to
come to them or give her a call. In case the authorities forget
her phone number, it is 530365. Please stop this national circus;
we are sick and tired of this show.
By all means, we are for national unity and reconciliation. How
it is to be achieved is not a problem, be it brokered or
negotiated. We believe that the central venue for peace and
prosperity is not in the meeting rooms of the UN or the
chancelleries of Europe or Asia or in the US, but inside our
country.
When it comes to the national cause, nothing is too late.
Political settlement is something that can be achieved if the
attitudes are right. The present confrontation makes me deeply
concerned about my fellow countrymen. Allow me to ask both parties
to restrain from extremities and save our nation and the lives of
the people. (BP)
U Aung is the chairman of the Alliance for Democratic Solidarity,
Burma.
***************
Mainichi Daily News, Sunday, May 26, 1996
SUU KYI VOWS TO STAY COURSE
==============
Mainichi Shimbun
==============
RANGOON -- Burmese pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi declared her will
to continue the struggle against the country's military rulers, in an
interview with the Mainichi Shimbun on Friday.
"They are just nervous. They are just frightened. They're acting like
this because they are frightened," says Suu Kyi, the leader of the National
League for Democracy (NLD), in her first exclusive interview with a news
organization after the junta detained over 200 opposition activists.
"They just want to stop the conference and they want to stop democracy
because they don't want to give up power,"she said.
The NLD plans to hold a party conference starting Sunday to mark its
victory in abortive general elections in 1990, when the NLD took 392 of 485
contested seats.
"We can't ignore the results of the 1990 elections, and the government is
trying to ignore them but can't ignore them," said Suu Kyi. "We will go
ahead with the conference and we will do what we have to do."
"When I was released (from house arrest in July last year), I said nothing
has changed. I was released and that was all," the Nobel Peace Prize winner
said. "Now you can see I was right. This is not progress. This is going
backwards."
Suu Kyi appeared tense but showed no signs of exhaustion during the interview.
She criticized Japan and ASEAN countries for their "constructive
engagement" with Burma, a policy of strengthening trade ties and providing
economic assistance to promote the democratization of Burma.
"If the Japanese government says it (constructive engagement) works, show
us the proof, or some proof of development toward democracy. Constructive
engagement does not help us to achieve democracy in Burma." She urged Tokyo
to reconsider its policy.
Activists urge halt to aid
In response to the junta's crackdown on opposition activists, Burmese
pro-democracy organizations in Tokyo also called for an immediate halt to
Japanese economic assistance and investment.
Win Khet, chairman of the National League for Democracy Liberated Area,
urged the Japanese government to stop its assistance, including humanitarian
aid.
The government has granted a total of 1.6 billion yen for a nursing school
in Rangoon.
At a press conference held Friday at the Foreign Ministry, Win Khet said
there is no system to verify if aid granted by Japan is actually used for
Burmese in need. He gave as an example a welfare association that had
received a Japanese grant run by the wife of a high-ranking military official.
Aung Thu, secretary of Burma Youth Volunteer Association, also said at the
Tokyo press conference that the Burmese people do not like the fact that the
Japanese government and corporations are working with Burma's military rulers.
According to the Myanmar Investment Committee, Japanese private investment
in Burma reached about 107 million dollars during the first nine months of
1995. Japan is the seventh largest investor in Burma, following Britain,
Singapore, France, Thailand, the United States and Malaysia.
**************************************************
HUNDREDS OF ARRESTS IN BURMA BESIDES THE NLD MEMBERS
Released by ISBDA on May 27, 1996.
A Rangoon University teacher said that about 200 student activists have
been arrested by the authorities during the current crackdown against the
democratic forces of Burma. As these students are not the members of NLD,
the number of recent detainees reaches to at least a total of five hundred.
On May 24, two young monks were arrested in public because they were
holding pro-democracy placards at a bus-stop nearby Sule Pagoda.
Many of the NLD MPs and other detainees including monks were already
transferred to Insein Jail. Eyewitness could not identify the detainees
because their faces were covered by blankets.
Meanwhile, a rumor spreads in Rangoon that a violent clash broke out
between some students from Medical College No. 2 and a group of heavily
drunk SLORC soldiers at N. Okkalapa town.
***********************************
BURMANET : BRIEF BUSINESS REPORTS
May 27, 1996
Compiled by Burma Net from information provided by Mbeer.
Contents:
Thai banks in Burma (an attempt at creating news by SLORC)
Detailed overview of SLORC constitution.
Burma tourism article
Motor Car Expo
Dr. Sein Win calls on Japan to reconsider its policy on ODA
-------------------
THAI BANKS LOOK FORWARD TO JOINT VENTURES IN MYANMAR
Xinhua News Agency
Bangkok, may 27
Thai banks are looking forward to joint ventures with Myanmar counterparts,
according to tossatis roprasert, assistant vice-president and chief
representative for Bangkok bank's branch in Yangon. Myanmar is opening up its
banking industry to foreigners in a move likely to widen the industry's scope
from conventional deposit and lending services. Siam city bank plc on April 11
became the first Thai bank to reach an agreement with Yangon to set up a new
joint venture, the Myanmar may flower bank. Other thai banks are studying
similar plans, as 17 Myanmar banks are eligible to join forces with foreign
counterparts. Five of the six Thai banks with representative offices in Yangon
held discussions with the Myanmar finance ministry and the central bank last
week on joint investments and shareholding, said Somchai Srisampan, manager of
the Thai Farmers bank's representative office in Yangon. The five are the Thai
military bank, Krung Thai bank, the Thai Farmers bank, the bank of Ayudhya and
Bangkok bank.
**************************
THE COUNTRY ACTS TO FINE-TUNE THE CONCENTRATION OF POWER
HEADLINE: Myanmar works towards shaping its constitution
BYLINE: Tin Maung Maung Than
IN April 1992, Myanmar's ruling State Law and Order Restoration Council
(SLORC) announced that it would convene a meeting for formulating "the basic
principles for the drafting of a firm and stable Constitution". Subsequently, in
October, the National Convention Convening Commission (NCCC) was formed, being
chaired by the (then) Yangon Region Commander and composed of ranking military
officers and senior judicial and administrative officials.
The NCCC classified eight categories of delegates for the National Convention
(NC): nominees of political parties; representatives-elect; nationalities;
peasants; workers; intellectuals and intelligentsia; service personnel; and
other invited delegates. For the first category, each of the 10 existing
political parties which had contested the 1990 General Election was allowed five
nominees.
Six political parties were invited to send altogether 99 delegates from among
their elected representatives. All eight elected representatives which stood as
independents were included. Also invited were 215, 93 and 48 nominees
representing the nationalities, peasantry and workers, respectively, who were
selected by a hierarchy of state/division, township zone and township
supervision committees. Each 15-member selection committee comprised heads of
local government agencies and respected residents of the community concerned.
Forty-one delegates from the intellectual/intelligentsia category were
"prominent intellectuals" and "knowledgeable" persons. Their selection was
scrutinised by a committee led by the Director-General of the Government Office
and comprising heads of government organisations and selected members of the
intellectual/intelligentsia community.
The state service personnel group's 92 members were selected by selection
committees formed within the respective ministries and agencies. Of the eight
category's 57 delegates, 42 "invitees" were chosen from members of the ethnic
groups which had given up their armed struggle against the government, while
others were "experienced persons in political, economic, social and
administrative fields in the State". However, 86 delegates from the National
League for Democracy -a party which won 80 per cent of the seats in the 1990
General Election -left the NC in protest at the beginning of the plenary session
in November 1995 and were subsequently excluded for breaching the NC rules.
The National Convention commenced on Jan 9, 1993, guided by six objectives
envisioned by the NCCC as: non-disintegration of the state; non-disintegration
of national solidarity; perpetuation of sovereignty; flourishing of a "genuine
multiparty democracy"; "further burgeoning" of "justice, liberty and equality";
and enabling the military "to participate in the national political leadership
role of the future state".
Subsequently, 15 chapters for the constitution were spelt out and detailed
principles pertinent to each chapter were discussed at length by the
participants. Altogether 104 "fundamental principles" underlying the prospective
constitution were distilled by the National Convention Convening Work Committee
from the various proposals put forward during the proceedings and were later
prescribed by the NCCC as a basis for future deliberations under each chapter
heading. Though the NC has yet to reach a conclusion, the essential points
regarding the state structure, the legislature, the executive, and the role of
the military has been delineated as follows.
The state structure is based on a secular republic comprising seven "regions"
and seven "states". There will be "Union" territories (under central
government), a hierarchy of district, township, and village/ward under each
region or state, and self-administered territories for ethnic communities
whereby a distinct "national race" constitutes a majority within its boundaries.
In this regard, the NC had endorsed the establishment of self-administered areas
for Naga, Danu, Pa-O, Palaung and Kokang races and the Wa self-administered
region.
For the legislature, a bicameral parliament with a five-year tenure in the
form of the 440-seat Pyithu Hluttaw (House of Representatives) and the 224-seat
Amyotha Hluttaw (House of Nationalities) which together constitute the
Pyidaungsu Hluttaw (Union Parliament) is envisaged. There will also be a hluttaw
(provincial parliament) for each region or state. One- quarter of all seats in
the legislature is reserved for military representatives nominated by the armed
forces Commander-in-Chief (C-in-C).
In the executive branch, the head of state will be the President. The Union
Cabinet, comprising ministers and the attorney-general, will be appointed by the
President and its members need not be elected representatives. The Chief
Minister of the region or state government is also a presidential appointee.
Self-administered areas will be governed by "leading bodies" whose members will
be represented in the territorially relevant region or state government.
Administration at district and township levels will be by civil servants.
Administration of wards and village-tracts is by appointed personnel.
As for the military, it will enjoy complete autonomy with its C-in-C
designated as the supreme commander. Ministerial portfolios for defence,
security/home affairs, and border areas in the Union Cabinet are reserved for
military personnel nominated by the C-in-C, who will also nominate the deputy
ministers. Furthermore, co-ordination with the C-in-C is required to appoint
military personnel to any other minister/deputy-minister post. The assignment of
military personnel to leading bodies of self-administered areas is also the
C-in-C's prerogative. Moreover, there will be a provision for the supreme
commander to assume state power in a national emergency.
The President, whose parents must also be citizens, will play a crucial role
in the governance of the Myanmar state. The candidate must not only have a
minimum of 20 years continuous domicile in Myanmar but also satisfy the
requirement that the "President of the Union himself, parents, spouse,
children and their spouses" must not owe allegiance to or "be a subject of
foreign power or citizen of a foreign country" and shall not be "entitled to the
right and privileges of a subject or citizen of a foreign country". Another
condition that the person be "well acquainted with the affairs of State such as
political administrative, economics and military affairs" would rule out most
political figures.
The presidential election procedure is significant. The electoral college
comprises three groups from the Pyidaungsu Hluttaw: equal numbers of elected
representatives from regions and states; representatives "elected on the basis
of population"; and military representatives nominated by the C-in-C. Each group
shall elect one Vice-President who need not be an elected representative. The
President will then be chosen from among them by the entire electoral college
after scrutiny by a body composed of leaders and deputy leaders of the two
hluttaws. The unsuccessful candidates will assume the vice-presidencies for the
five-year term of office.
The wide-ranging powers of the Union President allow unprecedented control
over the executive branch. The president can designate ministries and appoint or
dismiss ministers, deputy ministers, attorney-general, auditor-general, as well
as members of the Union Civil Service Board. He can prescribe the ministries and
the number of ministers for the region or state government and also nominate the
respective chief ministers (from amongst elected representatives of
region/state).
The President can assign region/state ministers and chairmen of
self-administered areas/regions (nominated through the chief minister by the
respective leading bodies) in coordination with the relevant Chief Minister. All
such assignments must be confirmed by the respective hluttaw but the latter have
no right to reject the President's nominee provided the person satisfies the
Constitution's provisions.
Thus, the President and the armed forces C-in-C, between them, wield
considerable authority and all important government executives are ultimately
responsible to the President only. The political parties will face a situation
whereby the executive positions may be filled with personnel external to the
body politic.
Even when elected representatives are chosen to serve in the government they
have to forego their party affiliations and resign from the legislature. In this
way, the elected representatives' role will generally be confined to legislative
and deliberative functions and the raison d'etre of competitive politics, that
is, to form a government, will be obviated. It effectively de-links state power
from political competition and representation of voting constituencies.
Consequently, a corporatist state may evolve in which the ruling elite will be
insulated from electoral politics.
Currently, the successful conclusion of the NC, which would lead to the
actual drafting of Myanmar's future constitution according to the agreed-upon
principles, has become imperative. Meanwhile, the NC has opted for
constitutional principles, which emphasise the autonomy of the executive under
the leadership of the President and the authoritative dual role of the military
as a counterpoise to the apparent failings of politicians. This will result in
an unprecedented and unique constitution for the Union of Myanmar which is
different from the previous ones which, in contrast, were premised on
governance by elected representatives.
Tin Maung Maung Than is a Fellow at the Institute of Southeast Asian
Studies.
*****************************
DILEMMA OVER TRAVEL TO BURMA,
SUBJECT OF MAGAZINE ARTICLE, TO BE
Distribution: To business and travel editors
Published on tuesday, May 28
The dilemma over travel to Burma is the subject of a major twenty page
feature to be published in the June 1996 issue of Conde Nast Traveler magazine,
on newsstands Tuesday, May 28 nationwide, the magazine announced today.
"The Dilemma On the Irawaddy" is by Andrew Cockburn*, a Washington D.C.-based
journalist who is also a contributing editor at Vanity Fair magazine.
NEW YORK, May 25 He is currently writing a book about the trafficking to
other countries of the former Soviet Union's weapons.
Cockburn traveled to Burma in November 1995 to do the reporting for the
travel magazine's article.
Burma's State Law and Order Restoration Council (SLORC) dubbed 1996 a "Visit
Myanmar Year". (SLORC renamed Burma in 1989.) However, Nobel Laureate San Suu
Kyi argues that tourism revenues will advance no interests other than those of
the ruling junta. Her pro-democracy group's conference on Sunday, May 25 is the
current object of a major crackdown by SLORC.
For more information about the feature article this weekend or to arrange an
interview with Andrew Cockburn, please call Susan Soriano, Editorial Publicity
Manager, 212-880-2579, or Cockburn directly at 202-342-9488.
(*pronounced "CO-BURN")
CONTACT: Susan Soriano of Conde Nast Traveler, 212-880-2579
************************************
MOTOR CAR EXPO OPENS IN YANGON
Yangon, May 25;
A four-day Myanmar motor car expo, co-organized by Myanmar industrial
development committee and cp exhibition of Hong Kong, was inaugurated here this
morning. This is the first international motor car expo in Myanmar in recent
years. Over a dozen international firms from Indonesia, Singapore, Hong Kong,
Japan, South Korea and China displayed their products at the expo, which will
last from may 25 to 28. Myanmar motor car market has been dominated by
Japan-made cars.
*************************************
MYANMAR PREMIER-IN-EXILE URGES JAPAN TO RETHINK POLICY
Japan Economic Newswire
Kohei Murayama
Washington, May 24, Kyodo
Myanmar's government-in-exile urged Japan on Thursday to reconsider its
policy on extending official development assistance (ODA) so as to more
efficiently influence the ruling military junta in Yangon.
'The Japanese government should reconsider it very, very carefully,' Sein
Win, the prime minister-in-exile of the National Coalition Government of the
Union of Burma (Myanmar), said in an interview with Kyodo News.
Japan suspended ODA to Myanmar after a military coup in 1988 and limited its
aid to humanitarian needs. But shortly after the release of pro-democracy
leader Aung San Suu Kyi from house arrest last July, Japan partially lifted the
freeze and decided to offer grants-in-aid for programs such as nurse training.
'That's too generous and too early, and it's now time to reconsider it,' Sein
Win said in referring to arrests this week by the military regime of some 200
members of the National League for Democracy (NLD) led by Nobel Peace Prize
laureate Suu Kyi.
The United States and some other Western nations maintain sanctions by
cutting off official aid to Myanmar, while Japan and some Southeast Asian
nations are taking a policy of 'constructive engagement' with the junta.
'We are thankful that the Japanese government has issued some expressions of
concern and also we know that the Japanese ambassador in Rangoon (Yangon) is
trying to negotiate or mediate between Aung San Suu Kyi and the military,' said
Sein Win, a cousin of Suu Kyi.
'We would like Japan to be a mediator...but we also want Japan to be
impartial and it is too early to resume (official aid),' he said. 'Otherwise,
they (the military) are hoping for Japanese foreign aid and my opinion is that
the Japanese government should set some conditions.'
Noting that 80% of the current ODA to Myanmar comes from Tokyo, Sein Win
said, 'Japan has a great influence on the military in Rangoon.'
'The military hope for very much from Japan. They want all the aid not only
at the financial level, but also as a sign of their legitimacy,' he said. 'And
they hope that after all the aid, the Japanese business circles will jump in and
that will give them time to go their own way.'
Sein Win also blasted China, saying Beijing is selling arms to Myanmar instead
of cooperating with the global efforts to influence the military junta.
'It's having a negative effect on everything,' he said, noting that Chinese
arms exports to Myanmar have reached more than 1 billion dollars since 1988.
On the current situation in Myanmar, Sein Win said he is worried that the
military crackdown may 'escalate.'
Referring to the mass arrests prior to an NLD gathering planned by Suu Kyi
this weekend, he said, 'Primarily, it is to disturb or block the meeting. But
it could go further than that. Maybe they will take this as an excuse to crack
down further on the NLD party.'
The NLD won more than 80% of the parliamentary seats at stake in the May 1990
general election, but the junta has refused to hand over power.
Noting that four nonmembers of the parliament were also detained in this
week's roundup, Sein Win said, 'We think that it is more than to prevent this
conference.'
Sein Win also voiced concern over Suu Kyi. 'She said she would go ahead with
the conference...But the situation in Rangoon is very tense and they may arrest
her again,' he said. 'We can't exclude that possibility.'
Asked if that could lead to direct conflict with the military regime, Sein
Win said, 'Right now, the NLD and Suu Kyi are nonviolent. She doesn't want any
kind of confrontation.'
But even if the situation worsens, 'we can't exploit that kind of upheaval
again,' he said, referring to the 1988 pro-democracy uprising which the military
crushed, killing hundreds of civilians.
Sein Win said the exiled coalition government has some 20 activists abroad,
with two members at the Washington headquarters and other members in Thailand
and India.
Their activities at the Washington headquarters include lobbying the U.S.
government and the United Nations, and offering information to Myanmar by
sending newsletters sent through facsimile machines and other means and
broadcasting a short-wave radio program from Oslo for about an hour every day.
Funds are provided mainly through nongovernmental organizations, including
those in Canada, the U.S. and Norway.
'We would like to do more than what we're doing now and that depends on
financial power,' Sein Win said, lamenting a lack of funds.
*******************************
------------------------------------
BURMANET SUBJECT-MATTER RESOURCE LIST
BurmaNet regularly receives enquiries on a number of
different topics related to Burma. If you have questions on any of the
following subjects, please direct email to the following
volunteer coordinators, who will either answer your question
or try to put you in contact with someone who can:
Arakan/Rohingya/Burma volunteer needed
Bangladesh Border
Campus activism: zni@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Boycott campaigns: [Pepsi]
wcsbeau@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Buddhism: Buddhist Relief Mission:
brelief@xxxxxxx
Chin history/culture: plilian@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Fonts: tom@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
History of Burma: zni@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Kachin history/culture: 74750.1267@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Karen history/culture: Karen Historical Society:
102113.2571@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Mon history/culture: [volunteer needed]
Naga history/culture: Wungram Shishak:
z954001@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Burma-India border [volunteer needed]
Pali literature: "Palmleaf": c/o
burmanet@xxxxxxxxxxx
Shan history/culture: [volunteer needed]
Shareholder activism:
simon_billenness@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Total/Pipeline Dawn Star: cd@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Tourism campaigns: bagp@xxxxxxxxxx "Attn.
S.Sutcliffe"
World Wide Web: FreeBurma@xxxxxxxxx
Volunteering: christin@xxxxxxxxxx
[Feel free to suggest more areas of coverage]
------------------------------------------------------------
The BurmaNet News is an electronic newspaper covering Burma.
Articles from newspapers, magazines, newsletters, the wire
services and the Internet as well as original material are
published.
It is produced with the support of the Burma Information
Group
(B.I.G) and the Research Department of the ABSDF {MTZ}
The BurmaNet News is e-mailed directly to subscribers and is
also distributed via the soc.culture.burma and seasia-l
mailing lists. For a free subscription to the BurmaNet News,
send an e-mail message to: majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxx
For the BurmaNet News only: in the body of the message, type
"subscribe burmanews-l" (without quotation marks).
For the BurmaNet News and 4-5 other messages a day posted on
Burma issues, type "subscribe burmanet-l"
Letters to the editor, comments or contributions of articles
should be sent to the editor at: strider@xxxxxxxxxxx
******************************************************